Behind the Steel Curtain: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: The Record of Wrongs: Vanderbilt Commodores

Mike Tomlin: 'People Get Too Preoccupied With Style Points...'

Lots of good thoughts on the game in the post game thread as well as the numerous fanposts written since the Steelers won their fourth straight this afternoon against the Dallas Cowboys. A few more from me.

* Let's start with the defense. You have to give credit to Jason Garret for finding ways to use Tashard Choice effectively against our imposing defense. The rookie from Georgia Tech had 150+ yards from scrimmage, including 88 yards on 23 carries. The 88 yards were the most by a running back against Pittsburgh this year. On consecutive possessions to start the 3rd quarter, the Cowboys scored a TD then a FG. The drives were 8 and 7 plays long, covering 67 and 57 yards respectively. Our top rated defense certainly didn't look top rated at that point. To me, the drives rekindled old memories of the 2006 defense - a good defense, but certainly not spectacular. Was this supposedly great defense being exposed on a big stage finally? 

Nope. First of all, bright coordinators, and even not so bright ones, typically discuss something at halftime that they think will work to start the second half. They did that. Secondly, and quite simply, teams put together drives from time to time. Even the Bengals embarked on a stunning 10+ play 90 yard drive for a TD with Ryan freakin Fitzpatrick at the helm. And thirdly, they had the wind in the third quarter. Nothing disturbing at all about what transpired. The reality is, we'll probably have to continue converting turnover opportunities at a fairly high clip to advance deep in the playoffs based on what we know about the offense, but to me, this game managed to enhance my appreciation for this Steelers unit. Holding the Cowboys often explosive offense to just 10 points certainly made me think no worse of them.

Anyway, back to those series real quickly to conclude. One of the bigger plays of the game was James Farrior's 8 yard sack of Tony Romo on 3rd and goal from the Steelers 7.  That sack not only killed the Cowboys long string of success on offense and forced on the FG team, it was absolutely it for the day for the Cowboys in terms of offensive production or ball control. They would manage just one more TO completion following their goal line stand, and one meaningless first down before turning it over on downs to seal it. The point is, even when teams find a little prolonged success during the course of a game against us, no time to panic.

* Obviously creating five takeaways per game the past two weeks is a an embarrassment of riches, but if we can continue to get two or three per game we're going to be so tough to beat.

* I really liked that Mike Tomlin called a timeout after the Cowboys ran the ball on 1st down with less than two minutes to go and the game tied. You can't measure these kinds of psychological things, but obviously Tomlin plays to win the game and believes in his guys. Similar logic applies to his decision to go for it on 4th and goal from the 1.

(BTW, I got multiple emails from NFC East fans that hate the Cowboys basically saying 'I can't believe Tomlin didn't kick a FG there. What an idiot).

I like the decision though. 12 play drive with multiple 3rd down conversions. Too bad Willie Colon slipped on the play and totally whiffed his guy.

* Speaking of Colon and the rest of the offensive line. Not a good day at the office from them. There have been a few bad in-game stretches since Darnell Stapleton took over for Kendall Simmons, but mostly the line has played average, not terrible, since then. Today was closer to terrible than average. We mustered only 70 yards on 26 carries. When we had to get a push along the goal line, we couldn't. Anyway, give the Cowboys a ot of credit for the confusion they created. They were physical and fast all day, and up front particularly, they had the upper hand against our line.

It's worth noting though that like the rest of the guys on offense, the line did their job when we were finally starting to move the ball with a sense of urgency and efficiency. Unlike in the Giants game when things fell apart in a hurry with our offensive line, they rallied at just the right time to assist in the win.

* The TD pass to Heath Miller was really a beautifully thrown ball. And to me personally, it was the kind of play that told me Ben is 'back'. By 'back' I mean no longer skittish and rattled in the pocket. He had the same intensity of pressure barreling towards him earlier in the year as he did on that TD throw. But at times earler in the season, he failed to just trust his instincts of where and how to throw that pass. Ben let it go before Heath was even close to breaking out of his route and it had -just- the right amount of air under it. Heath caught it in perfect stride and had the angle on the defender to the pylon.

