Initial Observations - 2009 Edition
Bumped from the fanposts. Many thanks to RickVa for the fine article that will lead us in to the weekend. Happy Friday all. - Blitz - (Michael B.)
**********************
Camp starts in a week. Its time (finally) to begin to fully focus on football and the season in front of us. Last year I thought the team had a shot of going all the way provided certain stringent conditions were met. For example, we had to be lucky with injuries (we weren't), the play of the OLine would have to be better than feared (it wasn't), the schedule would have to be a paper tiger, many opponents not living up to their reputations (it wasn't). The Steelers won anyway.
This year I am even more bullish on the Black and Gold. Barring the unforeseen I believe this team is the class of the League and potentially better than last years crew even though much of the personnel is exactly the same. Unfortunately, the unforeseen has already occurred. But, in what may be the first great Tomlinism of the '09 season, Coach Mike has already declared that the sign of a great team is its ability to perform in spite of the presence of distractions. What follows is one man's observations of random factors that may help shape the season for good or ill before things actually get in motion. Feel free to comment or criticize as you see fit.
They hate us. One thing that is clear in light of the recent allegations against Ben is a lot of folk have come crawling out of the woodwork and the sewers to pile on and wish Ben, the team and the Nation ill. The reason is clear and understandable; They're jealous. We have what they all want. We (owner, front office, coaches, players, fans) are the best , period. For fans of teams that have elite aspirations (Pats, Cowboys, Titans, Chargers, Eagles, etc.) the Steelers stand as a crippling rebuttal to their claims of world domination. The League has to pass rules to stop us from dominating play (You pass a rule to keep our wide receivers from bullying other teams' linebackers? Are you kidding me?), individual clubs have to pass rules to keep our fans from dominating their stadiums (The Steeler Nation is coming! One if by land, two if by sea!). Tomlin has yet to lose a game to a division opponent.
And if you run a league and/or its network partners and you believe the concept of parity is the road to profits the last thing you want to see is a small market team beginning to act like they're going to become the Yankees or the Lakers. So, let's be clear; we are in the season of 'Let's break up the Steelers'. In this sense to be hated or ignored is a good thing. In fact, let us all redouble our efforts to make certain that everybody hates us. Get that seventh Lombardi Trophy and watch the top of people's heads blow off.
Tomlin. A fairly substantial minority of folks here at BTSC began singing the praises of Coach Tomlin not long after he was hired. More have jumped enthusiastically on the band wagon as he quickly learned from his first year mistakes, led the team to its sixth championship and has demonstrated a unique, no nonsense leadership style. My observation of how Tomlin has been viewed outside Steeler Nation is very similar to how Big Ben was initially treated. It seems they view him as someone who has lucked out and found himself in a situation where the elements surrounding him (talent, organizational support) is so strong that all he has to do is "manage" things in such a way that he doesn't mess things up. And just like BB the world will eventually learn that Tomlin is bringing a lot more to the table than 'management skills'. As a charter member Tomlin fan I am anxious to see how he addresses the challenge of responding to success. As he moves into his third year, how he will craft the team even more into his image. I'm convinced that this team continues to be a work in progress, and that there are going to be surprises in store for the rest of the League and even some of the Steelers most loyal fans if they think things are just going to stand pat. My belief in the team's success this year is grounded in the view that Tomlin is going to challenge them to get better.
Big Snack. One thing Tomlin emphasized to the troops in the spring was the necessity of coming to camp in good physical condition. If Casey Hampton shows at camp in good enough condition to survive the conditioning run I think that's a good indication that the team is drinking the Kool Aid and is set to move beyond the Super Bowl hangover. It might also indicate that Hampton recognizes that this is a contract year and is set to rachet up his play. Regardless, it will be good news from a performance and leadership perspective.
Ben. Not enough has been made IMO of what Ben delivered on the field in the wake of getting that big contract last year. Nonetheless, BB continues to be an afterthought in discussions of top quarterbacks. Its as though the pundits are still trying to justify that they ranked Phillip Rivers and Eli Manning over Ben when they came into the League. And with Tom and Peyton selected as the Anointed Ones, it is considered blasphemy to suggest that anyone might approach these two in talent or achievement. Well guess what? Ben is going to get better this year. Not a little bit better, much better. He hasn't peaked in a developmental sense as a qb, he is in the third year of the current offense, the O line, though nowhere near great will be better than last year even if the starting personnel remains the same. As for the civil suit? Forget about it. It will be used as fuel by both Ben and the rest of the team. The Steelers will use the emotions of the Haters to consume them.
