Behind the Steel Curtain: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:





BTSC Mock Draft - Pick #1 by Miami Dolphins: Darren McFadden, RB Arkansas

steelerark gets things started in a very impressive way. By no means are the rest of you guys expected to put this much time and effort into your writeups, but I'm glad we've set the bar high out of the gates. In case you were wondering, the 'ark' in steelerark stands for Arkansas. I personally like the pick, but it will be interesting to see if Mr. Parcells agrees already having Ronnie Brown on the roster. Well done, sir.

With that, the St. Louis Rams and WolfPackSteelersFan are on the clock.

Well, to be honest, I wasn't expecting to draft this early.  I was expecting to trade down, but with a no-trade clause it falls to me. With the Dolphins, it's hard for me to decide just how big their need is at each position.  The Dolphins' needs are much greater than just one person can fill, with glaring holes on the oline, qb, and reciever position, along with an aging defense.  So which way to go??  Well...

QB - Everyone talks so highly of Matt, but the one game that I watched he was fairly flat against Florida State.  He showed flashes of good stuff, and did throw over 400 yds, but had a lot of attrocious throws.  However, he is the best qb out there in my opinion.  We picked up McCown in free agency, but I can't believe that he is the answer at qb.

RB -  Well, I have been saying for some time now that just about any team would be crazy to pass on Darren McFadden for the simple fact that he is the kind of player that comes around just once in a long time, the kind of player that can change a team. There have been many AP comparisons, and I do believe that they are warranted.  The guy will be a great pro running back, and if I was one of the gms drafting early, would I want to be the guy that passed on him, like the folks that passed Peterson.   I know that the Dolphins have Ronnie Brown, but he has not been able to finsih one season yet, and Ricky Williams is a disaster.   Also, Darren has great hands, upping his value as a reciever out of the backfield.

WR - IMO, its a need, but not the most pressing.  We picked up Wilford via free agency to replace Marty Booker, adding 4 inches and taking away 2 years in age of the other WR probably to start opposite Ginn.  After Ginn and Wilford, the depth is pretty thin.

TE - Sean Ryan has arrived via free agency, but he has only started in 4 games in 4 years. David Martin and Justin Peele are also currently on the team.

OL - Smiley comes in at right guard, but are thin at tackle, and Long would be reaaallly nice here.  

Defense - Biggest need here is d line, with Taylor's status up in the air.  Even if he comes back, his age(34) could still warrant the picking up of the other Long.

So with that, I am really torn.  Do I take best player available, and take McFadden?  I have seen every one of his home games, the guy is a stud, and there are NO character issues like the media has tried to say.  He has no illegitimate children.  One fight, at a bar, does not constitute character issues.  

This is a tough choice, as for me its down to BPA in McFadden, Jake Long on the Oline and or Chris Long on the Dline.   I honestly thought that when I took Miami, that I would be able to trade away the first pick, which is kinda why I chose them, I thought that would be fun.   For two years now I have been saying over and over that teams would be foolish to pass on McFadden, especially now with Peterson's success.  I believe that he is a huge upgrade from Ronnie Brown, and will instantly help the team.   Darren rushed for 1,100+ yards and 11 touchdowns as a freshman, 1,600+ yards and 14 TDs as a sophomore and 1,800+ yards and 16 TDs as a junior. He had 10 100-yard efforts as a junior, including a 321-yard performance against South Carolina. He has crazy speed, vision and balance, and he doesn't shy away from hits, getting significant yards after contact.

A 1-15 record last year brings much lower expectations in 2008.  The Dolphins are officially in a rebuilding process, with Parcells tossing out the old and bringing in the new.  No one man can transfom this team into a playoff contender, so with that, I look to the future.  With my first pick, I take Darren McFadden, RB - Arkansas.  Let the blasting of my pick begin...  :)

But before you do, remind yourself of what he was able to do to defenses in the SEC, hardly the minor leagues of college football.

Poll
Do You Like This Pick Based On Miami's Needs?
  • Yes
  • No

  85 votes | Results

0 recs | Comment 17 comments

Story-email Email | Print |

Comments

Display:

To quote Brady Quinn
I wasn't expecting that.  Alright, I'll get to work on mine for the Rams and Falcons.

by WolfpackSteelersFan on Apr 2, 2008 3:26 PM EDT   0 recs

one quick thing guys
When you write on this platform, do not use double spaces after sentences like you would do in MS Word. Strange quirk to our platform that makes the text look weird. Just a head's up so I don't have to go through each sentence.

Thanks!

by Blitzburgh on Apr 2, 2008 3:44 PM EDT   0 recs

Now he tells me. :)
Well,I didn't do much work yet, so no biggy.:)

by WolfpackSteelersFan on Apr 2, 2008 3:51 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

McFadden
I thought a Arkansas guy might be high on McFadden but I wasn't expecting this high.

by cgolden on Apr 2, 2008 3:50 PM EDT   0 recs

I think McFadden is highly overrated
JMO of course, but I don't think he's even the best RB in the draft let alone the best player. I think Mendenhall is the best RB and I would even rate Stewart over McFadden as well.