* Ben's shoulder seems to be doing fairly well too. He threw several nice passes in the 3rd and 4th quarters in tricky wind conditions. The deep ball into the wind to Santonio on 3rd and 16 was gorgeous. We were stuffed on the goal line of course, but that one play gave us a desperately needed injection of adrenaline and hope. God knows the offense was stuck in neutral, if not reverse, up until that point.

* In the last four games, our defense has 11 sacks, 13 takeaways and only given up 43 points.

* I've really felt like Santonio was going to make somthing happen in the punt return game if he continued to get opportunities. I heart Mewelde Moore just fine back there. The ball security he provides is priceless, but it's been Holmes who has shown the ability to at least get close to breaking one. The timing of his big return against Dallas was so huge. Dallas got a little breathing room when they got a first down as I previously mentioned after the goal line stand. But we then forced them to punt. It was a low line drive punt that Holmes brazenly scooped up off the bounce with a defender in his face. By grabbing it in stride without bobbling it at all, Holmes got by the Cowboys gunner and had open space and a slew of blockers ahead of him. We only gained two yards on our three play series, but his 35 yard return already put us in FG position. Spikey clanked home a 44 yarder and we were within 7 and in clear possession of the game's momentum.

* I felt good about Reed's chances on that kick. Tough conditions, but Jeff doesn't miss twice! Period. Also, anybody else hear the sound of the goalpost when a ball rattles it. Cool.

* One last thing on Holmes. This is a kid with lots of heart. The kind of guy we want in our organization if you ask me. He's not the shiniest apple of the bunch, but he wants to be a great football player and it shows out there. He plays with much of the same bravado and confidence as a Terrell Owens without the lame theatrics when things aren't going his way. Wasn't Holmes declared by us and the national media as a breakout player waiting to happen this year? Did we hear anything from him earlier in the year when he wasn't involved much in the offense while we struggled? Nope. Guys like him don't fall off trees, and while he may not be the prototypical elite #1 type WR we greedily may want, he's got elite talent and far better toughness than people are willing to give him credit for.

* Ha, I guess the race for Defensive Player of the Year didn't get any clearer after this week. 4 straight games with a pick for Polamalu! That's 7 for the year, best in the NFL. Credit the dude with 7 tackles and 2 assists as well. James Harrison meanwhile forced another fumble and added his 15th sack to his resume. He too had 9 total tackles like Polamalu. In my mind, the race is between these two guys for the league's top defensive honors.

* Props to the unsung heroes again. William Gay played well. Travis Kirschke's sack in the fourth quarter was huge.

* Just two penalties for ten yards today. I dunno, maybe we should try to get away with holding more often if this is going to be the alternative offensively :)

* Dallas punter Sam Paulesco actually had a better day statistically than Mitch Berger. Paulesco averaged 40 yards on four punts, whereas Berger only averaged 32.8 on 6 punts. Jeez, typing that I realize just how bad that really is, wind or not, for a punter in the National FOOTBALL League. Anyway, I was going to say though that Paulesco's last two punts played a big role in our comeback. The first one returned by Holmes for 35 yards was a 42 yard punt, but it was a total line drive that gave the coverage units no time to get down the field. His 4th and final punt was a 23 yard shank into the wind that gave us the ball back near midfield even though the Cowboys started their drive on the 40 yard line thanks to Reed kicking it out of bounds. 

Moral of the story? There are many, but that's also my point - these games come down to so many small things.

That's what Mike Tomlin talks about when he said 'this was a beautiful football game'. He manages 53 players and a slew of coaches. At the end of the day, nearly every player and certainly every coach with in-game decision making responsibilities did something positive to help win the game. The offense showed up just in time, thanks to the offensive line finally saying enough is enough and manning up for the fourth quarter. The defense went from bend but don't break to thoroughly impregnable for the last four series of the game. Jeff Reed had his ups and downs. Special teams again covered well and Gary Russel and Santonio Holmes provided sparks of varying degrees in the return game. And the main attraction Ben Roethlisberger got to do what he does best - engineer late comebacks and do just enough to help his team win. And perhaps most importantly, he was reminded by the sweet outcome that protecting the football was the difference between winning and losing.

