Troy Smith or Matt Leinart

Never put it all together in the Cowboys 3-4 and then he couldn’t stick with the Rams either. No reason for us to make him a reclamation project

Was a total bust. He never had the talent to be a starter for any kind of aspiring team. The fact that St. Louis cut him should tell you all you need to know.

he looked good compared to matt
also bobby is only good as a pass 3-4ILB sadly

And never panned out. Our version of the 3-4 is more complex than Dallas’s version, so I would have a hard time expecting anything out of him. Plus we have way too many prospects at Linebacker (never a bad thing)

Burnett was unlucky and fell victim to the numbers game. He wasnt a gunner on ST so he couldnt beat out Madison, and Butler just flat out outplayed him. He will find a team though, just needs to keep at it

Leinart deserved what he got, he almost reminds me of Ryan Leaf in terms of mindset, he just isnt as "out there: personality wise. He came to the NFL expecting success without having to really apply himself, and its stuffed up for him. Welcome to the Unemployment Line, I would be surprised if you are ever number one on a teams depth chart ever again.

That’s pretty interesting. I guess you never know what’s going to happen if you sign a big contract with a team on the decline.

I wouldn’t bother picking up either Leinart or Troy Smith. What’s the point? If both Batch and Dixon go down they’re going to be in major trouble any way.

The last thing this team needs is another quarterback to get the fans all hot and bothered. Not to mention the media.

So they are not in the market for another QB.

bring me Rhett Bomar, for a 3rd string QB he played pretty good against us, and if it wasnt for his college troubles he might have gotten drafted higher and became a decent QB, we could also cut either Leftwich or Batch and move forward with Bomar

All I know is it give them 6 weeks to decide on the player.
I figure Leftwich is going there, and that gives them another spot for an emergency QB. Someone mobile like Troy Smith, or someone from a similar system. Can never have too many Troy’s on the team. Similar system to Airens? ok forget that.
I was thinking the way Scott went off the field the other night, he would be another candidate for the PUP. I thought he was outplayed late in the preseason.

I know smith is just another version of Dixon, but I have always liked his game a lot and I think that he could start for a couple teams in this league (SF and Oakland come to mind)

I Lol’d. Trust me, you do not want this guy. He is NOTHING like Dixon.

i think we got the best one not named Vince Young, players like Troy Smith and Pat White are nothing more than little lanky RBs that can occasionally throw the ball (wildcat) the only mobile QB ive seen and had a little interest in was the vikings Joe Webb. But he is still on their roster. But the fact that they feel comfortable enough with him to back up Jackson next year when Favre “maybe” retires