Behind the Steel Curtain: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
New Blog: Sounder At Heart for Seattle Sounders Fans!

Pittsburgh Steelers 2009 Roster Analysis- The Linebackers

As undrafted free agent rookie signings and free agent acquisitions wind down prior to the beginning of training camp this summer, BTSC will be taking a look at the various positional battles of note on the Pittsburgh Steelers roster. Let's begin with the linebacker position.

2008 Starting LBs:

James Harrison (OLB), LaMarr Woodley (OLB), James Farrior (ILB), Larry Foote (ILB)

2008 Key Reserve LBs:

Lawrence Timmons (ILB), Keyaron Fox (ILB), Arnold Harrison (OLB), Bruce Davis (OLB), Patrick Bailey (ILB), Donovan Woods (ILB),

2009 Projected Starting LBs:

James Harrison (OLB), LaMarr Woodley (OLB), James Farrior (ILB), Lawrence Timmons (ILB).

2009 Projected Key Reserve LBs:

Keyaron Fox (ILB), Arnold Harrison (OLB), Bruce Davis (OLB), Patrick Bailey (OLB), Donovan Woods (ILB), Andre Frazier (OLB),

Additional Players on the Roster:

Andrew Schantz (LB), Tom Korte (LB)

J_harrison_081116_02_good_il_medium

 

Star-divide

Analysis:

The tandem of Lamar Woodley and James Harrison set a Steelers record for most sacks by a pair of linebackers with 27.5.  It's remarkable to think that the 2009 season will only be Woodley and Harrisons' second season together as starters, and it shouldn't be surprising if they continue to get better next year.  If the two can remain healthy throughout the season I don't think there is a better duo of pass rushers currently playing in the NFL. Harrison and Woodley have the outside linebacker position locked down for the next few years, and I wouldn't expect any of the outside linebacking reserves to get signifigant playing time unless major injuries occur.

The Steelers have adequate depth at outside linebacker although it's hard to analyze as few of the players on the roster have much experience other than special teams play.  The most accomplished back-up at outside linebacker is Andre Frazier who has 42 career tackles and 11 sacks in limited playing time throughout his 5 seasons in the NFL.  After Frazier, Arnold Harrison has 23 career tackles in his three seasons of work and Patrick Bailey and Bruce Davis are both going into their second seasons in the NFL.  Bruce Davis' first season in Pittsburgh would probably be considered a failure by most considering he didn't hit the field long enough to register even one tackle.  Davis seems to have the right attitude though and is looking to make a big impact on special teams this season, he recently said:

"The way it worked last year, I got to sit back and learn watching the best defense in the game. Until my number is called to make plays on defense, I'm going to play special teams like I'm out there playing outside linebacker. I'm going to go as hard as I can and try to knock some people out."

Inside Linebacker on they other hand doesn't have a lot of depth; according to the Steelers website the only players on the roster who are listed as Inside Linebackers are Farrior, Timmons, and Keyaron Fox.  Fox was re-signed this off season to a modest two year deal and looks to be the primary back-up at middle linebacker. Pittsburgh is also exploring some additional veteran help by bringing in former first round draft pick Napolean Harris for a visit and his connections with Mike Tomlin make me think this move is somewhat likely.  According to Datruth4life the guy to watch out for is second year man Donovan Woods, who is listed as an OLB by the Steelers website, but I tend to think that his size (6-2, 230lbs) makes him better suited physically for the inside. Woods was very promising last year at training camp and started off very strong in the early part of the season before he was sidelined off and on for the rest of the season with hamstring issues.  If he gets through training camp and the preseason healthy he has a great opportunity to win himself a spot as a valuable reserve.

Pittsburgh_steelers_v_new_england_patriots_2b3ld8ajv35l_medium

Although Woods appears promising, when the Steelers get to Latrobe I would be quite surprised if they don't have another veteran live body or two to compete for the 4th inside linebacker spot.  It's not Mike Tomlin's style to hand out roster spots without a heavy dose of competition.  Two long shots in the equation are Tom Korte, an undrafted rookie free agent from Hillsdale college, and Andy Schantz another undrafted rookie free agent from Portland State.  Korte excelled at Hillsdale leading the team in tackles 3 straight seasons and picked up numerous awards for his play.   Korte and Schantz will probably need at least a season on the practice squad before they are ready to play, but Korte is already making an impression on the coaches after intercepting Charlie Batch during the first mini-camp.