NFL games are basically decided down the stretch. We've shedded some of the early and mid season demons to close the door on several tightly contested games during this recent four game streak. We'll see if it yields dividends in the immediate future, but one can almost gurantee that we'll be in a few more close ones, be it against Baltimore, Tennessee, or a playoff opponent should we make the dance.

 

P.S. The Pittsburgh Steelers are 10-3 in 2008 and 20-9 since Mike Tomlin became the head coach. The style points may be lacking, but the bottom line results are not. And this year, we're getting it done against some of the league's best along the way. Next big test? The playoffs. I, for one, think the program, so to speak, is in very, very capable hands.

 

0 recs  |  Comment 20 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Resilient

I was impressed by how they never really thought they were out of this game. I certainly did at 13-3 with our offense at a certain standstill. The defense did finally seem to be showing some give against a very good offense, but when you look at the game as a whole, the defense played lights out against a top notch offense in a playoff atmosphere. The TD pass to T.O. could not have been defended any better by Ike Taylor if you ask me. He stayed with him, and it took about 11 seconds of pocket scrambling and a perfect pass to score a TD on this defense. Impressive.

Our line is going to cost us a ring. No doubt in my mind. I think we all know which line. I know Dallas stepped it up on defense but we have never really been able to run the ball with any authority this year. Every now and then we break a nice 6 yard run, or maybe a 20 yard sprint, but thats mixed in with a slew of runs for no gain. Willie Colon seems to screw up more than any lineman i have ever seen. I am pretty much done with him at this point. Thats a budget right tackle and we are paying for it. On the other hand it seems like Max Starks is actually playing pretty solid. How far we go in the playoffs depends on how much push our line can muster up. Ben really makes them look bad at times though. Ben turns a decent 3 sack performance by the line into a 5-8 sack day easily by just extending plays. We live and we die by it.

I have been waiting on Holmes to break out all year. Just like you Blitz, i thought this guy was going to step into an elite status this year but i think his chances were stumped by Bens shoulder, a lack of a legit running threat, and minimal time for deep routes. No running game=no play action=no Hawaii for Santonio. Glad to see him make some plays today though.

Mike Tomlin grows on me more and more. I love his intensity and fire for the game. You look over at Wade Phillips and it makes you want to eat a ham sandwich and take a nap. Tomlin is hitting flying chest bumps after scores and grabbing face masks to scream into. That man loves his job, and his team.

Great win because i truly can`t stand the Cowboys, and to rip a crucial game away from them puts a smile on my face for the rest of the week. Until i start thinking about the Ravens defense. Then my smile turns into more of a who farted look.

by SteelerDomination on Dec 8, 2008 4:58 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

nice measured thoughts from u as usual

1) Resilients a great word – I like that about this team. I wrote in the game day threat post that I thought we’d know right away if we were going to struggle all day. We surely did, but that didnt stop us or Big Ben from putting the past behind them and coming through when given one final opportunity late in the game.

2) Part of that’s on Tomlin. Surely the team knows and even embraces the fact that they are going to be in lots of these dogfights where the winner often emerges in ugly fashion. If the players played with the same sense of discouragement that the fans had, theyd get mauled out there.

3) I just don’t want people to give up on Holmes because the reasons you listed all are very accurate imo in helping explain why his #s have been pedestrian. It’s not an attitude or weed smoking issue or anything stupid like that. Product of circumstances and there’s 31 other teams that would love to have him. He’s still an incredibly vital weapon for our offense. I hate to think how anemic it might be if we didnt hvae him out there for defenses to contend with.

4) Perhaps I’ll see if theres ever been some historical precedent of a team winning a SB that has run the ball so poorly and given up as many sacks as we have. Just to (hopefully) inform us that it’s possible to do. I hope you’re not right, but it’s certainly reasonable expectation. At the least, I think Ben’s going to have to have a couple of magical games avoiding pressure when we get to the playoffs.

by Blitzburgh on Dec 8, 2008 5:22 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Yes sir!

