2009 NFL Draft Grades - AFC North Edition
We'll get on to the defending AFC North and Super Bowl Champion Pittsburgh Steelers soon enough, but let's first take a look across the division and assess who should be deemed this weekend's 'winners' and 'losers' in the 2009 edition of the NFL Draft.
Baltimore Ravens
Analysis:
I like this draft for Baltimore. I hate to say it, but it seems they got younger and faster at some key positions on defense, while adding an important cornerstone potentially to their offensive line.
Let's begin with Paul Kruger, who is a nice fit for what the Ravens like to do defensively - attack with their speed rushers off the edge in the 3-4 defense. With Terrell Suggs playing under the one year franchise tender in 2009, the Ravens can see what they maybe have in Kruger before making a determination on Suggs' long-term viability in Baltimore. My guess is he'll be shown the door and replaced by Kruger in 2010. Don't think that Suggs won't be extra hungry to prove the Ravens wrong though in this coming year. That could be a scary thought for the Steelers offensive line.
Speaking of offensive linemen. Michael Oher could fill an important need for years to come if he's willing to work at it and catches a break or two injury wise. Oher's stock has fallen since this time last year, but let's make no mistake about it - he has everything god-given that one wants in an NFL starting Tackle. More on him later.
If either Willis McGahee, LeRon McClain, or Ray Rice finds themselves injured this preseason or during training camp, 6th round back Cedric Pearman out of Virginia could be a sleeper pick for them that contributes more than one might imagine. That's only though if he finds himself on the field due to injury - the stable is full in Baltimore at the moment. As for Jason Phillips - I don't know much about him other than that TCU's defense is notorious for being one of the fastest in all of college football. They are notoriously undersized, but make up for it with tremendous collective team speed. I'd imagine Phillips fits that bill nicely - as he's a bit undersized at just 236 pounds to be your typical ILB in the NFL. He'll bulk up, and he'll spend some time with Ray Lewis. Give him a year and he might just be a name Steelers fans get sick of hearing about on the field in the future for Baltimore's defense.
Finally, 3rd Round CB LaDarius Webb. If you ask me, he might be the deciding factor down the line as to whether or not this Ravens draft class pans out to be anything other than just ok to pretty good. Webb will find himself fairly low on the depth chart at CB to start the year I'd imagine - certainly below Samari Rolle, who the Ravens re-signed last week after cutting previously this offseason, and Dominique Foxworth, the high priced free agent CB out of Denver. After that though, Webb could compete for some time in nickle and dime packages with guys like Fabian Washington, Frank 'I'll spit in your punter's mouth' Walker, and Chris Carr.

Grade: B+ I think Oher will be quite good, and I give Baltimore credit for pulling the trigger on moving up and getting him. As for his work ethic? You know what, I really think the spotlight he's been under has taken a tremendous toll on him since Michael Lewis followed him around for several years and wrote about him in a best selling book called 'The Blind Side'. Michael Lewis is like the Michael Jordan of non-fiction, documentary style sports writing, and I simply believe that all the attention that accompanied that book had to have been mentally and physically exhausting for Oher. So much so perhaps, that he put in a little less time to his football regiment than he might otherwise have. But that's all over with now that he's in the NFL. He's just another rookie looking to not have his lunch eaten by a grown man eager to show a young, newly rich kid how to keep his head on a swivel. And I think he'll respond just fine. As for their next three picks, I think they'll all be impact players by 2010 on defense, while getting started in '09 primarily on special teams units.
Cincinnati Bengals
| Round | Player | Position | College | Height | Weight |
| 1 (6) | Andre Smith | OT | Alabama |
6'4 | 332 |
| 2 (38) | Rey Maualuga |
ILB | Southern Cal |
6'2" | 249 |
| 3 (70) | Michael Johnson | DE | Georgia Tech |
6'7" | 266 |
| 3 (98) | Chase Coffman | TE | Missouri |
6'6" | 244 |
| 4 (104) | Jonathan Luigs | C | Arkansas |
6'4" | 301 |
| 5 (142) | Kevin Huber | P | Cincinnati | 6'1" | 220 |
| 6 (179) | Morgan Trent | CB | Michigan |
6'1" | 193 |
| 6 (209) | Bernard Scott | RB | Abilene Christian |
5'10" | 200 |
| 7 (215) | Fui Vakapuna | RB | BYU |
5'11" | 244 |
| 7 (249) | Clinton McDonald | DE | Memphis |
6'2" | 289 |
| 7 (252) | Freddie Brown | WR | Utah |
6'4" | 215 |
Analysis:
This is actually a tremendous draft for the Bengals if you ask me. At least it certainly has the potential to pay off for the Bengals and make them competitive again like they were in the middle years of this decade. So Andre Smith has a little bit of baggage. It's possible that the gamble won't pay off, but there just aren't that many behemoths like that in this world who have the ability to step in right away and be a Pro Bowl caliber tackle. Put it this way - if you're the Bengals and you're thinking about James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley abusing your OTs for the next five years, do you perhaps roll the dice on a potentially marginal character guy? Probably would.