What if he gets hurt? One thing that passed almost completely under the radar last year was the depth we had (and still have) at the quarterback position. A lot of people became enamored with Byron Leftwich. They should have. In a rational world there is no way that a talent like that would be available to the Steelers as a backup. Last I heard he was doing quite well in the competition for the starting job at Tampa Bay. So who's left? Charlie Batch. Oh yeah, the herd mentality says that Charlie's old and washed up. Well, there's old and then there's old. Batch has spent much of the last five years carrying a clipboard. Not exactly a lot of wear and tear there. He's a solid qb, a respected leader in the locker room (teams representative to Players Association) a favorite son and pillar in the community. If people can fight over a washed up shell like Brett Farve at 39 well...Dennis Dixon was a legitimate Heisman contender before he got injured in his senior year of college. Probably wasn't 100 percent when he joined the Steelers. Would be a great choice to run the Wildcat if it ever was decided to add that package to our offensive options. Quarterback will be a growth area with this years team.
LeBeau. Believe it or not I think the defense will be better than last year. The major concern is that offensive coordinators might catch up with LeBeau's scheme's though he is unlikely to stand pat. I love Larry Foote but Timmons ought to be an improvement. In fact, it is not unreasonable to expect the sort of break out year that Woodley enjoyed last year from Timmons this year. I also like BMac but I don't think he'll be missed. Gay or one of the rookies should adequately replace. Herd mentality also says that Deshea Townsend has a foot in the grave. Why? Townsend came into the league at same time as Hines Ward and is every bit as mentally tough. I saw no indication of him slowing down. Particularly in the Dallas and the AFC Championship game. The defense looks to be bigger, faster, younger and deeper than last year and years past.
Special Teams. Speaking of defense, the return of punter Sepulveda should mean that opposing offenses will have a longer field to traverse and the defense will have a bigger cushion. In general, it looks that a great deal of energy will be expended trying to develop a unit that will lengthen the field for the defense and shorten it for the offense, plus collecting enough talent that hopefully one or more players will emerge that will be a scoring threat either on punts or kickoff return. Add this to the reliable work of Jeff Reed and the Steelers become strong in three dimensions. Very tough to deal with.
The Schedule. Easier schedule than last year? Wrong! We have the Bullseye Schedule. True we won't be facing the best teams like last year, but we will be getting every team's best game. Sixteen Super Bowls. We may be as likely to lose to Detroit as to Tennessee. The approach to each game will have to be at least as disciplined as it was last year or we'll be courting disaster.
New England. Usually identified as the team most likely to dethrone the Steelers because Tom Brady is back (oooooo!) This is insulting. Last year I went out on a limb to predict that the Pats window was closing and that chances were good they wouldn't make the playoffs. Yes, I hear you, "Tom Brady was hurt." (As the late Dwight White would say "Excuses, excuses.") Well, consider this: Tom will probably not be 100 percent for most of the season. Yes, the Pats nearly had a perfect season two years ago. You can fall fast in the NFL. The '79 Steelers won the SB and then could not make the playoffs in '80. In fact, there are some interesting parallels between that team and the '07 Pats. They both struggled in the SB against an NFC wildcard team that upset the Cowboys early in the playoffs. Neither team made the playoffs the following year. Fact is that it's been half a decade since the Pats last won a championship even with the great Tom Brady leading them. The Steelers have won two championships in that period. I would be concerned if the Pats can escape their competition in their division. Somehow I don't think Bill Parcels is wetting his pants in anticipation of facing his old assistant coach. Neither is Rex Ryan. IF we (and they) both make it to the playoffs then we'll worry about crossing that bridge at that time.
Dan Rooney. The Steelers have been the most successful, most stable franchise in the NFL over the last forty years. The one element that has been consistently present over those forty years has been Dan Rooney. The Chairman is off to Ireland now and it is not altogether clear what effect if any his absence and the impact of the new ownership group will have on the day to day operation of the club. No worries about the competence and experience of Art Rooney, but whether the more introverted son of Dan will have an impact on team culture will yet to be seen. What do you think?
3 recs |
34 comments
| Add comment
|
Comments
I'm glad you mentioned the distraction
someone would have deleted the post otherwise.