What a great day to be a steelers fan. Our offensive woes are not news, but it’s good to see we are still able to pull out games. Just think where we might be in February if our offense gets any kind of consistency.

by sn0wballz on Dec 8, 2008 9:13 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

And where we’ll be if it doesn’t.

by Jonny B. on Dec 8, 2008 10:06 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

hehe

Yeah I was gonna say. I dont think the offense is going to ‘come around’ – at least not in the way we might have dreamed of.

But what we still have is a QB who relishes big moments and plenty of capable play makers. Of course it starts and ends with the line, but I think it’s also important to remember that it was really freakin cold and windy out there. It may just be let the prettiest ugly team win! And I think we may be that.

by Blitzburgh on Dec 8, 2008 10:26 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

+1

Well said Blitz. Steelers Football was never about Style points. Tomlin isn’t concerned about the stat sheet, our yards per play or getting our receivers or backs enough touches. This guy is about which team has the guts to win a slug fest. Its not innovative, its not pretty. But when it comes down it to it, its Steelers Football.

And although I often hurl things at the TV while watching our offense play, I do have to give them credit. They are tough and they are out there gutting out victories. In an offense we thought was STACKED with weapons – I don’t think we have a single pro-bowler this year. Not one. That’s fine – I still like watching those guys battle. I still like watching Big Ben pick himself up and get the job done. Let Drew Brees throw for 5000 yards. I would rather have Ben pick up 4th quarter comeback number 16. Save the style points for gymnastics. This is football.

by SteelerBuddha on Dec 8, 2008 1:05 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Always Grade them "A" for effort

Just think we should be getting more given the talent level (except on O-line of course).

by Jonny B. on Dec 8, 2008 3:07 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Physicality

The mind set that Tomlin instills (or continued) with this team wins games. From his first training camp, in which he went a little overboard, to Sun. game the common thread is being physical. How many Cowgirls laid on the ground injured after plays? I lost count! How many times did Ben absorb the big hit to complete the pass? How long did Nate lay on the ground? Exactly. It is disheartening to hit someone with your best shot and have them keep on coming, and that is exactly what this team does. It doesn’t show up in a box score, it won’t win you a fantasy game but this is a MANS GAME! Thank you Mr. Rooney for your excellent coaching hires, your hand OFF approach and your class. We are a spoiled fan base and should be thankful for what we have every day regarding this organization. And people wonder why we are such a loyal group of fans……

I wasn't hired for my disposition!

by Burgernazi on Dec 8, 2008 10:54 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

The best part

was that they played “Renegade” twice. After the Dallas goal line stand they started celebrating a little too much for the Steelers liking. So, some genius on the stadium sound crew decided to go to unchartered territory and play the song again. This time they got a much louder response and a much better response from the Steelers D.

by PensFan024 on Dec 8, 2008 12:42 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

Unsung heroes

I have to say our secondary (I’m not going to include Polamalu b/c we all know he played well) came up with a couple big plays. Ike did a good job covering TO during the whole game, as evidenced by TO’s post-game yelling, and on that interception he played it perfectly. Townsend obviously came up big, even though the throw wasn’t great. Finally McFadden had a really nice run stop in the 3rd quarter. On that play, I think it was Choice on a pitch, I saw a Steeler stop him dead in his tracks, and while I was expecting someone like Harrison or Farrior to be the tackler, I see #20 pop up.

by WPIALkid22 on Dec 8, 2008 3:12 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

weather

i didn’t ping Jeff Reed on the missed FG, the wind was crazy yesterday.

i did give big kudos to Santonio and BB for the hookup in same winds.

loved the statement that “nearly every player and certainly every coach with in-game decision making responsibilities did something positive to help win the game”

off topic, but… does anyone know the status of the WR that had his knee twisted from the tackle (Nate?)

by BoiseSteeler on Dec 8, 2008 3:47 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

One more thing that popped into my pea-brain...