Then there's Rey Maualuga, who many regarded as a 1st round type talent. His lack of excellence in the passing game probably explains his falling to the 2nd round more so than any character issues. My take is that this guy loves football and loves to compete. The question is, are there enough of those types of players on the Bengals where they can all sort of police themselves, at least enough so where they stay out of trouble enough to take the field with a full slate of talented players? In the 3rd round, the Bengals got two more guys that could fit in and make an impact in year one. Michael Johson is a super-long armed physical specimen that could be used in some pass rushing situations. Short-armed guys like Willie Colon could have problems with a rangy pass rusher like Johnson, who certainly will have to bulk up and learn some technique to utilize the skills he does and minimize the impact of the skills he lacks before being an every down type DL in this league. Chase Coffman, a TE out of Missouri who put up just monster numbers for a guy that only started 20 games in his career at Mizzou. Coffman set NCAA records for a TE in receptions (247), yards (2,659) and TDs (30).

Finally, C Jonathan Luigis out of Arkansas will be good. How quickly? Not sure, but if Steelers fans think that A.Q. Shipley out of Penn State is going to find a niche in this league, they must surely concede that the Bengals might have found themselves a good one in Luigis. And I'd imagine that Bengals fans are pleased to have gotten some extra depth at the RB position in Bernard Scott. Sure, he's an unknown from Abilene Christian, a Division 2 school in Texas, but if all goes to plan, the Bengals will have the services of a capable Cedric Benson, Kenny Watson, and a cheap backup in Gary Russell on the roster to carry the brunt of the carries while they see if they have anything at all in this Scott kid.
Grade: A-
Cleveland Browns
| Round | Player | Position | College | Height | Weight |
| 1 (21) | Alex Mack | C | Oregon | 6'4" | 311 |
| 2 (36) | Brian Robiskie | WR | Ohio State |
6'3" | 209 |
| 2 (50) | Mohamed Massaquoi | WR | Georgia | 6'2" | 210 |
| 2 (52) | David Veikune | DE | Hawaii | 6'0" | 257 |
| 4 (104) | Kaluka Maiava | ILB | Southern Cal |
5'9" | 229 |
| 6 (107) | Don Carey | CB | Norfolk State |
5'11" | 192 |
| 6 (191) | Coye Francies | CB | San Jose State |
6'0" | 185 |
| 7 (195) | James Davis | RB | Clemson | 5'11" | 218 |
Analysis: Well, it's a bit harder to assess Cleveland's draft. I'd start by saying that I don't think they got enough in return for trading down multiple times out of their fifth spot, where the New York Jets selected Mark Sanchez at. They wanted him that badly - make 'em pay. Anyway, to their picks. I suppose if Alex Mack turns out to be a multiple Pro Bowl type center, than Browns fans can look back fondly at this selection at #21. I'm not sold yet though. We'll just have to see, but the Browns probably are feeling pretty good about their foundation along the line with Joe Thomas and Alex Mack. As for the Browns next two picks, I'm again skeptical, though I do think that Robiskie can make plays sooner rather than later. Something about him and Mohammed Massaquoi screams poor men's versions of Joe Jurevicious and Amani Toomer respectively.
All four of those players are good football players, but I wonder if Robiskie will be able to stay on the field in this league - which has been a problem for Jurevicious as well. And I wonder about Massaquoi's ability to be physical. You'd think someone who couldn't post better than a 4.66 40-time at the Combine would be a few inches taller and more of a physical type WR made for the red zone, but Massaquoi seems to me to just kind of be a 'tweener in many regards. He'll have some moments though in this league. I just wonder if the Browns have not paid enough attention to the defensive side of the football with those four first day picks.
Grade: C+
1 recs |
12 comments
| Add comment
|
Comments
bengals got great value in first four rounds
smith was once considered as the possible number one overall pick, maualuga could have easily gone in the top 15, johnson was once widely considered a first rounder, and coffman might be the best pass catching tight end in the draft. so if you ask me they got three first round talents and a second without trading. not bad at all.
by tdp992 on Apr 27, 2009 6:50 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Not too worried about Cincy...
They had a great draft, but drafting talent doesn’t equal on field talent. They’ve proven they have an innate ability to not develop any talent they bring in. You can draft the top five prospects in the draft, but if you can’t coach them and get their talent to translate to the field, then what do you have? Not much.
by NYSteelersFan4 on Apr 27, 2009 8:23 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
this is very true
sum is more than just the total of the parts. We’ll see. They showed more heart than did Cleveland down the stretch last year. A good start and lots of the drama sometimes disappears on sports teams. Has been the case in every sport, though its harder in football I think. Anyway, all depends on Carson Palmer, not character. If he’s great and healthy, they’ll be a team worthy of keeping an eye on. No two ways about it. And if he’s not, they’ll be very mediocre without doubt.
by Blitzburgh on Apr 27, 2009 8:59 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Just another Cincy Linebacker for Hines to take out.