Besides the health of the unit I believe the key to our Linebacking corp next season will be the emergence of Lawrence Timmons.  Timmons was the first draft pick in the Mike Tomlin era and will only be 23 years old heading into his third season in the NFL. Timmons athleticism should allow Dick Lebeau to come up with a variety of schemes to give offensive coordinators around the league nightmares. 

In his limited playing time last season, mainly on passing downs, Timmons put together a very solid stat line.  Timmons had 65 tackles, 5 sacks, one forced fumble, and an interception during the 2008 season. With the departure of Larry Foote, Lawrence Timmons' speed and size should allow the Steelers to get pressure on opposing Quarterbacks from a position they weren't able to in the past.  The added pass rush from Timmons should also help to create more opportunities for the best outside linebacking tandem in the NFL and will hopefully lead to a third straight season as the number one defense in the NFL.

20080908mf_steelers15_500_medium

So there you have it BTSC, feel free to chime in with who you think will make the roster and what expectations you have for the Linebackers in 2009 season.

 

0 recs  |  Comment 52 comments  |  Add comment |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Timmons...

is a beast! I remember in the playoff game against San Diego, Sproles cought a pass over the middle and Timmons ran him down from behind, impressively. I liked Foote, but I think Milkshake is right, this guy will add a whole new dimension that will allow Coach Dad to give opposing offensive coordinaters the night terrors. Is he good enough to be used like the Polomalu of the linebackers?

It would be nice to see The Steelers come up with another good player out of Nowhere State University, at linebacker.

by WyoFan on May 11, 2009 4:31 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

we're definitely going to be a lot faster on defense

Which is pretty scary when you come to think of it. I am assuming Timmons is fairly comfortable with his assignments and responsibilities,, especially in the running game. If so, look out!

by Blitzburgh on May 11, 2009 4:38 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Is he good enough to be used like the Polomalu of the linebackers?

Funny you’d say that. After watching several Steelers games with me last year, my father asked why Polamalu didn’t rush the passer more often. I told him we have linebacker for that. He was under the impression Troy was a linebacker. God I love Troy.

Anyway, LeBeau has already gone on record saying he can’t write plays for the things Troy can do. That means OCs can’t stop them. If Timmons displays the same athleticism, OCs are going to need a change of shorts for every visit to Heinz field.

by Varmint on May 11, 2009 11:25 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Worst case scenario

Timmons is used like K. Bell was. Harrison and Woodley can cover when asked to. So even if Timmons can’t handle full responsibility, I don’t see it limiting LeBeau.

I want to see the Blitz with just the three lineman and Timmons, and then Troy on a late blitz following LT. It would kill.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 1:40 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I want to see Woodley/Deebo lined up on the right side with Timmons running to cover the other side.

Don't worry about the haters. Haters only hate.

by steelguy99 on May 13, 2009 3:07 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Wait...

If I read that right, I’m intrigued. Are you saying line Deebo and Woodley on one side of the line? As simple a concept as that is I never thought of it. The pass rush from one side would be ridiculous. Timmons can cover the TE on the opposite side, and the two blitzing beasts could have a field day on what ever poor tackle and guard they’re looking at… I love it. Pair 92 and 56 with A Smith or Ziggy, what a deadly pocket collapsing triumvirate!

by NYSteelersFan4 on May 15, 2009 9:47 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

if Gay

can hold up, and Ziggy can rotate, this defense will be scary, especially if the offense improves the running game, man think about it, no more putting the D in bad situations, bad punts, not being able to run out the clock at the end of games. CRAZY!!! Teams won’t be able to rack up yards at the end of games. I mean this season has the potential of dominance written all over it

by tannofsteel84 on May 11, 2009 4:55 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

POTENTIAL for dominance

That’s what scares me. Things look too good right now. I hope Ben doesn’t get anywhere NEAR a goddamned motorcycle, boat, or airplane this summer. I hope he sits in a padded room surrounded by throw pillows for 22 hours a day.

