COUNTING OUR BLESSINGS
A few comments and observations as a new season begins in earnest. A preemptive strike or two at the naysayers and the Lunatic Fringe of the Nation as we enter a period of high expectations. And maybe a prediction or two.
It has been said that a sign of a life wisely and successfully led is the ability to understand and appreciate the blessings that all of us receive on a daily basis. We are even more fortunate if we are able to see what we have while we have it. More often than not we, as the saying goes, 'never miss our water until the well runs dry.' So, in the closing hours of a championship off season, are you feeling blessed? Consider that 15 NFL franchises, nearly half the league, have never had a championship off season during the modern (Super Bowl) era. Consider also that even for an organization like our own which holds the record for Super Bowl victories, a championship must still be viewed as a rare event, occurring on an average of once every 7 years. And that number goes to show you how deceptive statistics can sometimes be. When Chuck Noll's 70's Steelers won the 4th Lombardi I had been married for about a year and a half and we were childless.When Bill Cowher's squad won the 5th my daughter had finished college, commenced her career and had started her own family. 25 years, a generation later. Nor was this some sort of peculiar quirk. In the 70's three coaches; Noll, Don Shula (Dolphins) and Tom Landry had combined for 12 Super Bowl appearances and 8 titles during the decade. Each man coached into the 90's. But from 1980 on they only combined for 2 SB appearances and 0 championships.
How about a more specific example? I moved to the Washington DC Metro area in 1987. That year the Redskins made their 3rd appearance in 5 years, winning thanks to a magnificent performance by Doug Williams. They would return to that stage one more time within the next four years. And then Joe Gibbs retired for the first time. Owner Jack Kent Cooke would die. The Super Bowl drought is now in its 18th year. This year the big news heading into the season is a front page article in the Washington Post. The picture shows a woman in her 70's, a Redskin season ticket holder for decades, weeping because she has lost her income and can no longer afford her season ticket package. The Skins, bless Dan Snyder's soul are sueing her. Feeling blessed now?
So why am I bringing this up now? While officially we remain the champions until a successor is crowned in February, we all will be swept up the drama of trying to repeat starting now. With expectations high and the margin for error slim we may quickly forget how good we've had it lately and how long it might take before we reach these heights again. Don't get me wrong. during the remainder of this post I will argue the possibility of the opposite, a rapid return to the mountaintop. Just trying to keep things in perspective.
I'm pretty optimistic about our chances this season. In fact, a lot of astute observers at BTSC have been pointing to this season for a couple of years as a probable opening of a window of opportunity where this team could make some noise. This does not have that much to do with what happened last year, that was pretty much a total surprise. The fact that the Steelers did win the championship in spite of significant lineup weaknesses, a brutal, unforgiving schedule and real bad luck in regard to injuries is pretty amazing quite frankly. As for this year; still some weaknesses, especially with the offensive line, but lots of depth, championship experience up and down the board, a lower bar to making the playoffs, excellent leadership. But still, no guarantees, particularly after the playoffs commence. And, of course, the normal disclaimers concerning injuries.
Mike Tomlin.I'm having trouble wrapping my mind around the fact that Tomlin is just beginning his 3rd year as a head coach. His strengths reflect those of a much more seasoned individual. Unlike a lot of young guys that bring a lot of high energy and emotion to their work, Tomlin seems to be more Zen like in his approach. Energy is channeled toward maintaining a high level of focus. Standards of expectation remain high regardless of who it is that is saddled with the responsibility to meet the standards. Most important, is that Tomlin himself is showing signs of continued improvement. I don't believe that it is just good fortune that the Steelers come out of training camp in a much better posture injury wise than last year. You have to watch carefully because they keep it pretty close to the vest for obvious reasons but this is one well organized group. And let's all hope the Tomlinisms keep coming. There'll be enough for a book eventually.
Ben. Ben hasn't peaked yet in his development as a QB. A frightening thing to consider if you aren't a fan. It appears that his legal problems will not amount to much and that he and his reputation will emerge relatively unscathed. He appears more at peace with himself as both a player and a leader. The sports punditry often lag behind reality. Herd mentality says that Brady and Peyton Manning have their own perches at the top of Mt. QB with Ben a tier or so down with the likes of Eli, Rivers, etc. If he can avoid serious injury and repeat that thinking will go out the window once and for all. Three championships, the same number as Brady, but at a younger age and one more than Peyton and Eli combined puts Ben no worse than equal to the absolute best.
Harrison.A number of people not given to hyperbolic conversation, including Tomlin and LeBeau are saying that James Harrison is better. Frankly, I have a hard time conceptualizing how such a notion will play out in the real world, but it can't be good for opposing offenses. He was just named a team captain as well. Be afraid. Be very afraid.
Special Teams.This is NOT a rhetorical question. I honestly don't know the answer for certain, but has there ever been a better combination of place kicker and punter than what the Steelers potentially enjoy with Reed and Sepulveda? Some quality contributors have been eliminated such as Madison and Davis. But a core including Fox, Bailey and Frazier remain, and hopefully newcomers like Summers, Lewis and Burnett will step up. And then of course there is Stefan Logan. For the first time in a long time we may not have to hide our eyes on punts and kickoffs.
Receiving Corps.Should establish themselves this year, if they haven't already, as the best ever for the Steelers. Better than the crew headed by Yancey Thigpen. And, yes, better than Swann/Stallworth. And this is coming from a [Cough] 'seasoned' observer who has witnessed all three groups. Strong headliners (Ward, Holmes and Miller) and great depth.
Defense. The only possible problem is that offensive coordinators have been working in their labs all spring and summer trying to figure out ways to bring LeBeau's defense to heel. Otherwise it's the same situation as with Harrison. They are not just good, they're better. And I really, really think that they are not just going to stop other teams, they're gonna beat the Hell out of them as well.