For long time fans, we all know that being down by 10 points at the start of the 4th used to be par for the course, it happened alot to us. Sometimes we came back, sometimes we lost. But the Steelers NEVER panicked, and no matter how good or poor our team was that year, noone ever gave up. not the defense, offense, or fans. And it was the blue-collar effort til the final whistle that kept our respect for the team.

Anyways, it is interesting to hear the TV heads talking about how the Cowboys ‘blew the lead’ in the 4th. I disagree. We are used to being down 10 in the 4th. We were against the wind in the 3rd (and with the wind in the 4th). We don’t panic. The Cowboys did panic and unravel a bit. And our defense rocks.

Troy was quoted somewhere last week as saying that the job of the defense is to disrupt and score points. The job of the offense is to manage the clock. Pretty much summed everything up for this game for me. :-)

Looking forward to a major slugfest in Baltimore. Predicting Steelers 9, Baltimore 3

by BoiseSteeler on Dec 8, 2008 4:02 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

found the article

http://www.post-gazette.com/pg/08340/932934-66.stm

“You always want to score,” Polamalu said. "On defense, we’re probably more concerned with scoring than the offense. They’re more concerned with controlling the clock.

“Our mind-set is to stop them from scoring or score whenever you get the ball. I think that’s everybody mind-set on this defense.”

by BoiseSteeler on Dec 8, 2008 4:07 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

i like this sentence a lot

Anyways, it is interesting to hear the TV heads talking about how the Cowboys ‘blew the lead’ in the 4th. I disagree. We are used to being down 10 in the 4th. We were against the wind in the 3rd (and with the wind in the 4th). We don’t panic. The Cowboys did panic and unravel a bit. And our defense rocks.

Very true. We did not panic. They did. It’s a fairly obvious point but I haven’t heard anyone say it as simply as that and youre absolutely right (as Troy Aikman might say)

Troy: Yeah Boise, you’re absolutely right. [Insert 150 word redundancy that could have been left at ’you’re absolutely right’.]

I wasnt very coherent in my post, but when I said Ben was ‘back’, that’s part of it. I think he’s jjust back to being his normal confident self back there. He’s still making some bad decisions with his mental clock in the pocket imo, but I think he’s mostly over the total rut he was in last month. I really think we should go to the no huddle a bit more frequently. We seem to be at our worst when we’re snapping the ball lesiurely late in the play clock. We’re a lot better with a sense of panic about us.

by Blitzburgh on Dec 8, 2008 4:27 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

thx for the props

and re: BB… i really liked his post game interview where he said that he was baiting ___________ (can’t remember who) defensive back all night with looks and pump fakes, then let is loose in the 4th to Santonio. Love that he is looking at the entire game as a chess match, and setting the opposition up for traps late in the game. Maturity. Love it.

and yah, Ben is back from a confidence/maturity/decision standpoint. (or at least coming back) Sure, he’ll have moments, but he doesn’t have the ‘deer in headlights’ look that he had for awhile. The 4th gave him an opportunity to step up and shine, and it’s great that the team met his energy and determination to jumpstart the offense.

and +1 on the no-huddle. let’s do it some more!

by BoiseSteeler on Dec 9, 2008 4:04 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I agree

The cowgirls didn’t give this game away.

The Steelers TOOK THAT GAME!!!!

Ripped away and ate it for lunch!!!!! So many news reports on this game were that the Steelers were being outplayed the whole way. Please…..if they were being soooooooOoOOooOo outplayed why was the score what it was? Down by 10??? Big deal.

I keep reading and hearing doubts about this team…but this team FIGHTS.

They’ve got skills, class, determination….these things give them a chance to be champions…..just as much or more than any other team.

Who is really sooooo much better anyway? The Giants are the defending champs, so we’ll say ONE team is a bit better. The Titans haven’t won anything yet….so until they do, I have no reason to think they are so awesome.