Seriously the only thing that can derail a run at #7 is the health of #7.

by JHolmes on May 11, 2009 5:10 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

agreed

I’m hiring Secret Service for Ben until September

by tannofsteel84 on May 11, 2009 5:26 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

re Ziggy

Adam Schein from Fox Sports doesn’t sound too high on Ziggy. I got to put my faith in Colbert that this guy will be a player by year 2.

http://msn.foxsports.com/nfl/story/9539876?gt1=39002

When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen

by 5020 on May 11, 2009 7:44 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Rest easy, 5020

We know Colbert is a liar about draft matters. This guy thinks we’d only select a Dlineman if he can contribute the first year because Colbert said so?! Hahaha!
We know better, and you’re spot on: Ziggy won’t get much playing time until next year. We’ve got the professors on staff to coach these guys into being successful.

by betelgeuse on May 11, 2009 11:22 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I don’t understand why everyone is so down on Hood. A lot of people had him going in the middle of the first. On the other hand, Unger didn’t go until 18 picks later and Loadholt 22 picks later, right about where they should have gone. Britton was our only other option, but I for one thought Hood was a better prospect for the near and long term. He’ll need to work on his technique some, but luckily we have one of the best DL coaches in the league. He has all the tools to be another Aaron Smith-like DE.

charity standing orders

by BadMaafala on May 12, 2009 9:29 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

The moral of the story is don’t question the Steelers draft just because they went against the grain a bit. They know what they’re doing.

charity standing orders

by BadMaafala on May 12, 2009 9:30 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

This sentence right here sums up why this guy has no credibility…

“I would have also considered Ohio State linebacker James Laurinaitis to replace Larry Foote, whom was cut by the Steelers this week.”

Laruinatis to replace Larry Foote? The where in the blue blazes is our first round pick from two years ago going to play?

I'll drink your Milkshake, I'll drink it up!

by drinkyourmilkshake on May 12, 2009 9:34 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

But

a lot of people asked that question. If the steelers knew Foote was gone why didn’t they do anything in the draft to address it? I’m not sure why they ignore Timmons but trust after seeing him run down sproles in the playoffs last year, they won’t even remember who Foote was. He will be our next Kendrell Bell who can do way more than Bell did, (all he did was rush the passer from what I remember). Timmons can and will take on the run well.

by tannofsteel84 on May 12, 2009 9:53 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Yeah, I they missed the fact that Foote was leaving to get more playing time. There will be a shortage of LB’s looking to get more playing time, so Laurenitis could have filled a pretty big need there.

charity standing orders

by BadMaafala on May 12, 2009 12:59 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Summary of Schein

Blah blah, should have picked a stud O-lineman, Blah blah.

Same story you here everywhere. Truth is we don’t need O-line as dominant as we used to, watch the offense people and stop assuming it’s the same as 1996.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 1:44 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

LB corps should be a strength in 09

I am convinced that this LB corps will be a strength in 09. Woodley and Harrison are the best in the business right now as a tandem coming off the corners. Lawrence Timmons will make his national debut as a starter against the Titans (for the 2nd time, he started against them last year when Woodley was hurt) and Farrior will continue to be Farrior.

I know there are some who are worried about depth for this unit, but that is what training camp is for. I do like A. Frazier, B. Davis and Patrick Bailey on the outside. The second-team backups on at ILB in training camp were K. Fox and D. Woods. I do expect this team to keep 9 LBs on the roster, with 8 being active on game day.

The biggest reason for optimism is the natural progression of Woodley and Timmons, J. Harrison coming of a NFL Defensive Player of the Year season with the possibility of being better and fresher since he’ll probably be taken off of special teams, and the second-year debuts of Bailey, Davis and Woods. People are down on the 08’ draft class right now, but don’t be too quick to judge them, particularly when you throw in the rookie free agent class. Take those three LBs and then add potential safety’s making this squad in Roy Lewis and Ryan Mundy and you have a very good draft haul.

I would expect Tomlin to add a veteran ILB to the mix before training camp, but pretty much the hay is in the barn. What they have now is what will largely represent the team in 09 and the Steelers are loaded. Good depth in the secondary, DL, RB and WR. I still want to see how the OL shakes out. If Capizzi or Hills take a big step forward, this OL could appreciably better in 09.

This squad is loaded and Tomlin knows it. A lot of competition at camp and there are spots up for grab. And don’t forget that there are several veterans in the last year of their contract who are playing for their next pay day. Always good to have a few of those on your squad (another example of this on the flip side is the Dallas Cowboys, with Jerry Jones extending everyone in their last year before the season started and then having those already receiving big money shut it down at the end of the year). Those who don’t bring it at Latrobe won’t be making this squad. Should be fun.

by datruth4life on May 11, 2009 5:14 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Blitz, if this OL comes to play this year ...

