Q&A With New York Giants Fan
You've probably already noticed his presence, but Ed Valentine (ETVal), who authors the solid NYG site Big Blue View, asked me if I was interested in exchanging a few questions about each other's respective teams and this Sunday's highly anticipated matchup. My answers to his questions should be available on his site tomorrow morning. Thanks to Ed for initiating this. And oh, real quick, we've built quite a reputation for ourselves Steelers fans with how we conduct ourselves and how knowledgable, chill and even-handed we are about the game. All of y'all have a played a part in it, but let's keep the bar as high as possible by avoiding the nonsense that often errupts on blogs. To the questions:
1) I liked your first question so much, I'm going to throw it right back at ya: Statistically the Giants offense and Steelers defense are right at the top of the league. How do you see this matchup unfolding? Do you think the Giants will have any sort of sustained success running the football against a rush defense that has been impenetrable for all of the decade?
BBV: I love this question, and I love this matchup. Sustained success? Maybe not. I respect the Steelers defense. I do think the Giants will find a way to pop a handful of good runs, and maybe one or two will break big. Why? Because the Giants can come at you with so many different styles of running backs. The big banger in Brandon Jacobs. The underrated speed guy in Derrick Ward. The slashing, quick tough to bring down Ahmad Bradshaw. If one guy can't get it done the Giants will keep probing and trying different guys until they hit a play or two -- that is what makes their run game so dangerous. Plus, they have a terrific line and an excellent fullback in Madison Hedgecock.
2) If my memory serves me correctly, I don't remember hearing much negative about Plexico Buress the last couple of years. Perhaps a minor thing or two, but similar to what happened when he left Pittsburgh, something about winning Super Bowls kicks in the prima donna in him. What's going on? Is he in the Giants long term plans?
BBV: Are you forgetting that Plax got himself suspended a couple of weeks ago for not showing up for practice and failing to call the team? Oh, and the shouting match last weekend where he apparently cursed at Tom Coughlin on the sidelines? Plax is a great player, and a great competitor on the field. He showed that last season, having a great year on one leg. He just signed a five-year contract, and the Giants want him around for the duration. His recent behavior tells me that won't happen, though. Eventually Burress and the Giants will tire of each other and they will have to move him.
BTSC Follow-up: Yes, I did read about the Plax suspension recently and the outburst on the sideline. Hence, the question :)
3) Tell us a little bit about your young defensive coordinator. Have you come to peace with the fact that this is likely the last year you'll be enjoying his services before he assumes the head coaching duties somewhere?
BBV: Don't say that, don't say that, DON'T SAY THAT! We are locking Steve Spagnuolo in a box and keeping him FOREVER! Seriously, I think Giants fans understand how lucky we are to have Spagnuolo, and know that he probably will be a head coach somewhere next season. If the Giants could somehow entice him to stay with an offer to take over for Tom Coughlin in a few years that would be great, but I don't see it happening. TC has three years left after this one, and we want him around (something we never thought we would say a year ago). So, we will have to come to terms with Spags being a short-timer.
4) Are the Giants still the team to beat in the NFL? Yes, I know they're the team to beat until somebody does it in the playoffs, but are they really the team to beat? I'm certainly willing to listen to an affirmative argument after what I've seen from them.
BBV: The answer is, yes, they are the team to beat. Will they still be the team to beat at the end of the regular season? I hope so. Fact is, they have an absolutely brutal schedule the rest of the season -- beginning this weekend. Pittsburgh, Dallas and Philly twice, Washington, Baltimore, Arizona, Carolina, Minnesota.
Who knows what will happen the next 10 weeks. Are the Giants good enough to repeat? I think they are good enough to have a chance, but so much changes week to week in the NFL it's impossible to say what shape they will be in come playoff time.
BTSC Followup: Ed, did you just refer to Dallas, Baltimore and Arizona as absolutely brutal opponents? Hehe, half kidding.
5) The Steelers special teams have been a lot better in 2008. There is nothing special about our special teams in terms of returns, but our coverage units have been much better than last year. Anything to worry about this weekend against the Giants return game?
BBV: Interesting question. Ahmad Bradshaw has been returning kickoffs, and he hasn't really broken loose yet. Last season he had several big returns and I know there are some coming eventually. He's too good and too dangerous not to break a return at some point. Hopefully, that will be this week. Domenik Hixon is a pretty good punt returner and has broken a couple of big returns so far this season. He also might see some action returning kickoffs. So, the Giants can be dangerous in the return game.
0 recs |
18 comments
|
Comments
Great Interview
Looking forward to the inverse questioning tomorrow.
One thing I have to say about the Giants, they are truly the only team I could love right now outside of the Steelers. A three phase running attack, workhorses in the trenches on both sides of the ball, balanced passing.
This team that is more than the sum of it’s parts. Watching their run last year was epic. They know how to pound the rock brutally and are balanced in every aspect of the game. As a Steelers fan, it’s hard to envy the way another organization is run, but I have some football envy of the NYG.
This should be an awesome game, regardless of the winner.
by BallsofSteel on Oct 23, 2008 2:27 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
my answers coming up in just a few minutes
by Blitzburgh on Oct 23, 2008 2:46 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Cool
I’m on the West Coast so I’ll be hanging around.
by BallsofSteel on Oct 23, 2008 2:54 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I feel the same way
but in reverse. I really like the Steelers (was rooting hard for you guys during the playoffs 3 years ago). I’ve also felt like the two franchises are connected in a way that none of the other 30 are, in that they are still owned by their original families, the Rooneys and the Maras, who to the best of my knowledge are pretty friendly with one another. It’s also hard to dislike a franchise that’s had less coaches during the entire Super Bowl era than the Raiders have had since 2004. Also, as a Notre Dame fan and slightly heftier than average guy, I always had a soft spot for Jerome Bettis.
by cjmulrain on Oct 23, 2008 9:33 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sound like a good guy. :)
Who doesn’t love the Bus?
by WolfpackSteelersFan on Oct 24, 2008 11:37 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Question for you all
Are you at all nervous about Plaxico having a huge game on Sunday?
I ask b/c the Giants have been lucky in recent years that they haven’t had a massively talented player who wore out his welcome then went to another team and became a star come back to play against them in recent years (maybe when Shockey comes into town, though he seems to be breaking down.) I ask because, as a Mets fan, it seems like every time we let a guy get away, he comes back and KILLS the Mets the next time they face him. And what with Plax coming off his suspension and blowup with Coughlin last weekend, I think a lot of Giants fans are banking on him having a chip on his shoulder this weekend, both at Coughlin and at the Steelers. Whether that means he sulks and catches 2 passes or decides to dominate the whole game and goes for over 100 yards, we don’t know, but that’s just the nature of Plaxico.
by cjmulrain on Oct 23, 2008 9:38 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
i woulndt be surprised if plax is highlighted in this game plan
With Bryant McFadden out, I can see the Giants trying to force the ball to Plax, particuarly after last week. Manning probably wants to simmer him the F down, and I wouldnt be shocked if he looks his way more so than usual. That could be scary. Plax is that talented. We’ll see, but I dont think we’ll see him break off multiple huge plays. But I could see a 8 or 9 catch for 90-110 yard performance with a TD or two. He’ll be up for this one. bigtime. He’s a gamer like that, though I must say I’ll be interested to see what happens if he gets shut out completely. Is it too late for Plax to do his best to send the NYG down the same path as the Giants???? haha
by Blitzburgh on Oct 23, 2008 10:00 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
lol
actually they were the one team i felt a bit reserved dogging there :) at least if that game was in glendale.
by Blitzburgh on Oct 23, 2008 10:36 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I know, I know
Just gotta give you a hard time.
by cgolden on Oct 23, 2008 12:12 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
For once
this year the Cardinals are actually a team to watch this year. I am a Warner fan so I wish them luck, except against us, of course.
by giant fan since 57 on Oct 24, 2008 6:15 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
dallas
if anybody would care to wager with me about dallas and making the playoffs, im right here. they aint going.
by Blitzburgh on Oct 23, 2008 10:36 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Schedule
I listed that schedule as a whole — that stretch is very difficult. And yes, two games with the Cowboys — who will be talented and desperate — are brutal for the Giants. As for Arizona, Giants never play well against them.
by Ed Valentine on Oct 23, 2008 11:02 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
dont matter if
Romos not back til nov 16th at earliest. at least so he says. If they are 4-7 or 5-6, or maybe even 6-5 before he comes back, its still going to be uphill sledding to get in. Giants and Skins are more complete teams with better coaching, TB and CAR are both legit in the South, and it looks like one of the NFC North teams (CHI or GB) will have a shot at a WC with either 8, 9, or 10 wins. Nothings given for Dallas this year. That loss to StL hurts their NFC record which may ultimately be the difference. I can’t see them being more than a 9 or 10 win team this year. Tops.
by Blitzburgh on Oct 23, 2008 11:29 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Good answer to the first question, ETVal. It’s hard to dominate 3 different running backs with different styles. Whenever we play the Chargers, we kill Tomlinson, but Turner whips us.
Interesting thoughts on Plax, too. I think we’ll have Ike shadow him all day.
charity standing orders
by BadMaafala on Oct 23, 2008 11:37 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Likewise we tend to be worried about playing the jags. Their dwarfish running back usually ends up killing us. Actually, they both usually end up killing us.
Not this year though.
by steelguy99 on Oct 23, 2008 12:23 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs

by 

