We’ll see on the field in a couple weeks.

by Ragnar808 on Dec 8, 2008 9:55 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments

- Didn’t you downplay the importance of turnovers last week in response to a post of mine where I stated that a truly great defense forces turnovers and I mentioned that the Steelers defense has been great in almost all categories this season except for that one? Now you are mentioning how many turnovers our defense is creating recently. Hmmm……

I’m just messin’ with ya. ;)

We’re all rooting for the same team after all.

- Interesting that you mentioned Dallas’ punter. It’s interesting because Dallas also lost their starting punter this year (against the Cardinals) and had to find a backup. It hurt them this week, much like our punting problems have hurt us this year. I have developed a stronger appreciation for punters this season.

- Polamalu has indeed had a hell of a year. I think most Steeler fans know that. But I don’t hear too much national talk about him for DPOY. Even the local media don’t talk about Pola in terms of DPOY like they do Harrison. I guess Harrison may be having the better year, but I think the gap is relatively small. Let’s look at some (superficial) analysis:

Harrison has 15 sacks and 7 forced fumbles. He is 1.5 sacks off the league lead in sacks (Porter 16.5) and he leads the league in forced fumbles (3 players with 5).

Polamalu has 7 interceptions. That leads the league. Two of those interceptions against Phi and SD are highlight reel worthy. He also has 16 passes defensed, which is 9th in the league and leads all safeties (Ed Reed 12).

Harrison is more than just about the sacks. He makes plenty of tackles (60), including 3 tackles for loss and even plays on special teams at times.

Polamalu is more than just about the interceptions. He also makes plenty of tackles (47), including 5 tackles for loss.

Harrison has a safety and an interception.

Polamalu has a scooped fumble for a td. (Oh wait a minute, an incorrect ruling negated that in the SD game.)

I could go on, but that’s the meat of the argument. At least that’s my opinion.

by steeler1275 on Dec 9, 2008 12:23 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

See the Harrison for DPOY Fanpost

We all go crazy in-depth with this stuff there.

"Damnit mom! You almost ran over Greg Lloyd!"

at an autograph signing back in 95. He walked out in front of our minivan, and my mom almost hit him. He apologized.

by PA ARMY OFFICER on Dec 9, 2008 9:02 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Punting and ST

Just thinkning about how stinky our punts have been this year and how it hasn’t killed us. It makes me appreciate the coverage guys that much more.

by SCSteeler on Dec 9, 2008 12:28 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the SIX-time world champion Steelers.

"Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history."

Art Rooney Jr.

"Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Start posting about the Steelers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Comcast NFL RedZone Moments from SB Nation

Music City Miracles
Tennessee Titans Red Zone Report
Bleeding Green Nation
Comcast NFL Red Zone stat of the week - Something doesn't have to give
Niners Nation
49ers Red Zone numbers: How effective are they?

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Steelers_small
A Day In The Life Of Punxsutawney Polamalu!
Small
Four Things I Learned From the Super Bowl
Bobby_ray_small
NFL Opinions - wanted or not
Small
BTSC 2010 NFL Mock Drafts : Updated 02/06 (4 round edition)
Steelers_brushback_l_small
Football-related Pet Peeves

Recent FanPosts

Small
Vasher to the Black and Gold ???
Small
Steelers add kicking depth, possible kick off specialist.
Small
Peyton Manning and the post season
Small
Alternate Theory: Draft version, What If?
Rayray_small
SB Weekend Wrap from Miami - Football Stuff
200px-siickeywoods_small
New friends and foes in the AFCN
Rayray_small
SB Weekend Wrap from Miami - Parties
Gildon002_small
Lame ass Fans ..
Small
What does your Mock Draft look like?

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

Mile High Report
Horse Tracks - 2/10/10 - Off-Season Begins
Gang Green Nation
Scouting The Draft: Jordan Shipley, WR, Texas
Niners Nation
Golden Nuggets: I promise

SPONSORS


Site Founder & Editor

Me2_small Blitzburgh

Steelers Historian

Steeler_small maryrose

Bringing You Your Daily Six Pack

Plainview_small drinkyourmilkshake