Remembering the Flip Side: Steelers Win by a Field Goal in Overtime
As a sequel to Fahey's excellent recount of 2002, there is another playoff game that should also be remembered between these two franchises. Thirteen years before the Oscar in Music City, on the last day of the 1980s decade, it was the Steelers who came out on top of an overtime thriller with a field goal against the Houston Oilers, predecessors to the Tennessee Titans.

Many have said that 1989 was Chuck Noll's finest year in coaching. With very little talent, the Steelers opened the 1989 campaign by getting obliterated by the Cleveland Browns, 51-0, at three Rivers Stadium no less. The next game they lost to the Bengals, 42-10. Two games into the season, Pittsburgh had been outscored 93-10.
Enter Emperor Chaz. After the Bengals' game Noll spoke to the team and explained the inner workings of a swimming pool. He talked about how the chemicals all worked together to perform different tasks in harmony. He then compared that swimming pool to the human mind and all the chemical reactions involved. The players were indeed intrigued, but clueless as to how this had anything to do with a season that was down 93-10. Noll was not concerned about the psyche of his team; he was concerned about the media contaminating that psyche. He was concerned that the players would let external harpoons invade the minds of the players. He told them such. The moral of the story, he concluded, was "Don't you dare let anyone piss in your pool."
Vintage Noll. This rag-tag bunch of underdogs won nine of their next 14 games, including a revenge win at Cleveland. The Steelers sneaked into the playoffs and were dispatched to Houston to play the explosive Oilers led by Warren Moon. The Oilers, for those who might remember, had mastered the spread offense and had a potent passing attack. The Steelers were a seven-point underdog.
Pittsburgh's Jerry Olsavsky blocked an Oilers' punt early in the game and soon after rookie Tim Worley's nine-yard jaunt gave the Steelers a quick 7-0 lead. Noll, along with defensive coordinator Dave Brazil and defensive backs coach John Fox (whose Carolina Panther's are now 11-3), devised a game plan that allowed Moon to dink and dunk, but not get into the end zone. The two teams exchanged six field goals and into the fourth quarter, and the Steelers still led 16-9.
Steelers quarterback, Bubby Brister, was a tough but ineffective leader. Completing only 15 of 33 passes for 127 yards, the Steelers relied, as they had done so often back yonder, on a running game that grinded out 177 yards and lots of clock. In the fourth quarter, the Oilers finally broke through the duct tape and bobby pins. Moon got hot and hit Ernest Givens for two touchdown passes, all but sealing the Steelers' doom.
Enter Merril Hoge, who like Olsavsky, Brister and so many others, probably brought a lunchpail to the Astrodome. The Oilers could not stop Hoge on the Steelers' last gasp and with just 46 ticks remaining, Hoge burrowed into the end zone to silence the stunned Houston faithful. Somehow we got that game into overtime. Houston, with regained composure, was marching into Steeler territory when halfback Lorenzo White lost the handle. The omnipresent Rod Woodson dropped on the loose ball and suddenly it was the Steelers who were at midfield.
More Hoge. Even Tim Worley, a first-round bust out of Georgia, chipped in with 54 yards. But it was Hoge's last carry, putting him at exactly 100 yards on the day (just 17 carries), that placed the ball on the 33-yard line and set up a Gary Anderson field goal try. He was perfect. If the goal posts were just three feet wide, Anderson would have still converted. It would be Charles Henry Noll's final playoff victory, and a sweet one indeed. Pittsburgh 26, Houston 23.
Comments
the next game
More evidence of Noll’s great coaching and the 1989 Steelers’ toughness: after that thrilling OT win in Houston, the Steelers traveled to Denver to face the AFC’s top seed. Everyone expected a big Broncos win, but Hoge stepped up yet again with 120 yards rushing and a TD, Brister chipped in with a TD pass to Louis Lipps, and Anderson added 3 field goals to put Pittsburgh up 23-17. Unfortunately, John Elway led the Broncos over 70 yards for the winning TD with just over 2 minutes left in the game. I was 11 years old at the time, and I remember being disappointed by the loss, but so proud to be a fan of the toughest, grittiest, best-coached team in the NFL. And I still am.
by nycsteeler on
Dec 19, 2008 8:59 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
That game is in my top 10 most painful losses
Even after the Elway drive, the Steelers had a drive of their own, needing just a field goal. A guy named Mark Stock, a rookie never to play again, dropped a beautiful soft pass right at his chest, facing the quareterback, across the 50. Anderson was ready to win it, and a guy named Stock killed the game. The Steelers would have gone to Cleveland, where they won earlier in the season.
Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history
by maryrose on
Dec 19, 2008 9:13 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
"The Heavenly Hit"
Years into the aftermath of the “Immaculate Reception” this game was one of the most unthinkable playoff victories in Steelers history. This team did get outscored 92-10. I remember there was very little hope around Pittsburgh in 89.
Making it to the playoffs cemented Brister’s status as a winner to many Steelers fans. The playoff game at Houston seemed unwinnable but we cheered anyway. It seemed like the whole game we were waiting for the inevitable L and when Moon led the Oilers to the late tying TD it seemed in the bag for Houston.
At midfield in OT Woodson came on like a torpedo separating ball carrier from ball. He then recovered the ball and set the Steelers up on the Houston side of the 50 where “The Machine” Gary Anderson began his legend and hit that kick. Myron Cope (always the marketing genius) dubbed Woodson’s play “The Heavenly Hit” and I still have the picture sent to me by Steelers DIgest of Anderson with his arms high in the air after victory. Great game in Steelers lore and great post as usual MaryRose.
When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen
by 5020 on
Dec 19, 2008 10:03 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I remember that Cleveland game. It was my first year in college and I was going to a school in Cleveland. I had to endure all the nimrods up there giving me crap the whole game….
by vin2k on
Dec 19, 2008 10:48 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
This is the first game I can remember watching
I was 7 years old and thought that 50 yards was awfully far for that little guy named Gary to have to kick a ball.
Great memory. If I remember correctly, the Steelers lost to Denver the next week. Not that it mattered. The 49ers owned that year.
by JHolmes on
Dec 19, 2008 12:08 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Memories
I’ll always remember this game. I watched it with my twin bro’ of 15 years and I’m sure he remembers it like I do. The drama of the win was enormous. After the loss to Denver, I remember that “Inside the NFL” on HBO profiled Hoge in particular with a kind of “we’ll be back” theme. The only quarrel I have is the characterization of Bubby – “Bubby Brister, was a tough but ineffective leader.” Bubby was, is and always shall be the freakin’ man.
by rushthequarterback on
Dec 19, 2008 12:26 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I think she meant
ineffective on the day. 15 of 33 passing isn’t good.
by JHolmes on
Dec 19, 2008 3:56 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
6
With you rush. I always thought that Cowher’s first and biggest mistake was choosing 14 over Brister as the starting QB in his initial 92 season.
Brister won three in a row at the end of 92 securing the #1 seed for the 11-5 Steelers. After a bye, Cowher installed 14 back into the lineup and O’Dufus promptly laid a playoff egg (his first) and lost to Buffalo 24-7. With Brister as QB and leader, Cowher would have won the ring between 92-95 that he didn’t get with Blitzburgh I.
When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen
by 5020 on
Dec 19, 2008 4:18 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I think
that was Glanville’s last game coaching the Oilers as well. And I’ve already mentioned my dislike for the guy, but I did crack up every time I saw him … walking around in all black ala Johnny Cash & actin like Jerry Lee Lewis … such a character. The kind of character you just don’t find on the sidelines anymore. If only he didn’t coach his defense to straight-up cheat…
Bubby was one of the good ones. He was like Bradshaw Junior … he just didn’t have the same kind of team around him that Terry had.
Nice write up! A good reminder of the history the Steelers have had with Houston/Tennessee, and the dualities necessary to keep things interesting.
by Fahey on
Dec 19, 2008 4:06 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
What a game!
I remember that game as well. I hated the Oilers and considered Glanville the worst kind of scum. They had swept the Steelers that year, so getting the win was awesome.
by WolfpackSteelersFan on
Dec 19, 2008 4:27 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
That season was the first season of football that I can remember - I was 7 years old
I remember coming home from church with my dad on the first game of the year, dad eagerly turning on the TV to check the score of the steeler game and . . . 51-0 Browns! That is my first conscious memory of football – a 51-0 loss to the F-ing Browns.
We actually taped that Oilers game. What I remember most is that they showed a replay of Noll’s reaction to Anderson’s game winner – and he just calmly tracked the ball in the air and then took off his head set. That was it. It’s a shame Worley had to fumble away the Denver game.
by houksyndrome on
Dec 20, 2008 6:05 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs












