Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Win or Lose, Boston Celtics' New Big 3 Era A Success

Seven Round 2011 NFL Mock Draft: BTSC's Three Weeks To Go Edition (Rounds 1-3)

Big Jay is at it again with the fourth rendition of his complete seven round mock draft for us here at BTSC. Like always, feedback always welcomed. Great stuff and many thanks, Jay!

Previous Seven Round Mock Drafts

 

Round 1

1. Carolina Panthers - Blaine Gabbert QB, Missouri

2010 1st Pick: Jimmy Clausen QB, Notre Dame

Team Needs: DT/WR/QB/OG/TE/DE

Rumor has it that the Panthers have stated internally that they will not select a defensive player with the first overall pick. That excludes Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers, Auburn DT Nick Fairley, Alabama DT Marcell Dareus, and LSU CB Patrick Peterson right off of the bat. Now it's pretty much down to UGA WR A.J. Green, Auburn QB Cam Newton, and Missouri QB Blain Gabbert. As much as I love A.J. Green it's rare that a WR goes number one overall, and he just hasn't received a lot of draft buzz since Julio Jones "out shined" him at the combine, so it's down to Newton or Gabbert. After Gabbert's pro day, where he wowed everyone in attendance, almost every mock draft will have him going to Carolina from now until the draft. Mike Mayock stated that he was as impressed with Gabbert's pro day as he was with Sam Bradford and Matt Ryan's. The new regime has no ties to Jimmy Clausen and with a pending rookie wage scale coming it won't cripple the franchise if Gabbert fails as a pro so owner Jerry Richardson can afford to take the chance on him.

 

2. Denver Broncos - Marcell Dareus DE/DT, Alabama

2010 1st round Draft Picks: Demaryius Thomas WR, Georgia Tech/Tim Tebow QB, Florida

Team Needs: DT/CB/SS/OLB/RT

I was genuinely surprised that Champ Bailey resigned with the Broncos. He seemed dead set on signing with another team. John Fox must be one hell of a salesman. The Broncos have several issues on the defensive side of the ball come the 2011 season. Even with resigning Bailey they still need help in the secondary as 2010 rookie Perrish Cox may be looking at some serious jail time in the near future as well with a pending rape charge. And to add to all of that, 2009 rookie Alphonso Smith (for who the Broncos traded a 2010 first round pick to acquire) was so bad that they traded him away after only a year. Upfront they need a complete overhaul of the defensive line.

Fortunately for the Broncos the 2011 draft is loaded with D-line and secondary prospects. I've seen a lot of mock drafts that have the Broncos taking Clemson DE Da'Quan Bowers given that new Head Coach John Fox used his first pick in Carolina on another powerful DE in Julius Peppers, especially since they will be switching to a 4-3 defense. But they currently have OLB's Robert Ayers and Elvis Dumervil on the roster and will probably have both of them playing DE in 2011. Plus there are lingering concerns over Bowers' knee injury. So this pick really only comes down to LSU CB Patrick Peterson or a DT like Auburn's Nick Fairley or Alabama's Marcell Dareus. DT is a much bigger need at this point after the Broncos released Jamal Williams and Justin Bannan.

 

 

3. Buffalo Bills - Cam Newton QB, Auburn

2010 1st round Draft Pick: C.J. Spiller RB, Clemson

Team Needs: OT/DE/OLB/WR/CB

First off let me just say it pains me to mock Cam Newton to the Bills. With every other draft guru already doing it, it make me feel like a sheep. Anyway it looks as though the Bills will continue their draft ineptitude for another year. With Buddy Nix's ties to the SEC and Chan Gailey's love of athletic QB's it does make perfect sense. While I agree that Ryan Fitzpatrick is not a starting caliber QB I don't think the answer is Newton and Buffalo has so many other needs at this point it's a waste to not take better advantage of their drafting spot.

NT Kyle Williams had a great year but he was the exception along the defensive line. Nick Fairley or Marcell Dareus would be perfect fits. As of right now there aren't any offensive tackles in this draft that are worth a pick this high so Buffalo will have to wait to fill that huge void until the second round. Also don't count out A.J. Green if Carolina passes on him. Green is an explosive player that would really open up the Bills offense and they currently have nothing at the position outside of Lee Evans, and yes I'm counting Steve Johnson. Another option would be Texas A&M OLB Von Miller who I've seen mocked to the Bills on a few different web sites.

Star-divide

 

4. Cincinnati Bengals - A.J. Green WR, UGA

2010 NFL Mock Draft Pick: Jermaine Gresham TE, Oklahoma

Team Needs: DE/WR/SS/RB/QB

The top three targets for Cincy will be Da'Quan Bowers, A.J. Green, and Patrick Peterson. Cincy's pass-rush was absolutely dreadful this past year except for Carlos Dunlap and Bowers would be a great addition. Current DE Antwan Odom is always injured. Unfortunately there is too much uncertainty regarding Bowers' knee. CB Jonathan Joseph is a free agent and if he's not retained by the time the draft rolls around the Bengals would certainly consider Peterson, who many feel is the best overall talent in the draft. The Bengals offense is currently in the midst of a complete overhaul. T.O. won't be resigned, Chad Johnson will probably be traded, and it sounds as though Carson Palmer is prepared to walk into the sunset unless he's traded or released.

So whoever QB's the Bengals offense in 2011 will need an elite talent like Green to throw the ball to, and Green is certainly the one to be that talent.

 

 

5. Arizona Cardinals - Von Miller DE/OLB, Texas A&M

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Dan Williams NT, Tennessee

Team Needs: QB/LT/OLB/OG/CB

A lot of mock drafts, including my own previously, have had the Cardinals taking a QB given all of the struggles of Derek Anderson, Max Hall, and John Skelton. But I believe given enough time Skelton can turn into a quality QB in the NFL. They would be better off signing a veteran like Marc Bulger or trading for Kevin Kolb. Coach Whisenhunt is in hot water already and cannot afford to have another year with a struggling rookie QB.

With Patrick Peterson still on the board it makes this pick very hard to predict. He would give the Cardinals one of the best young CB duos in the league when paired with Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie and he would replace Greg Toler who has been absolutely dreadful. I'm giving the nod to Miller for several reasons, not least of which is how ancient and anemic Arizona's pass-rush was this past season. Plus the Cards new defensive coordinator Ray Horton is of the Dick LeBeau School of coaching which doesn't put a lot of emphasis on CB's but rather on rushing linebackers.

On top of that Miller was by all accounts the top prospect at the Senior Bowl, beating all of the "elite" offensive line talent in Mobile, and was even seen being chatted up by the Whiz himself. During the game he did not disappoint and has assured himself a selection in the top ten of the draft. At the combine he even managed to increase his draft stock, if it was even possible, by running a 4.46 40 and dominating the drills.

 

 

6. Cleveland Browns - Patrick Peterson CB, LSU

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Joe Haden CB, Florida

Team Needs: WR/DT/DE/RT/OLB/CB

It's no secret that Cleveland's biggest need is for WR's. While Mohamed Massaquoi and Brian Robiskie have shown small flashes of potential neither one of them are ever going to be better than a solid number two at best. Unfortunately I see no way that A.J. Green falls this far and it's too early for Alabama's Julio Jones despite the clinic he put on during the combine. They will probably end up trading back to acquire more picks with someone looking to snag the top QB available if Gabbert or Newton fall.

Cleveland will be switching to a 4-3 defense and after cutting both Kenyon Coleman and Shaun Rogers it is imperative that they stock-up. However even though Auburn's Nick Fairley is still on the board I can't see a GM like Mike Holmgren passing on an elite talent like LSU's Patrick Peterson. Even though Cleveland used a top 10 pick on Joe Haden last year Holmgren has a history of taking DB's in the first round. Eric Wright had a disappointing 2010 season and is a pending free agent, Sheldon Brown is 32 years old, and pairing Peterson with Joe Haden would give the Browns the best young CB tandem in the NFL.

Also with Peterson available this is a prime spot for the Cowboys to trade up to get him, and with so many holes it would be good for Cleveland to trade back and acquire more picks.

 

 

7. San Francisco 49ers - Prince Amukamara CB, Nebraska

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Anthony Davis OT, Rutgers/Mike Iupati OG, Idaho

Team Needs: QB/CB/OLB/DE/FS

With a new coach this pick is going to be a difficult one to make. Obviously this Team Needs an upgrade at QB. Alex Smith is a pending free agent but Jim Harbaugh may feel he can work some magic with him. Troy Smith has been erratic when given his chances to play. Gabbert would have been the ideal candidate but as he's no longer available this pick is easy to make with Prince Amukamara. Nate Clements is due more than 15 million dollars over the next two years and is likely to be released sometime soon. On the other side Shawntae Spencer is very inconsistent. Aside from a needed upgrade at the Cornerback position they could also use an upgrade over Isaac Sopoaga and Ray McDonald at Defensive End. And San Fran needs to find players that can also be effective pass-rushers as well.

 

 

8. Tennessee Titans - Nick Fairley DT/DE, Auburn

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Derrick Morgan DE, Georgia Tech

Team Needs: QB/LG/OC/ILB/DE

With Vince Young and Jeff Fisher both out at Tennessee this pick has become incredibly hard to pick. They'll probably resign Kerry Collins who's good enough to play another year or two, but they really need someone to develop for the future. With the top two QB's already off of the board I can't see them taking a QB here anyway. Given the headaches this franchise has endured with one running QB I doubt they'll take another in Cam Newton if he's available anyway, but of course owner Bud Adams was so enamored with Young's athletic ability he could see an upgraded 2.0 version in Newton.

Ever since Albert Haynesworth left town they've had a hole along the defensive front. Given his rocky relationship in Washington it wouldn't surprise me to see the Titans trade for Haynesworth, of course that can only happen if a new CBA is reached before the draft. Another issue they have is the pending free agency of DE Jason Babin. He's 31 years old and will be looking for a big payday and the Titans will probably not want to pay the price tag. So with the top QB's gone this will come down to the highest rated DT or DE depending on the Babin and Haynesworth situations.

For the time being I'm going to go with Nick Fairley until Clemson's Da'Quan Bowers' knee checks out. It should also be noted that Tennessee's new D-line coach Tracy Rocker also coached Fairley at Auburn.

 

 

9. Dallas Cowboys - J.J. Watt DT/DE, Wisconsin

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Dez Bryant WR, Oklahoma State

Team Needs: OT/CB/FS/OG/DE/SS

The Cowboys biggest needs are at OT, CB, FS, and DE. Free Safety Alan Ball is decent but certainly not spectacular. Igor Olshansky needs to be replaced at DE. Doug Free is marginally good at LT and Mark Colombo is dreadful at RT, someone like Wisconsin's Gabe Carimi would be a perfect replacement for Colombo. OG Kyle Kosier is a 32 year old free agent. At CB, Mike Jenkins was terrible all year and has become a pass-interference machine, and Terrence Newman will be 33 years old before the start of the 2011 season. Watt has been climbing draft boards since the end of the college season and has surpassed Cal's Jordan Cameron as the top 3-4 DE in some circles.

 

 

10. Washington Redskins - Julio Jones WR, Alabama

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Trent Williams OT, Oklahoma

Team Needs: QB/WR/NT/DE/RT/OLB/CB/FS/RG/OC

Washington has so many needs it's hard to know where to start. QB is their biggest need but with Gabbert and Newton gone they'll need to look in the later rounds to satisfy that need. Clinton Portis has been released and Ryan Torrain is not a full time starter in which case Mark Ingram would make a lot of sense here. And besides that a QB's best friend is a RB. And whoever plays QB in 2011 will need a dependable WR to throw the ball to. Santana Moss is a 32 year old free agent and their best WR. On the defensive side of the ball the Redskins need a replacement for Andre Carter who is clearly not cut out to be an OLB in a 3-4 defense. Cameron Jordan would be good to replace Albert Haynesworth at DE. And at CB both Carlos Rogers and Phillip Buchanon are free agents.

Personally I feel as though they would be better off taking Robert Quinn to replace Andre Carter but I have a feeling that Dan Snyder is going to be so enamored with Jones' measureables that he won't be able to pass him up. Also if common sense prevails they would be wise to trade back with the Rams who are also in love with Jones and pick up some more draft picks to fill their many holes.

 

 

11. Houston Texans - Robert Quinn DE/OLB, UNC

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Kareem Jackson CB, Alabama

Team Needs: NT/OLB/FS/CB/SS/WR

Now that Wade Phillips has been hired to be the new defensive coordinator the Texans will be switching schemes to a 3-4 defense. Not knowing how the Texans will use what they have currently to fill out the new scheme makes this difficult. DeMeco Ryans will play ILB, and Brian Cushing could play inside or outside. Mario Williams will play DE and although he is very athletic he may not be quick enough to play OLB. That will still leave a vacant spot at OLB. In a division with Peyton Manning you can never have enough DB's and they really need a replacement for the recently released Free Safety Eugene Wilson, so a DB could also be chosen especially if Brandon Harris is still on the board.

They will also need a NT to anchor the middle of their new 3-4 defensive front. Right now it would be a reach for Baylor's Phil Taylor, unless they trade back, so they will need to wait until the second or third rounds for a NT and target Ole Miss' Jerrell Powe, Hampton's Kendrick Ellis, or Stanford's Sione Fua. Quinn is considered the last of the "elite" prospects and would be a great selection for the Texans.

 

 

12. Minnesota Vikings - Da'Quan Bowers DE, Clemson

2010 1st Draft Pick: Chris Cook CB, Virginia

Team Needs: QB/RG/SS/FS/CB/DE/OC/DT

The biggest question facing the Vikings in 2011 will be who is playing QB. Favre is definitely gone, Tavares Jackson has never shown that he's consistent enough to be anything more than a quality back-up and he's a free agent, and after a promising start against Philly rookie Joe Webb deflated his value with a dreadful showing against the Lions. In addition to needing a QB the Vikings also need to look for replacements for the Williams' wall as Kevin Williams will be 31 years old and Pat Williams will be a 38 year old free agent.

Add to that, Ray Edwards will also be a free agent and the Vikings stout D-line could look very different at the start of the 2011 season. They drafted Chris Cook last year but still have a lot of needs in the secondary as Cedric Griffin is very injury-prone and Antoine Winfield will be 34 years old to start the 2011 season. Based on the talent available Bowers makes the most sense as long as there aren't any lingering issues with his knee. Ray Edwards probably won't be resigned and 2010 rookie Everson Griffin can't seem to stay out of trouble so he would help keep Minnesota's reputation as having one of the best D-lines in all of football.

 

 

13. Detroit Lions - Tyron Smith OT, USC

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Ndamukong Suh DT, Nebraska/ Jahvid Best RB, Cal

Team Needs: CB/OLB/LT/OC/RB/SS

The Lions drafting philosophy is always to take the best available player. They could take one of the DE's available like Purdue's Ryan Kerrigan but they already have so much money and talent invested in the defensive line. They really need a CB but after watching Miami's Brandon Harris get burned by Michael Floyd in the bowl game it would be a reach to take him here. They also need someone at OLB to replace Julian Peterson.

On offense they desperately need some O-line help soon or Matt Stafford will become the next David Carr. Detroit will never climb up from the basement of the NFL if they can't keep their well-paid and prized QB healthy and upright. The only questions regarding Tyron Smith, about his lean frame from playing the 2010 season at about 290lbs., have already been answered when he showed up at the combine and weighed in at 307lbs. of solid muscle. This franchise can no longer kid themselves into believing that current LT Jeff Backus can anchor the blind side.

The only other player that I can conceivably see the Lions taking here is UCLA OLB Akeem Ayers as he would fill a huge position of need and would be one of the best talents available.

 


14. St. Louis Rams - Aldon Smith DE, Missouri

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Sam Bradford QB, Oklahoma

Team Needs: WR/RG/FS/DT/WLB/RB

The Rams really need to add weapons for QB Sam Bradford to succeed as well as adding pieces that take pressure off of workhorse back Steven Jackson. Unfortunately Alabama combine warrior Julio Jones is no longer available. After recently releasing O.J. Atogwe the Rams will have to target a replacement Free Safety in rounds two or three. They also desperately need to replace Adam Goldberg at RG so Mike Pouncey will get some consideration. On the defensive line they need a replacement for Gary Gibson, and even though James Hall is a good DE he's 34 years old. So this pick will come down to the best DT or DE available. Aldon Smith is an athletic freak who's drawing comparisons to Jason Pierre-Paul.

 

 

15. Miami Dolphins - Mark Ingram RB, Alabama

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Jared Odrick DT/DE, PSU

Team Needs: QB/RB/FS/TE/LG

In the 2011 offseason Ricky Williams will be a 33 year old free agent and Ronnie Brown will be a free agent with a history of injury issues. If he's available Mark Ingram would be the perfect option for the Dolphins. Given how ineffective Chad Henne has been at QB it wouldn't surprise me to see them target a QB if one of the top prospects is available. Defensively they could use an upgrade at ILB for the often injured Channing Crowder but that need will have to wait until the later rounds. They will also need to address the free safety position at some point because Chris Clemons can't cover anyone.

 

 

16. Jacksonville Jaguars - Ryan Kerrigan DE, Purdue

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Tyson Alualu DT, Cal

Team Needs: DE/FS/SS/CB/WR

Personally I think Jacksonville needs to replace David Garrard. Unfortunately the Jags seem to be content with him under Center. They could also use some WR help as well, especially if they don't resign Mike Sims-Walker. On defense they need someone generating a solid pass-rush. Aaron Kampman's body just doesn't seem to be holding up anymore. Kerrigan is a relentless pass-rusher with a great work ethic. They also need help at CB opposite Rashean Mathis as Derek Cox is no longer consistent enough to be counted on. And at both Safety positions the Jags need to find upgrades for Don Carey and Courtney Greene. In the later rounds they'll need to address Offensive Tackle depth after cutting Jordan Black.