I could see 14 and 2 in the regular season and a stairway to 7th Heaven. Injuries are always the big unknown, but as Tomlin says so eloquently, the expectations for whomever is replacing a starter won’t change. Players vibe off their coaches and what they do and say, and this team really believes in not letting things slip because of injury.

Now, how can he all best pass the next 3 months until training camp rolls around?

by datruth4life on May 11, 2009 5:22 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I don’t know why but I like Woods. Maybe it was his ST efforts last year..I don’t rightly recall. But here is to D. Woods have a good year and making more contributions on the field. I’d like to see him step up this year and give us some needed depth at ILB.

Other than that, our LB corp…ridiculous. I hope Farve comes back so Woodley and Harrison can terrorize him and make him regret coming back.

by Silverback92 on May 11, 2009 5:38 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I think I’m the only one that remembers D. Woods jumping over the LOS in pre-season.

The dude can play.

Don't worry about the haters. Haters only hate.

by steelguy99 on May 12, 2009 9:49 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Foote?

I like how foote is still a starter…

But honestly I have to wonder about depth. I think Fox is a solid backup but I dont know about the others. Time will tell.

by Mechem on May 11, 2009 6:03 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

oh lol im dumb

Sorry I missed that you had last years up first. My bad

by Mechem on May 11, 2009 6:03 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Reason why I'm so high on D. Woods

Guys, besides what D. Woods showed in the first game of the season this past year, there is one other play that has me believing that he could another one of those rookie free agent finds. It occurred against the Carolina Panthers this past preseason. Woods had been playing LOLB in the 4th Q with a lot of the other players who would have a hard time making NFL squads. He was regularly getting pressure from this spot on first and second down.

However, when it came to third down, LeBeau moved him inside, and he blitzed up the middle like he was shot out of a cannon. He put a shoulder into one blocker and kept going and then put his Superman cape on and leaped over another block and put a lick on the QB. Does anyone remember that play?

The Carolina announcers were like, “Whooaaa, who was that that looked like they were shot out of a cannon?”

It reminded me a little of that play that S Roy Williams did in college against Texas, I think. From the time the ball was hiked to the time he leaped into the air, over a blocker, and hit the QB to me exemplified what an explosive football player is. And last year was the first year that he had ever played LB. In college, he played QB for most of his career before switching to safety his last year. I bet he and Timmons will both be 240 plus this year. Woods and Bailey on the field at the same time on special teams could be something to behold.

by datruth4life on May 11, 2009 6:10 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

High On Woods Too

I watched him play in preseason last year. I feel this kid is a player and he and Fox made Foote expendable. I have a pretty good eye for talent and I have said Stapleton and Madison would play key roles before they made the team so I do have a history of spotting the talent the FO brings in.

When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen

by 5020 on May 11, 2009 7:46 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Ha, just commented on the superman play above before I got down to this comment.

Seriously, a play. Didn’t stop the ballcarrier, but that’s some serious ability.

Don't worry about the haters. Haters only hate.

by steelguy99 on May 12, 2009 9:51 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

That’s what Foote looked like his first season, exploding into the backfield and just missing the play.

If the kid can be a Larry Foote, we have the depth we need, and more.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 1:46 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Timmons is gonna be a freak this year.

It was Timmons who was getting in Warner’s grill (while being held) when he let the pass go only to be pick-sixxed by the Silverback. I can see this defense being among the best ever, with plenty of strip sacks and hurried passes being picked off. I cannot wait….GO STEELERS.

by SteelersFnRule on May 11, 2009 6:20 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Am I the only one who isn't high on Timmons?

He was a first-round pick two years ago, and where Woodley has flourished, Timmons hasn’t. He still hasn’t started yet at inside, and he probably wouldn’t if Foote hadn’t left.

I still think he’s a pretty good player, and I’m glad he’s getting his chance, but I don’t expect him to be something amazing. ILBs in a 3-4 make a lot of tackles, but very few highlight plays. I’m very hesitant to say that Timmons in ‘09 is going to be better than the Foote/Timmons combo in ’08. Hope I’m wrong.

by zacharai on May 11, 2009 7:41 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I don't think he has to be amazing.