Limas Mendenhall.Last year's high draft choices stepping up is going to be really big plus for this team. It may not be until the second half of the season that the full impact will be felt. This is especially true for Mendenhall. Age matters and Rashard is still younger than some of this years rookies. Look for similar second half improvement from Timmons and perhaps Ziggy Hood.
The First Month Of 2009.I'm not so sure the Titans will be the factor in the AFC that they were last year. The organization has absorbed some tragedy, still seem to be struggling with just what to do concerning Vince Young, the Colts won't go away, the Jags are desperate and the Texans are improving. While it would be embarrassing for the Steelers to lose, this is a much more important game for the Titans. Here are the reasons the Steelers are likely to win. The Steelers tend to come out strong in openers, and that has been particularly true under Tomlin. They are also usually very successful on the big stage such as Monday Night games and situations like this one where the whole league will be watching. The Hoopla surrounding recognizing the championship, and despite what is said, the desecration of the Terrible Towel may also be factors. But most important of all is that I understand that the US Ambassador to Ireland will be in town. You don't think that the entire organization won't try to show out for the Chairman? Think about the 75th year celebration when they blew the Ravens out of town.
The Chicago game could turn on the play of special teams. Its going to be a very big deal in Chicago. Tough game to win.
The AFC North could be much tougher than imagined this year. Steelers have run roughshod over the division in the Tomlin era. But if Palmer is healthy the Bengals should be competitive. An important game that may resonate later in the year when it comes time to face the Ravens.
It would be best long term if we win at least two with the Bengals game being essential.
Some comments for the Lunatic Fringe.Because we care Steelers fans can get very passionate about the performance of the team. Occasionally, I believe we all make trips to what I refer to as the lunatic fringe where perspective and compassion take a back seat to generally negative passions. Now, while we all visit from time to time, some of us clearly live there. The danger in a high expectation, low margin of error (repeat or bust) kind of season is that things could get out of hand. With that in mind a few pieces of advice for fringe dwellers.
Bruce Arians.The recent spate of O coordinator firings have stmulated fantasies of throwing BA under the bus once and for all. I understand. I have had my issues with BA myself from time to time. However, consider the following; the Steelers just won the Super Bowl, Ben seems to like him just fine, it was not LeBeau's defense but BA's offense that pulled our fat out the fire in the Super Bowl and he is very quietly been fighting cancer. So I will write this slowly: B...A...is...not...going...anywhere...! Lower your voice. Have a seat. Take a valium. Take two. And enjoy the games.
The Running Game.Saint Jerome is retired. Franco has been retired longer. John Henry Johnson I believe is deceased. 260 pound running backs who can gain 10,000 or more yards in a career and can run over Brian Urlacker do not grow on trees. Besides, we are paying Ben entirely too much money to simply pivot to his left and hand off, then pivot to his right and hand off, and then pitch out left...If FWP and Mendenhall remain healthy we'll be okay. Really. Besides you can't just let two SB MVPs rot from lack of work. In the meantime, until the next truly great runner comes along hold onto your wallet and, perhaps, your private parts if someone comes along with any of the following nicknames: M-1 Abrams, Half Track, Hummer, Nimitz Class, Galaxy Class, Dump Truck, Eighteen Wheeler, Bulldozer, Earthmover, Hippo, Rhino, War Elephant, Water Buffalo, Killer Whale, Great White, Black Angus, Bronto, T-Rex, King Kong, Godzilla, Womb Killer, C Section, Big Daddy, Baby Huey or Tiny.
The Patriots.They're not even on our schedule. Nor are the Giants, Eagles or Colts. The Dolphins. Now there's a group that should feel disrespected with all this New England talk. Now if we meet in the playoffs, put our foot up their ass and that'll settle things. In the meantime, worry about the Ravens.
The Offensive Line.Let's take Darnell Stapleton as an example. About a year ago conversation about Darnell was that of a raw, young talent who people hoped would do well enough in camp so that he could make the practice squad at least, and, hopefully make the 53 man roster and even dress on Sundays. Injuries result in him being thrown into the starting lineup, way too soon and not in his position (center). He manages well enough that he heips us win the Super Bowl and we want to thank him by giving him a one way ticket to Palookaville. GIVE THE KID A FRIGGIN' BREAK!!! GIVE HIM TIME TO DEVELOP, OR PLAY AT HIS NATURAL POSITION BEFORE YOU THROW HIM INTO THE TRASH COMPACTOR.
Charlie Batch.The Sporting News recently name the Steelers QBs the best quarterback corps in the NFL. Not bad given one of them is a cadaver. Yeah, Ol' Charlie is getting up there in years. But I think he moves around pretty good for a dead man.
7 recs |
50 comments
| Add comment
Comments
Very nice write up.
Thanks for the insight.
Only a life lived for others is a life worthwhile - Albert Einstein.
by fanofsteel on Sep 8, 2009 10:35 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I've been trying to savor the last few days of the Steelers as Superbowl XLIII Champions
because it doesn’t mean a damn thing come Thursday night.
"It was an attrition football game and you know we like that."
by showtime on Sep 8, 2009 10:49 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
You mean they aren't the champs until next feb?
Then who is?
Bring a towel to the game. Black or gold or yellow. If you don't have one buy one, If you can't buy one, dye one!!!
by SoCalSteelerFan on Sep 9, 2009 4:15 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
I think Tomlin would agree...