Can’t disagree, but don’t want to get my hopes up too early either. Actually it’s way too late for that. I’ve resisted the oportunities to gloat alot this spring/summer, no trash talk, just following every move the Steelers make everyday times a day. I’m with pretty much with all of Steeler Nation, in the back of my mind, I can see more SB trophy’s for the Steelers with Ben/Tomlin/Lebeau/Troy leading them.
by SNW on Jul 24, 2009 10:45 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Hey man,
Right on point as usual. Your observations are awesome.
This is surely a gut check year (season).
Go Steelers!
by C-Mac on Jul 24, 2009 10:47 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I agree, except for QB
I agree with your thoughts in general, but anyone who thinks that Charlie Batch is a capable backup this year, is seeing through black-and-gold colored glasses. Batch hasn’t played football in an entire year. In his appearances previous to being injured he looked old .. he looked like he had lost a step. Now he is coming back after being out for a year…. sorry to everyone, but Batch was only a competent backup when he was in his prime. Currently, he is a liability at the #2 slot.
Other than that, I agree with you. I am really psyched to get Sepulveda and Mendenhall back.
And I agree that our team, in general, will actually be better this year.
Regarding the Super Bowl Slump: I’d be more worried about it if Tomlin was older. He is still an energetic 37 year old.
by PaulMorel on Jul 25, 2009 1:29 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Great read and great analysis as always RickVa, also I feel t same about Batch He´s still a very reliable back up, even thinking that this season will b 16 SB, I feel that
Our D could b very dangerous, Imagine in some plays mainly to press t QB 2 put Ziggy as LB with Woodley, Deebo and Timmons, and in similar situations also We can send Big Snack/Hoke + Ra`Shon & Ziggy, for teams that run well by any side We can send Snack & Hoke 2 that side, & w/them or even w/o those options all t OC´s of t league will have nighmares and I personally like that t Pets will have Brady back, & b noted as t force of t league, I hope he also will block Deebo or Woodley or Timmons or Hood, that satr xcuse me, star mentality is just the same as fantasy football, Brady & Romo always beat Us there, not in t real gridiron, t Steelers r not a fantasy team they just play great at every position and defend any blade of t turf. And that is a great reason because almost All of our “exported” players always tend to become stars in other teams, because t competence for almost any spot here is just too “Steel(erish)” high. We play as a team, “We feed each other”. Not like D’all’as(s) & Pets they have I don´t know how many all pros, playing marbles that last season in december.
O sales tickets,...and let D rest a little, and D Win Championships.
by YeOldeMexFan on Jul 25, 2009 2:47 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
great read as usual Rick
I especially agree that in some ways I think this “distraction” of Ben’s civil case will almost help the Steelers. I see it being similar to 07 when the pats* got caught cheating and went out and annihilated the majority of the league (except when it counted).
I think Tomlin circles the wagons with this one and allows the Steelers to develop an “Us vs. Them” mentality.
I think the key this year like most years is luck with injuries. I’d like to see Ben, Troy, A. Smith, and Starks play 14+ games. While Starks doesn’t really belong in that company I think he’s the most solid lineman we have and he does a better than average job protecting Ben’s backside.
by Chicago Steeler on Jul 25, 2009 10:51 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Injuries
The main issues is not just who gets injured, but when the injury occurs. Our playoff run last year was successful largely because we went through the playoffs at nearly full strength. With the exception of Wards injury – we had no meaningful injuries in the playoffs (apart from the season long absence of Sepuldava).
Ward’s injury nearly derailed us in both the AFC championship game and the SB. However it was nowhere near as crucial as the injuries the Steelers had going into Wild Card game with Jacksonville in 2007.
That loss (close as it was) was directly attributable to the guys not on the field, or playing hurt.
A missing FWP and no running back depth made Najeh “Dookie” Davenport our feature back. That alone was enough to spell disaster as Dookie managed a total of 25 yards on 16 carries (a whopping 1.6 yards per carry) with Carry Davis and Gary Russel lighting it up for an additional 5 yards on 6 carries.
But worse then the loss of FWP was the absence of Aaron Smith on the defensive side of the ball. The ferociously stout Pittsburgh run defense had prior to 2007 held opposing backs to under a 100 yards for 35 consecutive games – until that streak was broken in a clunker of a game against the Jets earlier that season. However it was Smith’s absence that directly led the floodgates being opened.
With Smith suffering a torn biceps in week 11 against New England – the Steelers proud run defense began to resemble swiss cheese. In week 15 the Jaguars ran for 224 yards on 42 carries – averaging a healthy 5.6 yards per gain. In week 16 St. Louis fell behind early so they only attempted 15 runs the whole game, still they had no lack of success with those runs averaging 6.0 yards per rush. In the finale the Ravens ran for 180 yards on 40 carries – a 4.5 yard average.
In the playoff game the run defense seemed to ratchet up a notch. For most of the game Jones-Drew and Fred Taylor were held in relative check totaling only 67 yards on 24 carries. However in the crucial moments of the game it was the absence of another player which cost us dearly.
On a do or die fourth and 2, twin injuries spelled the end of the Steelers season. A missing Ryan Clark meant that Tyrone “Leadfoot” Carter was in at safety. In a play that has to be as painful and mystifying to Steelers fans as Bill Buckners classic 1986 ground ball through the legs, Tyrone Carter was juked by the cumbersomely slow David Garrard.

http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/052b78SgqQeOa/610×.jpg
Few of us have any doubt that if Ryan Clark had been on the field that the game would not only have been over but that Garrard most likely would have suffered a concussion.

Of course that play was facilitated by another freak injury. No not Aaron Smith’s injury, though I have no doubt he would have blown up the play at the line of scrimmage.
I am talking about the freak bout of momentary blindness that allowed a league official to miss Jacksonville Tackle Khalif Barnes sexually-assaulting, bear-hugging holding James Harrison who would have Garrard down behind the line of scrimmage.
Thankfully after a civil-suit official complaint to the NFL by the Steelers, the league issued a large cash settlement apology to the Pittsburgh Steelers and vowed to never again call an offensive player for holding James Harrison to try to do better in the future.
What were we talking about? Oh Injuries. Yes injuries can derail a season. But it’s usually much more about the timing of the injuries rather than who goes down.
by SteelerBuddha on Jul 25, 2009 1:27 PM EDT up reply actions 1 recs
Well said Buddha.
No wonder you’re so wise. You wrapped up everything I was thinking in much better logic and semantics. I agree that timing of injuries is really important, but I also feel that we’ll struggle a lot more if we have any of the players mentioned miss a lot of time early in the year. I’d love to get the first round by again (or even get to the playoffs, not getting ahead of ourselves). Good point about the refs being more fair by deciding that we’ll never get holding calls on Deebo again. That way we’re not surprised when it happens.
by Chicago Steeler on Jul 25, 2009 3:40 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
LOL
Thank you Chicago. I agree long term absence by any of the guys on your list could mean some trouble for the team. And yes Max Starks should be on that list – the thought of Trai Essex or Tony Hills guarding Ben’s blind-side should be enough to make any Steeler fan wet their pants on the spot.
On the other hand I think that short term injuries 1-8 games – by almost any player on the defensive side of the ball would be acceptable if they were back in full form during the playoffs. Injuries last year meant valuable playing time for our reserves – some of whom stepped into full time roles (William Gay for example).
On the other hand if any of the following went down for the playoffs I could see it costing the Steelers a close game:
Farrior, Woodley, Harrison, Troy, Clark, Smith or Ike.
Granted that’s a long list – but I do think those are the positions where the drop off in talent from the guy in the top spot to the guy next on depth chart is either very serious or just a total question mark. Or course chances are that some body will go down at some point – and that is when heros and goats are made.
by SteelerBuddha on Jul 25, 2009 4:44 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Barnes wasn't the only one holding on that play
there were at least two guys holding on that play…I felt so bad the whole offseason because we whipped that team all over that field after their fast start….the better team definetly did not win that day….of course, the Pats were next and we were beat up pretty bad, so it may have been for the best that we didn’t win (did I just type that?)….I think Brady was like 26 of 28 against the Jagoffs (something like that)….they were just rolling then….until the Super Bowl, that is….lol.
It felt SO GOOD to beat Jacksonville last year like we did….then it just seemed like the floor fell out from under the Jags after that….karma.
by SteelerStuckintheSouth on Jul 25, 2009 5:29 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Right On Rick
Always love your posts. My thoughts on your musings;
1) They have always hated on us. The Steelers have always been a class organization and once they started winning they became the envy of all. Small market team, loyal & boisterous fan base, the loyalty within the organization running both ways, everyone in the league wants to play for the Rooney’s…Let them hate. We just win Lombardi’s.
