Top Clutch Performances: Pittsburgh Sports History
How about the top clutch performers though, whether it be a moment, a game, or (less preferably) a season?
Here they, are the top 10, in inverse order:
#10: Roberto Clemente-1971 World Series
The Great Roberto batted .414, letting the world know what we in Pittsburgh had been treated to for years. His 12 for 29 performance included 5 extra base hits, including a pair of homers, one in the deciding 7th game against the Birds of Baltimore.
#9: L.C. Greenwood-Super Bowl IX
Dunno about you, but my one lasting image of the Steelers first Super Bowl win, is of L.C. playing volleyball with the offerings of Fran Tarkenton, 3 times batting his passes at the line of scrimmage.
For the record, L.C. didn't give a bad accounting of himself in SB X either, sacking Roger Staubach 4 times.
#8: John Stallworth-Super Bowl XIV
Steelers down in 4Q, and Stallworth hauls in a 72 yarder from Bradshaw for the go-ahead score, then make an over the head, falling catch on a similar play on the next possession to ice the victory.
Like L.C., one could also cast a vote for his other SB big-time performance, that of SB XIII where he made a pair of touchdown grabs.
#7: Terry Bradshaw-Super Bowl XIV
Like his teammates in the 8 & 9 slots, one could rightfully ask which Bradshaw SB performance nets our vote? Not often mentioned in a discussion of THE greatest quarterback of all-time, Brad was 4-0 in Super Bowls and threw a TD in the 4th quarter of every one. We'll take his final SB though, and his linkage to John Stallworth on whatever that play was called.
#6: Marc-Andre Fleury-Game 7
Again, one could argue that Fleury's defining moment was on the Dan Cleary breakaway with a little over a minute remaining in Game 6, that his teammates did a stellar job in keeping the puck to the edges of the rink in Game 7. True enough, but I'll take the final 6.5 seconds, and his turning away a pair of shots to earn the improbable Stanley Cup victory. I've watched this replay most morning since June 12th, and I never tire of hearing Mike Emrick, at the broadcast's conclusion, say, "...and the final 2 saves by Marc-Andre Fleury."
#5: Steve Blass-1971 World Series
Steverino, early on in his career, known for not finsihing games, in this complete game era, rang up a pair of complete game victories, including Game 7.Per Fleury, in games 6 & 7, Blass gave up a single run in both games, 3 & 7, surrending 3 & 4 hits in the respective outings.
In 1973, however, he contracted the illness to be forever dubbed "Steve Blass Disease," was unable to find the plate, walked 84 batters in 88 innings, and was essentially all done.
#4: Maxime Talbot-Game 7
Still can't figure this guy out. Scores 12 goals over the course of an 80-game season, then...
*8 goals in 24 playoff games
*4 goals in 7 Stanley Cup Finals games
*2 goals in Game 7
Clutch!!
#3: Ben Roethlisberger-Super Bowl XLIII
After having led his team to victory on the final possession on 5 previous occasions during the '08 campaign, Big Ben is faced with 88 yards in front of him, and about 2:20 remaining, down 4 points. He evades pressure, he buys time, and he's damn near perfect, leading his team to the winning TD...culminating in the scoring pass to Santonio Holmes, where Ben had only the very slightest margin of error. Perfect pass!!
#2: Santonio Holmes-Super Bowl XLIII
Forever and for all time linked with #7, Santonio had zero margin for error on the Catch, dubbed by some as the greatest catch ever, and this factor enables him to edge out Ben for the #2 slot.
I've watched this video, often repeatedly, most days since February 1st, and I'm thankful that when the ref was under the hood at Raymond James, we weren't being shown the replay from the rear. What appeared from the front to be both feet down, the right tucked in back of the left, was, for all but a split second, the right tucked behind the left, but off of the turf. Both feet were indeed down, but for the briefest of instants, necessitating Santonio to snag the pass with nary a hint of a bobble, similar, amazingly, to his goal-line grab a few weeks previous in Baltimore.
Santonio helps his case for #2 by making 9 catches on the game, 4 on the final drive.
#1: Bill Mazeroski-1960 World Series
Gotta go with the one swing of the bat that brought Pittsburgh its first championship of any kind in 35 years, sending the town into delirium. Once the offering from Ralph Terry cleared the 406 mark, with Lawrence (Yogi) Berra turning his back and trotting in, Bill Maz was to live forever as #1 in the hearts of Pittsburghers.
__________________________________________________ _________________
As an aside, I've argued that this June's 7th game Penguins victor in Motown qualifies as the Greatest Pittsburgh Sports Victory of All Time. Consider:
*Steelers were favored in all 6 SB victories
*Bucs were serious underdogs to the Yanks in '60, but did return to Forbes Field, needing to win but one game of two to take the Series
*Penguins were serious underdogs as well, homer series, final game at the Joe
I still hear two Mike Emrick calls...
a. "The horn sounds, and the Penguins have won the Stanley Cup!" (followed by 75 seconds, appropriately, of silence from the broadcast booth, in the best tradition of Ray Scott....yes, I timed it).
b. At the very close of the broadcast, after thanking his partners, "....the Pittsburgh Penguins are the NHL's Stanley Cup Champions. From Detroit, this is Mike Emrick, saying 'Goodnight, all."