Starting Thursday, everybody is in the hunt.
by smashtheguitar on Sep 9, 2009 11:14 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
except he would say it much cooler
like “When the first kickoff happens what happened last year dissappears” something cool is what he would say
by WVPiratesfan on Sep 9, 2009 6:01 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sorry, I drank all the Tomlin Koolaid in the fridge
you guys are gonna have to make some more
"It was an attrition football game and you know we like that."
by showtime on Sep 9, 2009 7:15 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
what Flavor is the tomlin Kool-aid
by WVPiratesfan on Sep 10, 2009 10:39 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Lombardi Flavored
I'll drink your Milkshake, I'll drink it up!
by drinkyourmilkshake on Sep 10, 2009 10:45 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
what falvor is that exactly
by the way I just put on my Hines Ward Jersey and I’m feeling like its gametime
by WVPiratesfan on Sep 10, 2009 12:11 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Great write up
Couldn’t agree more. This is the year that many people pegged as our best chance to win…and it is. All the pieces seem to be in place, it’s time to execute. As Steelers fans, we couldn’t be more lucky.
breathe in deep feel your heart beat, just to know that life's worth livin'. feel your feet on the earth, better love it while it's still here spinnin'.
by NoCal-SteelCity on Sep 8, 2009 10:57 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Thanks for reminding us!!!
RickVA has some great points. I became a Steeler fan in 1975 when I was 12 years old. I have had the blessing of seeing some great Super Bowl years and then a drought. We are truly blessed to be the fans of a SUPERB organization the likes of which there are few in this league.
by Durangosteve on Sep 9, 2009 12:02 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Thanks....
…great post. Well written and it was well needed. Though I wonder, should the use of caps is be a sign you may be wondering close to the lunatic fringe?
And as someone who began a Sunday Valium regimen two years ago, I feel compelled to advise the effects of said Valium becomes proportional to B.A. play calling when taken with a considerable amount of Vodka.
VavavaVoom!!!
Happy days are here again.
Vodka and Valium are here again.
Tada da da da da da dada!
Happy days are here again. Woooooooeeeee!
!
by Marvin, The Paranoid Android on Sep 9, 2009 12:05 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
T-Rex is on the Practice Squad...
…sadly he’s a Center ;)
by KiwiSteelerFan on Sep 9, 2009 12:46 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Cancer?
Nice post. I agree with your sentiments. I am surprised to hear about BA fighting cancer … I had never heard this before. I hope that he is alright.
And I agree about Arians. I haven’t liked all of his decisions, but he’s doing well with what he has to work with. He’s getting the most out of Ben and the WRs, even if it is coming at the expense of the running game. And how much better could he really do, with our O-Line?
So … I used to be a BA hater, but I have broken the habit, and I think it will stay that way.
by PaulMorel on Sep 9, 2009 1:32 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Great Post (yes Upper Letters) RickVa so damn good that almost feels as non-football masterpiece.
I also (as PaulMorel points out) used to be a BA hater, this cancer issue makes me feel bad about Bruce Arians, but also makes me feel very good about those Model of human relations that is this organization headed by The Rooney´s Family.
Also, Thanks for the insight. As Fanofsteel said before.
P.D.: This could be almost perfect, but still I like Ra´shon Harris.
O sales tickets,...and let D rest a little, and D Win Championships.
by YeOldeMexFan on Sep 9, 2009 2:43 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Did you notice...
As part of my fix for the past few weeks, I watched the playoffs and Superbowl over again, along with the pre-season games on NFL Network. GIven the Arians references, I noticed that Mewelde was used for the occasional screens last year, but then I started seeing them more often in the pre-season this year with several backs.
I know that last year several of us (prob me too) were seeing perfect opportunities for the offense to use a halfback screen when pressure came quick, and were publicly scratching our heads as to why it wasn’t used more.
Well, guess it’s being used more. As you prob know, I don’t have a huge football background, but was one of two things that stuck out for me when I went back to the video.
With a healthy running game (and a learning Redman on the PS), Ben staying more upright in the pre-season, Limas starting to show flashes, and Offensive Line 2.0, I feel pretty good about the offense going into September ball.
PS. The other thing that stuck out to me was that the offense lit up when Ben went to no huddle in the Buffalo pre-season game. WOW
PPS. Thanks all for your insights and comments week to week when I check in. Idaho is a long way from Western Penn, but always feel a part of the city again when I visit the site.
by BoiseSteeler on Sep 9, 2009 2:59 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Great Write Up!
I have been to the lunatic fringe….does the term “apoplectic” ring a bell?
"Whaddya' mean all the beer is gone..?
by OhioYinzer on Sep 9, 2009 5:35 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
"I have a hard time conceptualizing how such a notion will play out in the real world"
That’s a great quote, and I share your sentiments. I try to imagine a spontaneous wormhole forming directly over Heinz Field and the entire universe collapsing into it. That’s the only way I can conceptualize James Harrison being better this year than last.
by CarlWeathersMustache on Sep 9, 2009 9:07 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Of course
They may have just been referring to him getting his long snapping problems under control ; )
by RickVa on Sep 9, 2009 3:20 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
maybe
that would require him to become less strong
by WVPiratesfan on Sep 9, 2009 6:02 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Whew!
Right on Rick Va! And thank you for letting those Bruce Arians haters have it. And Also, I loved the part about the run offense that we read about continuously. Yes, Ben is getting paid a ton a dough. We should be thowing the ball. Plus that’s what he wants to do anyway.
Thanks Again for the great write up.
by C-Mac on Sep 9, 2009 10:00 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
The Washington Post really came out guns-a-blazin at the Washington Redskins. I thought their piece was probably a necessary evil even though I think both sides (Redskins and Post) used information to distort the truth of the situation that was going on.
I'll drink your Milkshake, I'll drink it up!
by drinkyourmilkshake on Sep 9, 2009 10:19 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Good stuff, and I especially agree with your remarks about Ben
I thought he looked outstanding in the pre-season. His reads were so much quicker and he looked relaxed and supremely confident. I think the input he’s had on developing the passing game and his continued maturity have helped slow everything down for him. Plus, last year was the first year he called the protections, so having more familiarity in that area should help as well. It really does seem like he’s going to get better. That is definitely a blessing worth counting…
by cliff harris is still a punk! on Sep 9, 2009 10:25 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Awesome Rick!