2) I am one of those who chose to reserve judgment on Coach T. He needed to improve from the 07 debacle against Jax (which one?) and redeem. He did. He still needs to improve (as we all do) but I am pleased as punch with the Rooney’s choice and have the confidence that the players have Tomlin’s back.
3) Hampton will be ready to go even if he can’t run the fitness test. He will play and play hard. He is playing for his last contract. My guess is it won’t be in Pittsburgh but his last year will be a good one.
4) Ben is the M-A-N. Ben is the MVP. Ben is the straw that stirs the drink. If Ben goes down the Steelers are in HUGE trouble. I like Batch but I think he is too old to lead this team for several weeks. Maybe a couple quarters. What would be best is if Dix steps up in camp and can show he is a #2. That way Batch can be a coach and play if need be to finish a game and get us a W. His best days are behind him. He has slowed a bit and is brittle. But, he has a great head on his shoulders, plenty of game day experience and we are lucky to have him on the roster. He may be the best #3 in the league if that’s what he is in Pitt.
5) LeBeau is a genius. The Steelers will have good days and bad but LeBeau will keep the bad ones to a minimum and make the right adjustments. Woodley will be better than last year with the experience and confidence. Timmons will be an upgrade over the solid but undersized Foote. Once again the Steelers LB corps will be an asset and position of strength for this team.
6) Sepulveda will be an upgrade over the revolving door of punters from last year. He has a long way to go to be one of the top punters in the NFL. But with only 1 year under his belt there is lots of upside here. Hope he comes back from injury and develops into a stud kicker. Would love to see Dix as the holder instead of Sepulveda. Gives the team so many more options from FG or PAT or if the snap goes awry. Frazier, Madison, Bailey, Fox and Woods will be exceptional on ST hunting down the ball carrier. Tank, K Lewis and Ziggy can hopefully step up and perform well on ST too. Look for MacDnald to be PR. Wallace makes game day roster of he can KR. If not MeMo, MacDonald or K Lewis could get the job and Mr. Drop (Sweed) will dress on game day instead of the Rookie Wallace.
7) The schedule is the schedule. You can only beat who they put in front of you. This will be a tougher schedule than last year because last year was last year and we haven’t beaten anyone on this schedule yet. Every team is dangerous. In the NFL on Sunday one team wins and one team loses. Steelers need to come out +1 on points most weeks and should.
8) Tom Brady is great. Pats* will be a big challenge. That said; **** them. Hope we beat them on the way to XLIV and become team of the decade over their beaten and rotting carcasses. See Cowboys circa 1978.
9) Dan Rooney will be missed. His presence, guidance and knowledge were unsurpassed and you can’t lose a guy of that stature day in and day out and have it not effect the team. Hopefully Art II is ready to step in full time and lead.
When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen
by 5020 on Jul 25, 2009 12:12 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
Tomlin still needs to improve? Sounds like you’ve been listening to Mike Tomlin.
by Phantaskippy on Jul 25, 2009 8:03 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
initial observations
I agree with most everything you say here. I do think McFadden will be missed, you can never have enough good corners and BMac is legit. Gay has good potential though. I look for Willie P to have a good year. Our coaches need to set the tone early in training camp and I have no doubt they will. One thing that needs to improve is the intensity of the fans. Sorry, but at times the fans disappearduring games and you can hear a pin drop. Let’s really get into it this year. I hate it when Heinz is quiet, regardless of the score.
by mternes on Jul 25, 2009 1:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
As to b-mac
One thing I think we forget is that B-Mac wasn’t even our starter going into the year I don’t think. Didn’t Deshea come out as our starter? I might be remembering wrong, but in any event we’ll see very little drop off between b-mac and gay/deshea.
by Chicago Steeler on Jul 25, 2009 3:43 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think he did start (finally)
It took him years to supplant Deshea. And then as luck would have it they both got hurt against the Bengals giving Gay his chance to shine. I think people forget that LeBeau was a great DB and Tomlin cut his teeth coaching the defensive secondary. If b-mac was irreplacable I’m sure they would have worked harder to keep him. I honestly believe that we may have the deepest secondary in a long time (maybe ever) when you take into sophomores Mundy and Lewis and the two rookie draft picks. If only half of those guys pan out we’ll be in clover for awhile. And check out the article on Ike Taylor in the Trib-Review. Timed at 4.2 recently. Wow.