I like Timmons, but like Larry Foote, he’s not gonna be relied on as the number one guy in that LB core. I do think however he could be great. From all that’s been said about his game and how impressed the Steelers have been with him, I think there’s good things to come from Lawrence.

It's true what they say...Even the NFL's Big Wigs hate the Steelers. On the plus side, I can now tell my future grand kids about Hines Ward and how the NFL made rules because of him. Roger Goodell, you make me sick.

by HighSchoolSteeler on May 11, 2009 8:38 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

so much more complicated a position

Woodley just got to tee off in one-on-one situations. Timmons had more to learn, plus the big age difference and experience in college all accounts for the difference in production so far. Timmons is going to wow in the future. Couldn’t be more sure of it zacharai.

by Blitzburgh on May 11, 2009 11:05 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I couldnt be more high on Timmons if i rolled him up and smoked him

Beast, a physical specimen. He will be in the running for DPOY as we make our journey towards Number 7

BLITZBURGH IS BACK

by Steeler_ on May 12, 2009 1:50 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

yes zacharai,

you would be the only one. I’m not sure what you were watching last year, but this guy has superior talent and it’s completely obvious. Once he gets his assignments down, let the games begin. It must be obvious if the guy in front of you wanted outta town to go play for the worst team in the league.

by Hypocycloid on May 12, 2009 8:00 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Heres why Timbo takes longer

Firstly you had two older guys at the position. And at a position that requires experience in many ways, knowledge and just all around field sense. The longer he sat behind them, the better IMO.

Woodley HAD to take over for Crunk Haggans out of necessity. Simple as that.

Now BigFoote is gone you’ll see Timmy in and you’ll be amazed.

by Mechem on May 12, 2009 9:49 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Not so fast

The question is not whether Timmons is an upgrade over Foote. I think we all agree Timmons is the more versatile athlete. If you have to pick just one, you go with Timmons. But, again, that’s not the question. The question is whether Timmons solo is better than Timmons and Foote combined. They made a solid duo last year.

If I recall correctly, Timmons took nearly half the defensive snaps. Obviously, the coaches thought he could play. Yet Foote held him off the starter position and played the other 50% of the game. Obviously, the coaches thought Foote was better for certain situations.

All we saw of Timmons last year were the downs where his skills were maximized. This year, he’ll be asked to play in the situations where Foote was better. Also, Timmons won’t be as fresh for each play. He’s not going to have the luxury of taking a seat for every other play.

I have faith that Timmons can step up and deliver, but let’s not allow our enthusiasm for this kid’s athleticism to blind us to the reality of the situation.

by Varmint on May 12, 2009 11:02 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

slight loss but major gain.

Even if Timmons is unable to play the run as well as Foote, (which remains to be determined)

I think his speed and coverage more than make up for that potential minor loss.

He’s so fast to the edge of the field that it’s like having an extra strong safety on the field. He could be making a lot of tackles in places where the other team runs right at the edge blitz and the DE and OLB have over pursued. Right now those are like 7-8 yard plays it seems. I think Timmons may be able to limit those to 3-4 yards or maybe less with his closing speed.

Also since he’s the better pass defender, he’ll be an asset to passing plays on the first 2 downs.

by Steely McSmash on May 12, 2009 12:40 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Better than the combo, that would be hard. We need to find a back-up who can play. But Foote was not deserving of the snaps he wanted on this team anymore (and I love Foote).

Worse case scenario (as I’ve posted other places) is they use Timmons like they used Bell, to minimize any weaknesses he may have. That would still be devastating, and I think Timmons can do more than just rush.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 1:49 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Starters are Best Linebacking Core in the NFL

I like Keyaron Fox a lot though. I think he’s vastly underrated. I mean I’m not saying he’s the next pro-bowl LB, but I got to see him live in action against the Eagles last pre-season, and though it may have only been preseason, he was everywhere in that game. I believe he even had a pick.

It's true what they say...Even the NFL's Big Wigs hate the Steelers. On the plus side, I can now tell my future grand kids about Hines Ward and how the NFL made rules because of him. Roger Goodell, you make me sick.

by HighSchoolSteeler on May 11, 2009 8:36 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I wouldnt be suprised

if all four of our starting LB’s made the pro-bowl.

by GDEUCE on May 12, 2009 2:16 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

They wont

Because even though Woodley’s numbers will beat out some Balti-whore Terrell Thugs will still get in or somebody like that.