To me, McFadden isn't built like a RB, looks to thin in his lower body and when you watch him run, he goes down too quick when hit in the lower body. To me, he has a WR body and I think the potential to be a bust at the pro level is quite possible. I see him as a little bigger version of Reggie Bush who will never be an every down back in the NFL.

by Terry on Apr 2, 2008 4:09 PM EDT   0 recs

i dunno
Perhaps, but as I said in the intro, SEC defenders are the cream of the crop. Of course, nothing like what you see in the League, but he wasnt tearing apart weak defenses.

As per usual, it'll come down to work ethic. That, and the system he's in. Put him with a Brees or Pennington type QB that likes to check down and I think he can have a big impact.

I think we'll see fewer and fewer RBs get the ball 20-30 times a game anyway, so I don't think his value is diminished by the fact that he may not have the frame to be a workhorse.

by Blitzburgh on Apr 2, 2008 4:12 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

Mayock
Yeah, I watched that video too.  Hard to say how McFadden will turn out, but I don't think he's AP.  Although in his defense, last year, I thought AP was too big an injury risk to take before #7.  In any case, Brown is still young and had a great season before getting injured, so I wouldn't take McFadden here.  Too many other needs and quite a number of safer picks.  

by BadMaafala on Apr 2, 2008 4:21 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

D-Mac
I don't think he'll be a bust, I just don't think there are many RBs that are worthy of a top 5 pick. For all of the guaranteed money that goes into them I'd rather take a guy with a longer shelf life, but we're not really concerned about the money aspect of it here. He's a dynamic player and would make a lethal combo with Brown.

by cgolden on Apr 2, 2008 4:26 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

too true
golden.  I really struggled between him and the Longs.

by steelerark on Apr 2, 2008 4:30 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

golden
please find me on gmail when you get a sec

by Blitzburgh on Apr 2, 2008 4:37 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

hehe
I knew going into this that picking McFadden was kind of a homer pick, and honestly I really wasn't expecting to pick, since I was thinking trade.  But you just haven't seen him play.  You may have seen have a game or two, but I have seen every game.  There is a reason why Oklahoma fans were touting AD so much last year.  They saw him on a regular basis.  This guy throws, runs and catches with ease.  He shreds defenses, like in the Auburn game two years ago when Auburn was #2 and he torched them, even tho they were stacking 8 to 9 guys in the box.  He is explosive and has great patience.  Sorry, but every team that passed on peterson has expressed regrets for not drafting him, mcfadden will be no different.  At least I know what I'm getting.  

by steelerark on Apr 2, 2008 4:29 PM EDT   0 recs

well
after watching those videos lets draft some Arkansas guards.  the blocking on some of those plays was phenomenal.  great discipline by their line.

by TheMostViolentTeam on Apr 2, 2008 4:56 PM EDT   0 recs

Agreed
He was untouched on several of those highlights.

by WolfpackSteelersFan on Apr 2, 2008 5:09 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

we had
one of the best offensive lines in the conference.  Averaging 286.5 rushinig yds per game, only allowed 13 sacks in 13 games.  The whole line is anchored by Jonathan Luigs, C.  Two time winner of the Rimington Award for best center.  

by steelerark on Apr 3, 2008 12:52 PM EDT to parent up   0 recs

McFadden will be very good
Don't think he is a great fit for the Dolphins because they are in pretty good shape at the position and they have later picks they can use on a RB if necessary. But he is not overrated. In fact, it's become so fashionable to knock him lately that he might be underrated. He's nothing like Reggie Bush. He's a strong guy who runs behind his pads, reads his blocks and accelerates just like AP. The thing people forget about him is that everyone in the SEC knew he was coming and he still racked up great yardage. He was also taking snaps in one of the dumbest offenses I have ever seen (sorry Ark, Houston Nutt is an idiot). Yes he has skinny legs but the guy will be instantly successful for whatever team gets him, probably either the Raiders or Jets.

by steeler lifer on Apr 2, 2008 10:30 PM EDT   0 recs

no apology necessary
on Houston.  I'm not one to overly knock a coach, and he did win games, but he is not a good coach.  Great motivator, not a good x's and o's guy at all.  Very frustrating to watch.

You said it best about the SEC, they all knew he was coming sometimes stacking up to 9 guys in the box.  He did all he did in an offense geared solely around him and Jones, with an inept passing game.  And don't forget, he did all he did while sharing carries in a buddy system.  Both he and Jones tallied over 1000 yds all three seasons.

by steelerark on Apr 3, 2008 12:06 PM EDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the five-time world champion Steelers. "Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Steelers Question of the Week: Offense vs. Defense vs. Special Teams
Girl-tv1_small
Steelers Links
Small
Effect of Ownership outcome on looming CBA deadline
Small
Espn story on the Rooneys
G_small
Meet the Youngest Steelers Fan in the World
Img_0163_small
Steelers Still Interested in Kevin Jones???
Small
Prowlbowl center for sale;cheap!!
Small
Steelers Question of the Week: 2008 Training Camp Battles
Small
Notes on the 2007 Season from the Football Outsiders
Steeler_small
Steelers Sign Two More Draft Picks

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Site Editors

Small Blitzburgh

Editors

G_small cgolden

ad

Site Meter