Thanks for the perspective.
TOMLIN; a great coach that will certainly make mistakes but is getting better all the time. Every week he learns something and every year he improves some facet of the Steelers game.
BEN; an up and comer with 2 rings. As Howard Jones sang “things can only get better!”
SPECIAL TEAMS; should definitely be an improvement. Field position should be better this year (Logan & Sepulveda) thus the D should be in better position and better overall.
RECEIVING; going to have to wait to put Ward and Holmes over Swann, Stallworth, Lewis, Jimmy Smith & Grossman. Sweed and Wallace have about 6 career catches between them. Catch the damn ball Limas and 50s happy.
LUNATIC FRINGE; usually they are off the edge but sometimes they are right. Of course even a stopped clock is right twice a day.
BA; didn’t know about his cancer. Hope he beats it and stays healthy. Hope he scores a HUGE contract from Al Davis as coach of the Raiders after our 7th title.
OL; I’m with you Rick. Let them develop and form some cohesion. Biggest issue I have is not with the OL but with the OL bosses (Z & A) who I feel do not have a grasp on who is talented and who is not or how to exploit their players strengths and minimize their weaknesses. Coaches need to be great teachers (see Chas Noll) and as much as Z & A probably know, I do not think they teach it well enough to the players.
PATS*; do not kid yourselves. They have gotten older and lost some vets. They still have Brady and Belicheat* That will be enough to win the AFCE and get invited to the dance. Once there, Brady is a “dancing with the stars” former winner…3 times. Do not underestimate that.
When You Run The Ball Good Things Happen
by 5020 on Sep 9, 2009 10:55 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
A well-timed piece, thank you
When the Steelers beat Seattle, I told Mary Rose that she needed to soak it all in, every moment, all the post-game, etc. I told her she may never experience it again in her lifetime and that she needed to take advantage of the moment. I told her the same drill again after Arizona, though lately she finds it hard to believe that a lifetime drought can exist. Just ask Detroit, Cincinnati, Cleveland, etc. etc. etc., as you mentioned Rick.
I also tell her that while we revel in the glory of a championship, that is not the reason we are fans. We are fans because we love the Draft, the preseason, the tailgating, the games, the press conferences, the speculations, the banter on BTSC and all the trimmings. The real joy is in the journey, not the glory at the end. If our joy was based soley on being a champion, we would lead very frustrating lives. Better not to even be a fan at all.
I found it repulsive that Pitt fans booed Bill Stull last Saturday. I have never booed a Steeler in almost 50 years and never will. They are my guys. They wear the black and gold. It is not possible for me to boo any man wearing those colors. I didn’t in 1969 when they went 1-13, so I won’t ever. That’s like booing one of my kids. No matter how they fall short, they deserve my support and they will always get it.
Let the 2009 party begin!
Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history
by maryrose on Sep 9, 2009 11:03 AM EDT reply actions 5 recs
Great points as usual, MR
After XL, I wanted to buy a bunch of memorabilia (which I did), and I recorded the SB to a DVD so my son could watch it in 10 years. He was 2 1/2 at the time. After XLIII, I still wanted to buy memorabilia, but couldn’t afford it this time (Only got the team picture). I did, however, record highlights from NFL Replay throughout the season (as well as NFL Replay Realtime, Livewire, and Starting 11), in addition to recording the entire playoffs, so that I and my children could re-live this season. Because, as you said, it could be the last SB win we see in our lifetimes. I was 6 for XIV, which is the first SB I saw live on TV. I had no clue before that.
As far as the booing, if only the rest of Steeler fans had felt like you, Bradshaw may have returned to Pittsburgh earlier.
For ideas on statistical analyses, email me at wolfpacksteelersfan@gmail.com.
by WolfpackSteelersFan on Sep 9, 2009 12:37 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Soaking it in
The only thing is I am a little embarrassed by the 2005 Super Bowl. I never reveled in it. The game shouldn’t have been close, and I hate the fact that the ref’s calls were to focus of the game. To me that was one of the most boring and sloppy Super Bowls in recent history.
OTOH, last year’s is one I still get chills thinking about. Great game. Great season.
Funny thing is I have a foreign wife, so she doesn’t get America’s fascination with sports. Her son has been drawn in though (as is my daughter). Since my blended family started, Pittsburgh has won two Super Bowls and been in two Stanley cups. A Pittsburgh team has only not been in the playoffs (not counting the Pirates, of course) one time.
My kids think it is always like this. I tried to prepare them for the heartbreak that is sure to come… but… there is really no way they can understand it.
So, rather than be a grinch, I’m just going with it…
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 10, 2009 9:40 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Sept 21, 2008
The Eagles embarrassed the Steeler offense, sacking Ben almost at will, including a safety, holding Parker, et al to 27 yards and holding the team out of the red zone until the final drive, where Leftwich was in the game due to an injury to Ben.
And while the defense remained strong, it was arguably the lowest point of the season.
There will be lowpoints this season, there will be moments where everything is going wrong, and it is difficult to believe the Steelers can right the ship, there will be injuries (though hopefully very few, and never lasting), and much of the outcome will depend on luck.
Going undefeated 4 or 5 games in the regular season is difficult, in the postseason, it is what defines champions, but failure to do so is not shameful in the least.
thanks for the post Rick, being a Steeler fan is a pleasure
by vherub on Sep 9, 2009 12:22 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
Great post!
Tomlin – I’m in awe of the guy. The Rooneys knew what they were doing. If he keeps this squad from letting down it will be a fine achievement. If there’s any man that can lead this team to another back-to-back he’s the one.
Ben – I wrung my hands through the whole beginning of the draft and jumped up and down on my couch when the Steelers drafted him screaming, “We FINALLY got us one!” No more Bubby’s, Stewarts, O’Donnells, etc. When it’s all said and done Ben will be spoken about with the same reverance as Bradshaw and Mean Joe. And that’s as high as it gets.
Harrison – Just another one in a long line of great Steeler LBs. I don’t expect anything less. Death, taxes and great Steeler LBs…
Special Teams – You know it’s bad when you find yourself thinking after a punt return, “5 yards aint bad.” Logan could be special. I’ve always envied teams that have had Whiteshoes Johnson, Rick UpChurch or a Hester. I hope they sign Reed. Almost every game you hear the announcers say how hard it is to kick in Heniz Field right before Reed puts another one through the uprights.
Receiving Corp - The jury is still out. Sweed has to prove it in real games and the rookie has to prove he can get open against first team defenses.
Defense – My concern is that with the majority of the teams now deploying a 3-4 defense it’s going to be much easier to prepare for and to find weaknesses. Coaches and teams copy what is successful, but offenses will adjust. It’s always been that way in the NFL. If the Steelers D stays in the Top 5 I will be happy.
Mendenhall - I like the guy. Always have. I think he’ll surprise demanding Steeler fans, but this is not the ‘run first’ Steelers of old. They don’t have Pro Bowl maulers at Guard and Center to lead the way as The Bus did in his prime. I like Mendy so much I took him as my 3rd back in my fantasy draft.
The First Month - It’s not how you start, it’s how you finish. I wouldn’t mind them starting slow and then slowly gel towards the end, and then get on a hot streak at the end. See XL Steelers.
Lunatic Fringe – I’m 48 years old and witnessed the good, the great, the ho-hum, the almost great and finally back to the top. Winning in the NFL is not a right no matter how good you are. I don’t care who the experts say is going to win and I don’t expect them to win. I just want a healthy, rested team that gets to the playoffs. This team with this coach will take care of the rest.
BA - He’s got more tools to work with this year and a OL that has played together. He’s got a special teams that will get him better field position. I’m curious to see what he does with it.
Running Game – I think FWP has another great year (or two) still in the tank. With a healthy, hungry Mendy ready to show what he can do. Coupled with a passing game that will open up the running game I’m much more optimistic this year than in the past.
Off Line – I don’t see an Pro Bowlers on this line. The Steelers haven’t drafted high enough lately nor have they made it a priority. I just hope that ‘good’ is ‘good enough’ again.
by RobZagnut on Sep 9, 2009 1:37 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
John Henry Johnson
John Henry Johnson was at Heinz Field last season for one of the celebrations. Unless he died recently, he is most likely still in a retirement facility in the Cleveland area.
regis18
by Schmedlap on Sep 9, 2009 4:02 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I stand corrected
wasn’t really sure of his status and published without checking.
by RickVa on Sep 9, 2009 6:11 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Great post!
The Steelers are all about finding ways to win despite the obstacles. It’s a privilege to be a fan and we should all be glad.
I particularly agree with you about those who want to write off young players without ever giving them a chance to prove themselves. Not every player can develop in 6 months or during training camp. I think Stapleton is a keeper and Mendenhall should get a good chance this year to answer his critics.
by Billy52 on Sep 9, 2009 6:19 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
OK… some of what you said is good… much of it is incredibly wishful thinking…
Mike Tomlin: Agreed. He’s a gem, and we are really lucky he’s here. He’s already passed Cowher as best Steeler coach ever, and is closing in on Emperor Noll.
And… I guess that’s where you and I part ways, because the rest of this post seems like real fanboy stuff… Which is OK, I guess. I mean, this is a fan site. But…
Ben: Three championships, the same number as Brady, but at a younger age and one more than Peyton and Eli combined puts Ben no worse than equal to the absolute best.
First off, I love Ben. I think he’s great and I would have given him the Superbowl MVP. However… If you look at his work in Super Bowl XL, you have to say that we won in spite of him. You can’t say that about Brady and the Patriots. I have no problem with Ben being named after Peyton and Brady. I think that is accurate.
Some of our Offensive Line problems is due to the fact that Ben takes too long to make up his mind in the pocket. Sorry. It’s true. A lot of Ben’s sacks are due to his inability to make a quick decision. Did you see the difference between Byron Leftwich and Ben in the Redskins game? Leftwich has probably the slowest delivery on the planet, and he was still making better reads and faster decisions than Ben.
Ben has the unique ability to scramble and make plays. It’s what makes him great. But gun-slingers tend to be a gamble… they win it all, or they crash and burn. Ben had a great run last year. But that does not make him a better QB than Brady.
Harrison.A number of people not given to hyperbolic conversation, including Tomlin and LeBeau are saying that James Harrison is better.
He’d better be. Because once the linemen figured out how to hold him and get away with it, he ceased to be the force he was early in the year. If the “collar block” is legal, I don’t see him getting as many sacks this year. That’s not a knock on him. But I don’t see how he can get to the QB when 300 pound linemen are allowed to grab him by the throat…
Special Teams.
OK. I actually agree with that one too…
Receiving Corps.Should establish themselves this year, if they haven’t already, as the best ever for the Steelers
.
You cannot be serious… Better than Swann and Stallworth — two HOF members? Please… Hines, sure. He’s an HOF lock. But Holmes needs to do a lot more than make a nice catch in the super bowl to make the HOF. And, while we’re at it… his catch wouldn’t have even been needed if he had caught the first one Ben threw him. You said you are a seasoned Steelers fan? Remind me, please, of one ball Lynn Swann ever dropped in any of the four Super Bowls he was in? Because I sure can’t remember any. And a few of his catches were the kind I wouldn’t have thought were humanly possible. Holmes had a nice grab. But compared to the ones Swann pulled in, it looked like a game of Sunday catch. Let’s not get too caught up in the moment…
Defense. And I really, really think that they are not just going to stop other teams, they’re gonna beat the Hell out of them as well.
We’ll see. Timmons is a better pass rusher, but worse at stopping the run. We are thinner at the secondary. Defense played lights out last year. It will be interesting to see how we manage this year.
Limas Mendenhall
You must be a seeing a lot more than I am. Mendenhall looks like Duce Staley to me. A straight up runner who can sometimes get you ten yards, but with no real breakaway speed. And, if the hole isn’t there (and I mean there in a big way) I have never seen a big man who falls down without any forward progress like that.
Limas? He has height. He gets separation. now let’s see him catch the ball in big games. I am not sure Ben really trusts him, which is a problem…
The Running Game.Saint Jerome is retired. Franco has been retired longer.
I don’t mind the fact that they are retired. But, did they have to retire the running game when they went? Because first and goal from the five used to be a given. Now it’s pray that Ben can find someone open, because our running “attack” sure ain’t doing it…
The Patriots.They’re not even on our schedule.
Right. Unless you are talking about that whole playoff thing. Then I’m pretty sure they will be on our schedule. And we never have much problem with the Patriots in the regular season, anyway. It’s that damn AFC championship game where we’ve had problems…
Look, I admire your optimism. I hope you are right.
But we don’t win just because we have that cool logo on the side of our helmet. It is going to be a dogfight this year.
Your post makes it sound like we are going 16-0. We’re not.
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 9, 2009 10:40 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
About the receiving corps
I’m pretty sure Rick wasn’t claiming Holmes/Ward are better than Swann/Stallworth. I didn’t read it that way. Swann and Stallworth are the best pair of starting receivers on one team in NFL history. The depth now, including Heath, Moore and two promising WRs COULD be better than the Steelers have ever had. When Swann and Stallworth were established starters, Frank Lewis was hurt a lot and Jim Smith didn’t develop. Tight ends were rarely used. Of course, with Swann and Stallworth they didn’t really need any depth but the game is different now. And I’m loving all the pessimism everywhere about the running game and Mendenhall in particular (Duce Staley, are you kidding?). Let’s see how it goes but 2,000 yards in team rushing is not out of the question by any means.
As for Ben, I don’t think any impartial observer would rank him higher than No. 3 in the league. I agree with you. I also wouldn’t trade Ben for any quarterback in the league. He’s got two rings, he’s strong as a horse and he’s going to get better. You’re welcome to Brady and Manning.
It’s crazy to predict 16-0. 14-2 and another Super Bowl is not that crazy IMO.
by steeler.lifer on Sep 10, 2009 1:14 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Maybe 14-2. I’ll be happy with 12-4 to be honest. Let us get through the season healthy, clinch the division, and let the pedigree take over. I’m good with that.
But I am not giddy right now, hours before kickoff. I do not expect a blow-out tonight. And if we start the season 3-1 I will be really relieved.
Santonio came up huge in the playoffs, and of course in the final drive of the Super Bowl. But he didn’t seem to be that guy in the regular season. There are two possibilities for that. One, he matured as the season went on, and he has evolved. Or… and this is just as possible… the opponents looked at our games and decided: “We stop the run, and take away Hines Ward. That should do it…”
I love Santonio when he gets his hands on the ball. He reminds me a bit of Stallworth with YAC ability. But I just don’t see him beating guys and getting separation much. We’ll see. As for the Steelers of the 70s receiving corps… it’s hard to say. The game was different then. Most teams ONLY had two quality wide outs, and four wide receiver sets were pretty much unheard of.
I’m just saying… can we PLEASE wait until this receiver corps has won… say… TWO super bowls before we state they are better than the guys who won four?
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 10, 2009 9:18 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
BTW, about that running game...
Last year, the Steelers had the worst running attack that they have had since the AFL merger.
This year, they return, essentially, the same offensive line to try it again. Willie Parker is a year older, and there is concern that he carried the ball too much in his younger days, and is now running on broken parts.
There is a real correlation between running backs getting 300 touches in a year and running backs hitting the wall.
I’m not a fantasy football guy, but this is a nice breakdown of the phenomenon:
http://www.footballdocs.com/running_back_carries.html
If Parker can’t do it, do you really think Mendenhall is going to step up and be the guy?
Maybe if Logan, Holmes, and Wallace and gets some reverses or something, you might see 2000 yards in the season. But, 2000 yards between the tackles? With this line? Are you kidding me? We sure as hell didn’t get 2000 last year (we finished with a gaudy 1690… wooo whoo!) . What makes you think we are going to do it this year?
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 10, 2009 9:33 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
A good topic for another thread
It might seem unreasonable to have high hopes for the running game. Probably worth a separate thread, but here’s my basic argument for a better running game:
1. Three healthy running backs. Yes, last year we also started with three healthy running backs, but it only lasted three and a half games. We didn’t really know what we had in Moore until after the Baltimore game. He hadn’t even caught a pass in the first three games. Mendenhall is an enigma but a year older and closer to making an impact.
2. Better blocking from the tight ends. Spaeth seems to have improved considerably. Johnson is a blocking beast.
3. An upgrade at RG and better play at RT. We run right most of the time. Anyone who has watched Colon this preseason can see he is becoming dominant at times in the running game.
4. The Tomlin effect. He’s given Arians a long leash but I think his hands will be all over the running game this year. It started at the draft by taking a run-blocking G, a power RB and a blocking TE-HB who was a perfect fit for this offense. That was the tip-off for where his head is at in regards to the offense. His frustration last year was palpable.
5. The schedule. Yes there are some tough games. Bad teams can improve. But it’s not the meat-grinder that last year’s schedule was. None of the AFC West teams will be tough to run against.
by steeler.lifer on Sep 10, 2009 12:19 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
We can spin this off if you want...
But I’m betting that after tonight’s anemic performance by the running game, you probably want to wait on that debate/discussion.