That pissed me off last year. WTF.

And Farrior tends to get snubbed despite owning tackle counts by a mile

by Mechem on May 12, 2009 9:50 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

I'm hoping for low, low numbers.

Low numbers means the opponent’s offense rarely stayed on the field.

by Varmint on May 12, 2009 11:05 AM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Steelers Final Draft Report Card by Scouts.com

Guys, here is another report card on the Steelers draft. Someone file this away so that in 3 years we can come back and laugh at it. I may be in the minority, but I definitely think this is Tomlin’s best draft in his 3 years and some of these players will have a quicker impact on the field for this team than the first 2 drafts. Would love to hear your view on this so-called “expert’s” take.

Pittsburgh Steelers Final Draft Report Card

By Tom Marino, Scouts.com Lead Analyst

If medically sound RB Rashard Mendenhall should pay big dividends in 2009. Safety Ryan Mundy and LB Bruce Davis are fast developing prospects and good special teams players. If healthy OT Tony Hills has an upside. WR Limas Sweed is overrated while QB Dennis Dixon is not a professional prospect.

 
Pittsburgh Steelers Grade – C +
NO RD Name Pos School HT WT 40 Grade 32 1 Hood, Evander DT Missouri 6027v 300v 4.89v 1.202
79 3 Urbik, Kraig OG Wisconsin 6052v 328v 5.39v 1.422
84 3 Wallace, Mike WR Mississippi 6003v 199v 4.34v 1.512
96 3 Lewis, Keenan DC Oregon St 6012v 208v 4.49v 1.393
168 5 Burnett, Joe DC C Florida 5093v 192v 4.59v 1.722
169 5 Summers, Frank RB UNLV 5091v 243v 4.60v 1.900
205 6 Harris, Ra’Shon DT Oregon 6036v 298v 5.04v 1.800
226 7 Shipley, A.Q. OC Penn St 6011v 306v 5.21v 1.800
241 7 Johnson, David TE Arkansas St 6014v 260v 4.73v 1.900

The Steelers drafts are never flashy, but year in and year out the club makes sound selections that ultimately upgrade their football club. I like number one selections Evander Hood’s quickness, hand use, ability to stretch things and playing character, but in my opinion is going to need to get stronger and develop a second (counter) move as a pass rusher. He’s going to play a very long time. Kraig Urbik, is another tough, physical inside player with a chance to play early. Mike Wallace can flat out fly and with further skill development could develop into a strong vertical threat in the near future. Both corners (Keenan Lewis and Joe Burnett) are skilled performers who should contribute in back up roles. I like Lewis’ size and speed, but is going to need work in off coverage (pressed almost exclusively at Oregon State). He can’t be faulted for this, but I really didn’t like the the side pedal that Central Florida employs in their secondary. I really didn’t like the way he played the run. I thought he struggled to get off blocks, and was not explosive on contact. The best area of his game appears to be as a punt return man. I liked his confidence fielding punts in traffic. I particularly liked his first step quicks and instincts in this area. Frank Summers is an inside hammer, who could surprise. He a downhill runner who was particularly effective on short yardage and red zone situations. A. Q. Shipley kind of grew on me as his season progressed, but what really scares me about the undersized center prospect was his lack of lower body strength and short arms (29"). I’m not as concerned with his arm length on pass protection or as a run blocker at close quarters, but rather his ability to get the ball up on center snaps.

FRANCHISE PICK: N/A
QUICKEST TO START: Kraig Urbik
FASTEST TO PRO BOWL: Keenan Lewis
BEST IN 3 YEARS: Kraig Urbik
OVERRATED: Joe Burnett
UNDERRATED: Mike Wallace
PROJECT: Ra’Shon Harris
BEST COLLEGE F.A.: Ramon Foster (OT)
TOP TALENT SCOUT: Kelvin Fisher
HAH?: N/A

by datruth4life on May 12, 2009 11:10 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

do we have to wait to laugh at this?

If healthy OT Tony Hills has an upside. You mean he’s not a finished product after his rookie season? Why wouldn’t he be healthy? Looks like this is based on last years draft notes.