by RickVa on Jul 25, 2009 4:00 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Dont forget our sophmores!
there are so many second year players that are going to get their time in this year. Our rookies dont get much on either side of the ball, but the second year seems to be the time to shine for steelers draftees., Hills, mendenhall, sweed, and dixon should get some snaps in when Ben pretends to be hurt again this season.
by darkwingdank on Jul 25, 2009 1:34 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Special Teams Might Be Special This Year
Sepulveda will have the biggest impact on the team this year. He doesn’t have to be the top kicker in the league to turn around the special teams. The defense, I’m sure, is looking forward to having more field to defend.
by 13thieves on Jul 25, 2009 1:37 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
LOL
Buddha. Maybe Deebo could pad his retirement account by hiring a good lawyer and filing civil suits against the majority of left tackles in the league. Good point on injuries, always an X factor. I would add Marvel Smith to the list from this past season, but decided to follow Tomlin’s lead; no excuses.
by RickVa on Jul 25, 2009 1:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Ha
Yeah – I am pretty sure he has a solid case there, considering the number of tackles (pardon the double entendre) and sacks that he left on the field last season. I think we at home games the fans have to start chanting holding after every defensive play in which Harrison rushes the QB. After a while refs are just going to get frustrated and call something. For another year or two – there is NO blocking the guy – especially with the grizzly bear dressed in a football uniform that we have playing at the other linebacker spot.
by SteelerBuddha on Jul 25, 2009 2:50 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Good point about the fans mternes
I don’t know if it is a sense of entitlement that creeps in but it seems that the fans sometimes seem to forget that they can play a valuable role in supporting the home team and pressuring the opponents.
by RickVa on Jul 25, 2009 1:46 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
although
I’ll say that at the games I’ve been too the crowd can sometime “switch it on” (a term I’m adopting from swissvale). When the game gets late and it’s still close you hear the song Renegade come on and all the sudden the crowd is a beast. It’s always a pleasing feeling when you see frustration set in on the offense as they can’t communicate, and you see our guys hopping around feeling the energy. I have to say it’s one of the most amazing communal experiences I know of.
by Chicago Steeler on Jul 25, 2009 3:46 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Not Going to Go 6-0 in the Division
Another thing I would add: We’re probably not going to sweep our division again.
We are lucky that we have an easier out-of-division schedule, because I seriously doubt that we are going to sweep our division again. The Bengals are getting Carson Palmer back. They will be a better team, and they always play tough against us. Similarly, the Browns will have new confidence, with new management this year. And both the Bengals and the Browns had terrific drafts. The Ravens might not be better than they were last year, but they could still steal a game.
by PaulMorel on Jul 25, 2009 4:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
It will be a pleasure to take that
new found confidence away. Hey if it’s brown flush it down.
by steelerstyle on Jul 26, 2009 6:52 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I can live with that
if the Steelers beat the Bengals, Ravens, and Browns twice each.
This math only works if they beat the one that beats them in the playoffs.
by SNW on Jul 27, 2009 1:40 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
View From New England
I’m a Steeler fan who grew up in Western PA and now live near Boston. I have three disagreements with this otherwise excellent post.
1) "As for the civil suit? Forget about it. It will be used as fuel by both Ben and the rest of the team. The Steelers will use the emotions of the Haters to consume them." Really? Consume them? Maybe this bothers me because I’ve spent the past two years listening to every friggin’ Pats fan I know tell me precisely this about Spygate, right down to the "haters" characterization. It was part of every Pats fan’s denial and rationalization of that event. Fat good it did them in Super Bowl 17-14. This view also appears to operate from a certainty that Ben is innocent. If so I don’t see how you can say that. Let’s just say that the Steelers are immensely motivated and focused professionals and the civil suit will indeed be irrelevant to them. To say that the civil suit will rally them to greater heights is just wishful thinking.
2) The Pats are no more positioned for a fall than the Steelers themselves. They are the best team in their division, they have stockpiled high draft picks, they recruit free agents better than anyone (Leigh Bodden signed for the minimum wage for cripe’s sake), and they along with Dallas and Washington are one of the three teams to separate themselves from the rest of the league in revenues. The Pats have a bright future.