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 11, 2009 1:02 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
But Ben is still learning
When you consider the relatively short time that Ben has been in the league, I think he’ll probably be in a class by himself by the time he retires. I wouldn’t trade him for any other QB in the league.
by Billy52 on Sep 10, 2009 12:58 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
In my own defense
In my post I tend toward optimism and make no apologies about that, but giving the impression that we go 16-0? That’s crazy. Let me respond to one of your points. Yes, I am a seasoned fan, and one thing I know is that Swann, indeed did not drop a ball in SB IX. Of course he never CAUGHT a ball that game either. He was a total non factor. In their first year with the Steelers Swann and Stallworth didn’t even start (Frank Lewis and Ron Shanklin were the starters). The first and second tandem alternated quarters. I think he said in his own words that a big part of what motivated him to do so well in SB X was based upon what didn’t happened the previous year. But the more important point was made by LIfer. If we are just comparing wideouts than I concede your point. But a receiving corps. IMO also includes a tight end. I notice when you reference “Swann/Stallworth” you fail to include a tight end. And I suggest that oversight was because while we had some really great guys playing the position (Brown, Grossman, Cunningham, etc.) there was no one who was nearly as complete and top tier as Miller. It is the comprehensive nature of the current group that, all three potential Pro Bowlers that forces me to the realization that when it is all said and done (And Santonio is just getting started) that this group with also some very capable back ups will be considered the best.
by RickVa on Sep 11, 2009 7:31 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Swann/Stallworth vs current core
Ummm… actually Swann did start his rookie year — towards the end of the year. You don’t remember his game winning touchdown against the Oakland Raiders in the AFC Championship game? He also returned punts and led the NFL in punt returns that year.
But, rookie years don’t matter… just ask Hines Ward.
Holmes is on a mission to show us what he can do this year. Ward has shown us what he can do. But Swann and Stallworth are in the HOF. We know what they can do. Feel free to say you are excited about this new receiving corps. But don’t compare them with HOFers and tell me they are better already. (which is what you claimed in your post).
Even though the idiot Collinsworth said something similar. I about choked on my beer when they showed Swann at the game and Collinsworth said something like no catch Swann ever made was as big as the one Santonio made last year.
That smacks as jealousy to me, because Swann made catches that defined the Super Bowl. There was no doubt who the super bowl mvp was in super bowl ten. To be honest, I don’t even think Santonio should have gotten it in this past super bowl — I think it should have gone to Ben.
Santonio made a nice grab and kept his toes in, which was good. But that catch could be made by a half a dozen guys in the league. Probably hundreds of guys who have been in the league. The ones Swann made in Super Bowl X defy description. I’m not sure that there have been three receivers in history that could have made them. Maybe only one.
Everyone focuses on the incredible falling down and batting catch he made. Equally as impressive is the one where he jumps up, catches the ball out of bounds, and then somehow brings his feet back in to land in bounds, while his body is still out.
If you have ever seen the sideline shot of that catch, it is just impossible. I heard Jack Ham say he was standing right on the sidelines and he still doesn’t know how Swann made it.
That is a hell of a lot harder than tapping two toes in bounds in the end zone. And, I’ll repeat, before Holmes was the hero, he dropped the game winner. Swann dropped nothing. Ever. You are right, nothing was thrown Swann’s way in Super Bowl IX. But the Steelers were a different team then.
That’s why it was so critical that Swann and Stallworth never dropped anything. They didn’t get many chances.
Look… I hope Holmes ends up being a monster receiver that ends up in the Hall of Fame. (And if he does, I hope he is still a Steeler.. but who knows?) But lets not put him there after one really great Super Bowl.
As for Tight Ends — you can’t even compare them. The Steelers tight ends of the seventies were blockers. They weren’t drafted to catch the ball. I remember Myron Cope exclaiming once: “Yoy! The Steelers threw a gadget! They hit their tight end!”
Saying Miller is better than Cunningham is like saying a Porsche is better than a tractor — you might think so on the road, but I can’t see the Porsche pulling a stump out of the mud.
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 11, 2009 10:31 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
One more try
I’m really not trying to diss Swann/Stallworth. In fact I’ll help you make your case on SB X, one that you have overlooked. There was doubt that Swann would even play in that game. George Atkinson jacked him (cheap shot?) up so badly in the AFC Championship game that Swann was hospitalized for days with a concussion. It wasn’t all that clear he would play. And as for dropped balls don’t forget the touchdown pass that Ward dropped in the endzone in SB XL. I even agree with you on who should be MVP in this year’s game (Ben).
On the other hand, I think you put entirely too much emphasis on Holmes’ drop when you consider that the team might not be in the Super Bowl without the performance of Holmes throughout the playoffs; his punt return vs the Chargers, his touchdown catch vs the Ravens, as well as the one that the officials mistakenly took away from him. And if you watched the game on Thursday I believe we can say that the light has come on for him. Now, I agree with you that he is a long way from being a HOFer, but if you read what I have written, that is not my arguement. I am talking about ensembles, not individuals.
As for the tight ends — It hasn’t just been the 70s Steelers that underutilized the tight end. In fact, one of the good things I can say about Arians’ offense is that it does provide generous opportunities for the tight end. Of course it would nonsense to not exploit the talents of Miller. I do have to disagree with your Porsche analogy. Miller is a very good blocking tight end, and if you check he’s probably executing against larger men than Cunningham had to deal with.
So, I would say that Stallworth is the best WR in Steelers history based upon the combination of pure ability and skill in executing his position plus numbers. Swann is the most spectacular and the best pure athlete, though his production is low relative to other HOF receivers; which probably one of the reasons along with the competition with his own teammates that Swann was selected so late. In fact, given the team philosophy receiver production will almost always seem low relative to other teams. Having said that I still contend that the current ensemble of Steelers receivers is probably the best GROUP of receivers because:
Hines Ward has already statistically surpassed both Swann and Stallworth and has the opportunity to do what neither of them accomplished; be a first ballot HOFer. And where Swann was uniquely graceful and balletic, Ward is uniquely brutal; a fierce and dangerous football player who happens to play WR and has had to be specifically (like Mel Blount) legislated against. I would also add that WRs that are also team captains are rare.