WR Limas Sweed is overrated Overrated by who? what’s his rating?

while QB Dennis Dixon is not a professional prospect. No need to back this up with any arguements or anything.

my opinion is going to need to get stronger Pretty much true of every rookie — great insight here.

lack of lower body strength….. but rather his ability to get the ball up on center snaps. No basis in reality. Shipley’s strength is one of his stand out areas. Inability to snap the ball high? is he serious? Not worried about defenders locking their arms out on him or anything? No? just can’t snap?

I do agree on the players he put in categories at the end.

by Steely McSmash on May 12, 2009 12:52 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

The Shipley part is especially laughable since Hartwig is a pretty crappy snapper.

Don't worry about the haters. Haters only hate.

by steelguy99 on May 12, 2009 1:02 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

If healthy OT Tony Hills has an upside. Okay, he just lost all credibility to me. ;)

Honestly I have no problem with the C+ grade. It’s pretty hard to find something that blows you away with this draft. We went need pretty much from start to finish, which is a poor way to accumulate talent, but a good way to fill some chinks in an otherwise sturdy dam. The only picks I was thrilled with were Hood and Shipley, which found the place where value meets need.

In general, I think the Steelers are a little overrated at drafting. I think they’re above average, but not outstanding. They are much better at developing talent (especially defensive talent), including drafting people who they can mold (like Hood) and attracting eager UDFA’s that want a shot. I live in Ohio and all non-Steeler fan Ohioans are pissed that whoever we put at OLB turns into gold while their first rounders turn out just so-so. Something like 70-80% of that is development, not superior drafting. The Steelers are also one of the best teams at playing the free agency market – consistently finding cheap role players like Moore, Fox, McDonald, and hopefully Harris for dirt cheap and signing the guys they’ve been developing for 4-5 years to extensions. The fact that they invest as much (both time and money) as they do in their draft picks after drafting them is why most of our team is homegrown, which makes their drafting look a little better than it actually is.

charity standing orders

by BadMaafala on May 12, 2009 2:56 PM EDT up reply actions   1 recs

Good post

I think this hits on the key. Considering that Steelers’ draftees washout around the same percentage as other teams you’d have to contribute a lot of their success to good coaching from the position level up. The one area where the Steelers don’t seem to miss though is the 1st round. This could still be partly due to organization and coaching though as they are always willing to let a rookie sit the bench for a year before getting a lot of reps. Other teams take the philosophy that all experience is good experience whereas the Steelers seem to believe it’s worth the bench time.

by Chicago Steeler on May 12, 2009 5:33 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

One thing to add.

The Steelers have run this defense for years. They draft for their defense. They don’t draft a great athlete then try to fit him in a system he isn’t ideal for.

The reason Woodley started before Timmons is Timmons was drafted as more of an athlete who needed to learn our system, where as Woodley was perfect for our system when he walked in the door.

Finding good players is different from finding the right players, which is what the Steelers do. That said consider the draft grade accurate in the CB, they are good enough to play reserve roles, and eventually contribute more. Wallace is a vertical threat, he doesn’t need to be more, and Sweed overrated? Someone is rating Sweed highly out there? Oh wait, that might be me. Sweed is gonna surprise some people, he showed a fighting spirit after he dropped that pass last season, he won’t sit on his laurels, he’s gonna work to get better.

Shipley is a great 7th round pick, he either flames out, becomes a back-up, or just fights his way onto the field. The kid has all the intangibles in the world, lets see what he can do with them.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 1:58 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

One thing the Steelers do better than anyone else

Is they almost never screw up taking guys with poor character. This year’s draft is another example… by all reports each pick is a great citizen with an interesting life story. I think they sometimes under value athleticism, and reach for positions (I know in 2008 they did the opposite but other times they have…). That said they are certainly better at drafting than New England.. also rated highly by the conventional wisdom, but maybe not as great as San Diego and Baltimore

the other thing is, as already pointed out by some other posters, that they pick guys who can succeed in thier system and they have the patience and coaches to develop them. Guys like John Mitchell, Keith Butler, and Dante Scarnecchia do make a big difference especially when combined with patience at the top of the organization.

by SteelerFan Ben on May 14, 2009 6:03 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Timmons' Time To Be Great

Some people may say that the team was better off keeping the Timmons/Foote combo, but I don’t agree. Foote didn’t want to be here and Timmons has paid his dues. You don’t pick a guy no. 1 to sit. Time to put him in there and let him be great. That’s the Steelers way of doing things. You learn, prove that you can be trusted, beat out the competition and then you play. Don’t forget Timmons had 2 pretty good players in front of him on the no. 1 D in the league his first two years. Foote was a good player; he was never a great player. Timmons has the ability to be great.