"Damnit mom! You almost ran over Greg Lloyd!"
at an autograph signing back in 95. He walked out in front of our minivan, and my mom almost hit him. He apologized.
by PA ARMY OFFICER on Apr 27, 2009 9:03 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Be careful...
Anybody who’s read my pre draft posts know that I really wanted Maualuga. And as big of a Hines fan as I am, Rey is no Keith Rivers. Maualuga may not be the best pure LB out there, but I tell you what, he’s probably the most physical hitter (at least on Cincy). I think Hines will give our division’s new ReyRey a shot, but he better be looking to avoid the shot aswell. That will be the little side story of Steelers/ Bengals game one (and two, and probably every game after that they’re both on the field), the most phsyical WR in football trying to block one of the upcoming big hitters in the league. At least there’s something to make those games interesting.
by NYSteelersFan4 on Apr 27, 2009 4:08 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think the bengals had a better draft, but it’s sort of unfair to give them the nod. When your team has a whole at almost every position it is very easy to draft well. The ravens had a draft similar to ours, filling areas of need and stocking up on depth. I give the ravens the vote because of this.
Don't worry about the haters. Haters only hate.
by steelguy99 on Apr 27, 2009 9:02 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
If I am a bengals fan
I am very excited about the draft. They got three players that were considered first round talent prior to the draft, and they got a one of the best tight end in the draft as well.
The one player that is a gamble is Bernard Scott out of Abilene Christian. He has a very troubled past, but with a player in the 6th round I think you can certainly take that gamble, you just don’t let him even hit the practice squad if he doesn’t pan out in the locker room.
For some additional info on him check this out; he punched a coach allegedly.
http://www.dailymail.com/ap/ApSports/200904260589?page=2&build=cache
I'll drink your Milkshake, I'll drink it up!
by drinkyourmilkshake on Apr 27, 2009 9:22 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
No way we get rid of Suggs
Kruger would have to win DROY and put up insane numbers, which is not going to happen. He will be solid, but we are not going to get rid of Suggs. What would be our reason to? We did not get Boldin, so we do not have to worry about a big contract except for Suggs next year.
Thanks for the B+ grade though. I think it goes to an A- if we took a WR on the first day. That is the only reason. I actually gave our draft a C+, cause I wanted a WR so badly. But looking back at it a day later and all sobered up, I like it.
You have to hate losing more than you love winning.
by Mr MaLoR on Apr 27, 2009 11:26 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I was with Pats* fans all day
Most of them were jumping up and down when they realized Oher was still on the table at pick 23. Then, as you know, that pick got traded to BAL and your boys scooped Oher. They were flabbergasted. I had to explain to them that BAL’s first priority is to win the division. That means stopping Harrison.
Suddenly the Oher pick made sense. Naturally, that put pretty high expectations for what to expect from the traded pick. Not sure they were happy.
by Varmint on Apr 27, 2009 1:53 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Browns
They definitely ripped off the Jets. Not sure how you can see it any other way. They add some bodies that Mangini likes and some high picks. They clearly didn’t want anyone that high so it makes a lot of sense.
by chanman on Apr 27, 2009 11:29 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
As a whole the AFC North did pretty good
but I would give the Bengals the nod for the biggest immediate impact draft choices in the division. Andre Smith and Rey Maualuga are instant starters who will improve their teams toughness and intensity. I wathced Keith Rivers and Rey Maualuga play at USC and together they are a formidable tandem.
Now that we have that out of the way, the Bugngle’s psyche is fragile and as an organization they are too inconsistent to win a superbowl. The talent is there, the coaching is fair, but the ownership it weak. If Carson Palmer is healthy they have a shot at competing in the division but I don’t see them going much further than that.
by Steev1705 on Apr 27, 2009 6:06 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
About the Ravens....
Ozzie Newsome does a great job drafting players cause he learned how the Steelers do it
Ozzie is always giving comments on how the Steelers draft well
I thought that the Browns had the better Draft, although I think that Coach Mangini is a Jerk for how he treated Crabtree. Mangini is a typical Bill Belichick Clone Jerk Coach, just like the Coach at Denver, Josh McDaniels. How in the Hell do you get rid of a Franchise QB? ….I am looking forward to seeing all Belichick Clone Coaches fall on their Faces from Failure (LMAO)
by Steeler Y360 Nation on Apr 27, 2009 11:52 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 


