Holmes, a first round draft choice – and a high one at that -like Swann, and like Swann is a quality punt returner as well as WR. He seems to have reached a point where he is able to show excellence on a consistent (game to game) basis. Good blocker, excellent after the catch, chemistry with Ben improving. And, yes, he hasn’t done it all yet, but at this point things look promising.
Miller, another first round draft pick. Probably best Steelers all around tight end ever, certainly in the running for one of the best in league. At the very least he has helped to stop talk about Todd Heath in the division.
Back ups are big, athletic and faster with the wideouts (Sweed, Wallace, etc.) and bigger and stronger with the tight ends (Spaeth and Johnson), assuming rookies Johnson and Wallace fulfilling between 80-90% of their potential. Yes, I think this group in aggragate can and will be the best receiving corps in Steeler history.
by RickVa on Sep 12, 2009 3:49 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
aggragates are tricky things
My Ukranian wife tells me they have a saying:
“The average of temperatures in the hospital were normal: the people on the first two floors have fevers, and those on the third floor were dead.”
My point is that a receiving core should be measured by the starters first and foremost. Especially when comparing them to a an historical legend. We’ll never know how talented some of the backups were on the 70s Super Bowl teams because we never had to find out. (Pray to God we never have to win with Sweed and Wallace instead of Holmes and Ward…)
Let me ask you this: In the next Super Bowl, if you had the choice of starting Swann, Stallworth and Cunningham — in their prime — or starting Ward, Holmes and Miller… which three would you take?
If you say Swann/Stallwroth/Cunningham — then you invalidate your point.
If you say Holmes/Ward/Miller — then you need to go lie down and take a nap. Hopefully whatever you have will pass and you’ll be better soon…
by MarkJoel66 on Sep 14, 2009 7:28 AM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Ya know…It was such a Hines Ward team and that’s who a lot of us B-more fans focused on-for good reason. Then, he goes out in the first quarer of the AFCC. Pitt still wins. At that point, I had to just hands down give it to your franchise. Heart and soul on the sideline, no o-line, youth everywhere and you got it done. Tomlin is already a real pain in the ass.
by raven on Sep 10, 2009 2:06 PM EDT reply actions 1 recs
It’s very cool and intense to have such a heated rivalry with another team. When they met in the AFC Championship game it brought it up another notch.
When I was a kid the two main rivalries in the NFL were the Chiefs/Raiders and Redskins/Cowboys matchups. They just hated each other and the games were fun to watch. The Steelers/Ravens rivalry now equals them and NBC is going to have a hell of a game Sunday night on Nov 29.
by RobZagnut on Sep 10, 2009 3:18 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
so true. i used to love the oilers/steelers rivalry. i grew up in redskin territory and never saw the colts. we couldn’t get baltimore stations w/ the rabbit ears, tin foil and roach clips strung to the top of a cabinet. but we got a ton of pitt and skins games. my first jersey was jorgenson’s and then one christmas there was a full steeler uniform under the tree for me and my bro. i guess my parents kept track of who was winning.
we both still have them; overstretched from padding them with clothes and small pillows to look like LC and Green. they were ordered out of a Wards catalog. i wished them to victory over the cowboys every year partly because of the skins and a deep hatred for anything cowboy.
by raven on Sep 10, 2009 5:28 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
a little late but I'll jump in anyway
Receivers: I don’t think Rick meant that Hines and Santonio are better than Swann and Stallworth, he meant as a whole unit they might be the best we’ve had. If that is what was meant then I have say the potential is there. In over 30 years I don’t remember a group this deep and diverse, we have burners and size and a possession receiver who seems to catch anything close to him so I understand that statement.
Repeating: The run game is the only thing keeping this team from making a serious run at several championships. The offense has more talent in the skill positions than we have had since the 70’s. The defense is a corner and a healthy Troy away from being extemely good. The OL is going to make or break us, and who knows if it is the talent or the zone blocking scheme. There is nothing working as far as the run game goes from the blocking, to the confused appearance of the RB’s, to the what seems like 3 sec long telegraphed handoffs from Ben. I will say a few more 360 yd. games from Ben and there won’t be 7-8 in the box all game long which should improve the run game in itself.
Tomlin: very good and getting better but it will be a couple more trophies before I can mention him in the same breathe as Noll. A draft like 74 would help his cause as well.
Special Teams: May be the best we have ever had, after years of it being a weak link I have to say it is a strength not only because of the obvious but coverage has been very good for the most part.
RB’s: There is talent there even though it isn’t showing much so far. I think the look of confusion will fade once we figure out how to at least get them out of the back field before the get hit. FWP has never been a huge make something out of nothing type back and it looks like the zone blocking is confusing him because he can’t decide where to go. Give him a hole and tell him where it is going to be and he can still get his yard but he in not an improviser like Chris Brown is . Mendy give him some serious carries and then judge him. There is no way he is comfortable and confident enough yet to just go off of instincts. He will need a lot smaller hole than FWP and I still think he can be more beast than bust. Memo- perfect for what they are using him for, he is not a full time all season back, he wasn’t in Minnesota and he won’t be here. Frank, honestly haven’t seen enough of him to form an opinion. Redman, everyone loves him but I have said in other posts and I will say it again, he is too slow to be the savior of the running game. He may be good as a lead blocker and those tough third and short but not as a full time back.
That’s about it, just hoping they either figure out the zone blocking or no when to say enough of this ****that line is too big to be getting pushed around like that.
by DarinS on Sep 13, 2009 3:12 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs

by 















