A Few Thoughts on the NFLN's Show: Top 10 Super Bowl Performances
I don't know if anyone else saw the NFL Network show on the Top 10 SB Performances, but I caught it this past Tuesday night and there were a couple of things that I wanted throw out there on BTSC and hear the community's thoughts. These are mainly random thoughts, so I apologize in advance if it's kind of scattered.
- First, Lynn Swann's SB X performance was ranked number 5, which was the only Steeler performance. This got criticism from some on the show because he "only had 4 catches." Considering the style of game at the time, and the fact that 2 of the 4 catches are considered among the greatest feats of grace and athleticism in NFL history, I think his performance is deserving of top 10, even top 5, recognition.
- Joe Namath's performance in SB III was ranked 8th. Again, there were the haters who said his stats were very average (even below average), but I thought this deserved to be included. Sure, as games go, this was probably one of the most boring SBs to watch, but this was the greatest upset ever. The historical significance and the pressure of Namath's guarantee should certainly be factored into his performance in the game. But, here was the clincher for me. QB's still called their own plays back then, and Namath directed that game to victory. They also pointed out that Namath was the kind of guy who loved to sling it all over the field, but in this game, he put aside his ego and called his halfback's number more often than not.
- For anyone that was watching, I don't know if you noticed, but Terrence Moore's commentary was the most annoying throughout the show, at least to me. Tim Curran's smarmy looks were up there, too. One thing that was particularly questionable to me was the inconsistency that he showed. He called Timmy Smith's performance (ranked 6th, I believe) in SB XXII the biggest fluke ever. Then, he called Doug Williams' performance (their top pick) in the same game the greatest SB performance ever, without question, and not even close. Both were great performances by backups. The only real difference that I can see is that Williams had been a starter in the past, while Smith was a rookie, but neither ever really did anything else after that game. So, how is Smith a fluke, while Williams, who surely benefited from Smith's running and the Hogs' blocking, is the greatest SB performance ever? Why is Williams not just as big a fluke? He didn't start most of that season. Personally, I don't think either is a fluke, just great performances on the biggest stage. Maybe they didn't do much afterward, but nobody can take that day from them.
- I don't remember all of the top 10, and their website doesn't have them listed. I do remember they had Jerry Rice's SB XXIII performance at 10, Steve Young's 6TD passes was in there (2 or 3?), Marcus Allen in SB XIX, John Riggins in SB XVIII, Vinatieri's two game-winning FGs was ranked 4, and I can't remember the last one. Maybe Larry Csonka in SB VII.
- I was a little surprised that Franco's performance in SB IX didn't get any love. I don't think it was even included in the "Best of the Rest."
Well, that's pretty much it. Those were some things that I found interesting about the show. Particularly, I was curious whether you at BTSC agree or disagree with me on Namath and what I saw as the inconsistency in how Terrence Moore treated Smith and Williams. What do you think?
0 recs |
5
comments
Comments
I think Namath was #1
For the very reasons you articulated Wolf. He did much more than guide the Jets to a Super Bowl victory, he guided the AFL into equality with the NFL. I am more impressed with a quarterback who takes a 16-point underdog and manages a 16-point upset by making the favorite chase him in vain all day, than a quarterback who throws three more touchdown passes and 200 more yards after the game has been decided. I’m not taking anything away from Young or Williams, but what Namath did was help change the landscape of the game. His leadership and confidence in doing so was far more important than statistics.
by maryrose on Jun 26, 2008 5:29 PM EDT 0 recs
Namath
I’m not sure I’m willing to put him number 1, but I definitely thought he should be top 10. Apparently, people forget just how monumental that game was at the time. It was enough to put him in the HOF with relatively mediocre career statistics. Also, this was time then QB wasn’t praised JUST for his passing statistics. Sure, it was a big deal if guy threw for over 300 yards and 3 or 4 TDs. But, they were viewed as football players back then, not just passers. They weren’t just the guy throwing the ball. They were the team leaders, the field generals, etc.
I was really glad that they got it right, and included him in the top ten.
by WolfpackSteelersFan on
Jun 26, 2008 6:09 PM EDT
up
0 recs
I agree with Rose
Not just the best SB moment, the most important game in professional football in the past 40+ years at least. Prior to that game the AFL teams were thought to be minor league next to the NFL and Kansas City’s and Oakland’s performances in the previous two SBs had done nothing to dissuade that thinking. That game, followed by the Chief’s pummeling of a very good Vikings team the following year leveled the playing field and made the move by the Steelers, Colts and Browns into the AFC more palatable.
by RickVa on Jun 26, 2008 8:15 PM EDT 0 recs
All Steelers Top 10 SB Moments
IN NO ORDER: (PLUS ONE)
1) Dwight White sacks Fran Tarkenton in the end zone as the Steelers cruise to a 2-0 halftime lead in IX
2) Franco’s 2 big runs en route to the first Steelers TD (a Franco run) and a then SB record 158 yards.
3) Bradshaw to TE and future All Pro OT Larry Brown. Final Steelers 16 Vikings 6
4) Bradshaw to Swann diving and tipping his way to the cover of SI but not to the end zone (yet)
5) Lambert throwing Cliff Harris to the turf after another missed Gerela FG and energizing himself into the most ferocious LB I have ever seen play in any game ever.
6) Bradshaw to Swann 64 yards for a TD and SB X. Bradshaw is knocked out cold on the play.
7) Rocky Bleier leaps higher than Renaldo Neahmiah to snag a Bradshaw ariel for a TD in XIII that puts the Steelers up 21-14 at the half.
8) The Steelers are down 19-17 in the 4th quarter of XIV. The Rams are driving for another TD and the Steelers are on their heels. Lambert picks off Ferragamo inside the 20 to stop the bleeding. Lambert’s heroics lead to;
9) Bradshaw to Stallworth. Twice in the 4th quarter of XIV. One for a TD and one set up a Franco TD from close in. Steelers cement the dynasty.
10) FWP to the house!
11) Ben to El to Hines. One for the thumb!
When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen
by 5020 on Jun 27, 2008 4:47 PM EDT 0 recs
All great moments
I had forgotten how close the Rams were to extending their lead. That was a team that just made the necessary plays.
by WolfpackSteelersFan on
Jun 27, 2008 4:59 PM EDT
up
0 recs