3) The Steelers’ wide receivers certainly led the league in linebacker jack-ups and I’ll miss seeing them, but, I’m inclined to believe that the league ultimately had player safety in mind when they made those rule changes.
That’s all. Be good.
by Eleye on Jul 25, 2009 4:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
View From New England Revisited
After re-reading my post, I’d like to add that Ben is indeed innocent until proven guilty.
by Eleye on Jul 25, 2009 7:47 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
2 points
1. I honestly don’t care what Pats fans, Colts fans, Cards fan, the mainstream media, Mel Kiper, Sister Mary Catherine, the Dalai Lama, Hugo Chavez or anybody else think about the Steelers or Steeler Nation. Hate, love, indifference, confusion, blah, blah, blah. I don’t think how anyone else feels toward them matters a bit in how Tomlin coaches, Ben throws, Hines catches, Troy tackles, etc. And I will be a fan in good times or bad no matter what anyone else says, does or thinks.
2. 2009’s team could be better and could finish the regular season with a better record. But if they don’t win when it counts the most, then they weren’t good enough. Sorry, but trophies matter.
But I am totally on board with most of the post. Timmons as a starter, getting Mendenhall and Sepulveda back, what Ziggy (I’m hoping) can do as inside pass rusher in the dime defense and what should be vastly improved talent at kick returner should make the Steelers an incredibly good team.
by pghnorthside on Jul 25, 2009 4:54 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Hate
Interesting take on the “hate” piece. The piling on Ben, in my view, is similar to the unbridled joy voiced by many (self definitely included) with last year’s “Down Goes Brady.”
The rule changes….much as I hate ‘em, and they may have some ill effect on the Steelers, one of my proudest moments this past off-season was the video of the NFL Meeting segment where those rule changes were adopted:
*First, you had what looked like a “We Got Our Ass Kicked by Steelers” support group clip with Marvin Lewis & Jack DelRio, sitting side by side, practically holding hands, bemoaning the rough play (although none of the Jax players were Steeler victimes).
*Then….LOVED it when first 3 of the 4 video clips were of Steelers ass-kicking, then Rich McKay took the vote, said "It’s unanimous? Oh….one “no” vote….Pittsburgh."
This is now the second time that Steelers play results in rules changes, first being the “Mel Blount” rule in the ‘70s. Only other example I know of is the Colts bitchin’ & moanin’ about Ty Law leading to the “point of emphasis” on d-backs contact, an emphasis that, karma being what it is, bit the Colts in the ass this past post-season against San Diego.
The business about the efforts to stave on the invasion of Steelers Nation at visiting venues, though? Is there any corollary? Does the requirement that fans seeking a ticket to a single specific game buy a ticket to another game put in place anyplace else?
by swissvale72 on Jul 26, 2009 11:03 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
2 more rule changes for specific players
i think the Roy Williams horse caller penalty was made almost specifically for him. Chuck Cecil flying helmet…I believe they brought out the rule about leading with your helmet on defensless recievers and Chuck Cecil of the Arizona Cardinals quickly retired saying he had no idea how to tackle otherwise. He was my favorite non Steeler at the time because he had no concern for his own body…kinda sick but the guy just flat out knocked people out…Ryan Clark must have been a fan too.
by black&goldtilldead&cold on Jul 27, 2009 12:39 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Refreshing piece
To transition us from the Ben fiasco to the opening of training camp. Thanks Rick.
Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history
by maryrose on Jul 26, 2009 11:42 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Great Article! Good points made!! Good luck steelers we have the talent to win superbowl again this year. Love you boys, God Bless the steelers
"That’s been our story all year. We’ve got a team that doesn’t blink in the face of adversity. It’s never going to be pretty or perfect, if you will, but they’ve got a great deal of belief in one another. They’ve got a great deal of resolve, and it was put on display. Our defense gets a lot of recognition for what they’re capable of, and rightfully so, but what you saw from our quarterback and our offense at the end of that football game is what they’ve provided for us all year. When we’ve needed it the most, they’ve done it and done it big. That’s a rerun for us."
Mike Tomlin, before superbowl 43
by steelcity7612 on Jul 26, 2009 2:34 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
good read
One – albeit minor – discrepancy – Tomlin has lost to a division rival – once. Dec 30, 2007 – they lost to Baltimore 27-21, although it was a meaningless game
by Jeebas on Jul 27, 2009 2:04 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 


