I don’t think the Steelers have had 2 ILB’s that could play all 3 downs since Levon Kirkland and Chad Brown. And I think that is the mold that Tomlin wants all of his LB’s to have — versatility, speed, explosion with the ability to be tough at the point of contact.

And another reference to D. Woods, I’m sure that was a pass play in which he put his cape on and made like Superman. It was a called blitz where he shot the A gap and looked like he was fired out of gun. The pass was incomplete but his effort and explosion were impressive. The good thing is that he not only flashes ability, but that he is one of your best special team players on the squad to boot. In other words, you get good production from a young player that you can continue to groom for the base defense — The Steelers Way, BABY!!!!!!

by datruth4life on May 12, 2009 11:27 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs

Not enough credit to Scouting Department

BMF, you are definitely one of my boys here that I love reading, but I have to disagree that the Steelers are just “above average” when it comes to the draft. For the most part, the draft is hit and miss anyway. However, I include whom you sign as rookie free agents as part of your draft haul as well, and I think the Steeler’s scouting department is second to none as far as finding talent that fits the team’s philosophy and schemes. I’d be the first to admit that K. Colbert’s second day of drafting hasn’t been that great, but he seems to have done a little better the past 3 years (at least some of those players are still on the squad now).

This team believes in building around a core group and I think they do as good a job as any team in the NFL at doing that. They’re just not going to pay top dollars to other team’s players to come here. The only players they usually pay big money to are those that they have drafted, developed and have produced at an All-Pro level. Their philosophy of not negotiating a new contract with a player until the last year of their contract might cause a few good players to leave, but they usually keep who they really want to keep and it saves the organization a ton of headaches in the offseason when it comes to contract talks.

I agree that player development is crucial, but the talent has to be first identified before it can be brought in and developed. That’s called Scouting. And once you get that talent under contract, they have to be taught the Steelers Way and their skills refined. That’s called player development and coaching. And the Steelers do both of those, the acquisition of talent and player development, as well as anyone in the NFL.

by datruth4life on May 12, 2009 3:37 PM EDT reply actions   0 recs

I think you will see a difference with Tomlin on day 2.

Cowher was a gambler. He loved huge upside potential and you can see that in our drafts. Ex. Ike Taylor and Ricardo Coclough, Ike worked out, Rico not so much.

Tomlin seems to be drafting guys that he thinks are a safer bet to contribute to the team, like Dungy did.

The scouting department rocks, I think we are seeing a different idea in place for the draft, esp. later picks.

Sure he can score goals, but can he cook?

by Phantaskippy on May 13, 2009 2:02 PM EDT up reply actions   0 recs

Timmons

is probably the most versatile LB of the group, because he can play ILB and OLB

by GDEUCE on May 14, 2009 1:32 AM EDT reply actions   0 recs


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the SIX-time world champion Steelers.

"Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history."

Art Rooney Jr.

"Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Start posting about the Steelers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

09_mc501_hemlet_105270_small
HSS Quarterly Draft Report #2: Late edition
Small
At The Half: The Steelers On The Back Stretch
Miketomlin-200_small
Familiar feel? & a look ahead
Steelers_small
Keystone Zebras Want You
Vaca_mexico_068_small
Ryan Clark, Denver, and Sickle Cell Disease

Recent FanPosts

2196876391_dcb0380cb0_small
Sunday games open thread
Small
Law don't go around here Law Dog
Dsc00111edit_small
Ah, familiarity.
Dr
Knowing when to pull the trigger
Jester_small
Yinz Luv... Jim Shearer
Sidney_steelers_small
Look for Woodley to Emerge
Small
Biggest Concerns - Denver Broncos
Yeswecan_160_small
See "The Chief"
Small
Hurry up offense
Sidney_steelers_small
Bengals - Turning point for a franchise

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Latest NFL Headlines from SB Nation

SPONSORS


Site Founder & Editor

Mbean_small Blitzburgh

Steelers Historian

Steeler_small maryrose

Bringing You Your Daily Six Pack

Plainview_small drinkyourmilkshake