Game 7...#1
12 comments
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
error, of omission, on my part
- (Tie): Willie Stargell-1979 World Series
Almost identical to the performance of Clemente in ‘71. Willie the Starge batted .400 (12 for 30), with 7 hits for extra bases, including 3 homeruns, his final homer a 2-run shot in the 5th inning of Game 7, putting the Bucs ahead to stay, after trailing, 1-0. Making this a complete mirror image, the 7th game was also in Baltimore’s Memorial Stadium.
It was Dwight White
White was sick before the game, but played a heck of a game and scored more points with his safety than the whole Viking offense.
I recently purchased the 5 Super Bowl DVD set and watched the game this week. Brought back a lot of memories. Mostly, of Greenwood playing volleyball with Tark’s passes and the Steel Curtain being completely dominant.
#7
That play was called ‘60 Prevent. Slot, Hook and Go’.
Even though it wasn't
in a Super Bowl, I believe Franco’s Immaculate Reception deserves a place in that list. At that point the world realized that the Steelers were the real deal.
My heros have always been Steelers...
compelling argument
Been made on another site as well….Everyone else on that list was cited for a play, a game, that brought a championship to series. Franco DID excel in Super Bowls, though not in the “pull the game outta the fire” vein. Another poster asked about Mario Lemieux…..the best……but no one play, one game of #66 brought a Stanley Cup to Pittsburgh.
Game 7: Pens v Wings
Not only did the kids beat the grown ups, but it was the first time in 30 years that ANY championship, in any of the major American sports, was won in game 7 by the visiting team. That’s clutch…and odds-defying.
breathe in deep feel your heart beat, just to know that life's worth livin'. feel your feet on the earth, better love it while it's still here spinnin'.
Holmes not #2
First off the Steelers were down by 3 not 4 at the start of that drive. If Holmes was so clutch he would have caught the pass before that went right between his hands. Ben on the other hand was clutch on both plays. Once again Ben gets overlooked for Holmes. I do agree though that what the Pens did was incredible. Going down 0-2 having to win 4 of 5 with game 7 at the Joe. Amazing. This has been an amazing year, and I doubt we will ever see 2 comebacks of that magnitude to win 2 championships in the same year.
Ben/Holmes
I don’t think Ben was overlooked, Six. He & Holmes are inextricably linked on the winning play. One could certainly argue, convincingly, that Ben should argue the #2 spot, or even #1. I placed Santonio in #2 as he really had zero margin for error on the play, while Ben had perhaps a smidgen…not much though. As for the previous play, in where Ben put the ball, as Santonio said, "where only he could catch it, " I’ll use Ben’s own words, “It really doesn’t matter, as I’m coming back to you (Santonio).”
I also don’t buy the Steelers being down by only 3 as mitigating in any way the heroics of this winning drive. While we were offered some relief knowing Steelers needed only a FG to tie…would we, as fans, have survived an OT?? Not sure I would have.
Asking for another asterisk Swiss
since my nomination came in a losing effort…Hard to be labeled “clutch” when the outcome was on the short end…Anyhow, Merril Hoge played his heart out in Denver in the second round of the 1989 playoffs. He gained 120 yards on just 16 carries and also caught 8 passes for another 60 yards. That’s 180 total yards on just 24 touches. If you recall, Hoge was not a big gainer, he was a grinder. His yards did not come on one or two huge plays, yet he averaged 7.5 yards per touch. Hoge almost single-handedly willed the Steelers to victory, but a rookie named Mark Stock dropped a pass right in his hands setting up what would have been the game-winning field goal. The Steelers lost by one point. Even the Bronco players praised Hoge’s game as one of the all-time guttiest performances.
I’m not saying this belongs on the list, but I thought it deserved an honorable mention. By the way, great job again of stirring up great memories.
Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history
Hodgie...
Thanks for the response, Maryrose. While Hoge’s play that day was nothing short of heroic, it would take a pair of asteriks to include him, as it was not only in a losing effort, but not in a game that could have brought a title.
Was quite the game, and the Steelers inability to put touchdowns on the board after a pair of second half drives deep into Denver territory cost them dearly in the end. I also remember the Denver FG right before half being questionable, due, I believe to a pass not being legitimately caught directly preceding the FG. Then, on Denver’s winning drive, Elway, as did Ben in the SB, had to overcome a 1st & 20.
Beinc a techno-dummy, I’ve not yet figured out how to edit my own stuff. I will tell you I’ve posted this piece on 3 sites, and have had a number of requests to edit my list. Being…flexible…I’ve done so with the addition of Willie Stargell and James Harrison. I’ve been steadfast though in not including greats such as Franco Harris & Mario Lemieux. Hal Smith is under consideration at the moment.
I don’t think I can add, Hodgie, Maryrose, but your note on Mark Stock gives me an idea for another piece. Thanks again for writing.

by 





