 

 

17. New England Patriots (via Oakland Raiders) - Cameron Jordan DT/DE Cal

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Devin McCourty CB, Rutgers

Team Needs: OG/LT/OLB/DE/WR/RB

Current LT Might Light will be a 33 year old free agent this offseason. The Patriots could move Sebastian Vollmer to the left side but that would create a hole on the right side. It also appears as though Logan Mankins may be traded at some point regardless of the fact that he's been franchised. In addition to the Mankins situation Stephen Neal just announced his retirement. They also could use someone to help generate a pass-rush from the linebacker position. UCLA OLB Akeem Ayers possesses the kind versatility that the Coach loves. Cameron would fill the large hole vacated by the Richard Seymour trade to Oakland. I don't think the recent signing of Marcus Stroud will have any impact on their draft decisions as Stroud is at the twilight of his career and was probably signed as insurance because of the uncertainty of the CBA. If they don't resign Matt Light it'll be a toss-up between Jordan and Boston College OT Anthony Castonzo.

 

 

18. San Diego Chargers - Cameron Heyward DT/DE, OSU

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Ryan Matthews RB, Fresno State

Team Needs: OLB/DE/ILB/DE/WR

For statistically being first in the NFL in total offense and defense the Chargers have a lot of issues to address in the offseason. On offense they could see their WR corps become seriously depleted with the pending free agency of Malcolm Floyd and eventual trade of Vincent Jackson. A very tempting option would be Pitt's Jon Baldwin. He's a perfect fit for the type of WR the Chargers covet. Defensively they will need to replace pending free agent DE Jacques Cesaire. But more importantly they will need to get someone who can generate a consistent pass rush. Larry English was supposed to be that man, replacing Shawn Merriman, but so far has barely been noticeable.

This pick will come down to the top OLB or DE. Previously I would've had Georgia's Justin Houston but after watching him at the combine I don't think he'll be good enough in coverage to play OLB. If Wisconsin OT Gabe Carimi is still available he would be the perfect replacement for disappointing RT Jeromey Clary.

 

 

19. New York Giants - Anthony Castonzo OT, Boston College

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Jason Pierre-Paul OLB, USF

Team Needs: LT/OC/RB/OLB/OG

The Giants need a total overhaul of their linebacking corps. Michael Boley can never seem to stay healthy and Keith Bullock is just plain old. Akeem Ayers would fit Perry Fewell's defensive scheme perfectly. On the offensive side they really need a Left Tackle. They drafted William Beatty to fill that need but so far he's been very underwhelming. They'll have to address their needs at both Center and Guard at some point. Shaun O'Hara and Rich S off of injury plagued seasons. At this point it'll come down to Akeem Ayers, Mike Pouncey, and Anthoeubert with Castonzo representing the most valuable option.

 

 

20. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Adrian Clayborn DE, Iowa

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Gerald McCoy DT, Oklahoma

Team Needs: DE/ILB/CB/RT/OG

Tampa Bay certainly upgraded the interior of their defensive line with 2010 picks Gerald McCoy and Brian Price but they added nothing to the DE spot. Coming into the 2011 draft this is going to be a huge need for them. Fortunately there is a plethora of quality 4-3 DE's in this draft to choose from. Despite his past off the field indiscretions Clayborn is a relentless pass-rusher who slides due to an inconsistent year. The Bucs could also use a replacement for the ageless wonder Rhonde Barber so with Brandon Harris still on the board I could see the Bucs pounce on him if Clayborn falters during the draft process. And at RT Wisconsin's Gabe Carimi would be an option to replace Jeremy Trueblood. Also don't count out Akeem Ayers because Barrett Ruud and Quincy Black are both free agents.

 

 

21. Kansas City Chiefs - Phil Taylor NT, Baylor

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Eric Berry S, Tennessee

Team Needs: NT/OLB/WR/OC/RB

Personally I don't think the Chiefs will get far going forward with Matt Cassell as their Quarterback. He's got a very weak arm and his intermediate to deep passes always seem to sail a bit. However given their success I don't think they make a change anytime soon. They also need to add another passing option for Cassell in which case Jon Baldwin and especially Julio Jones would be options.

The rest of their issues lie on the defensive side of the ball. Tamba Hali was franchised but they really need another rusher to compliment him. Current Nose Tackle Ron Edwards is a free agent and the Chiefs could certainly use an upgrade over him anyway. GM Scott Pioli hit it big in New England when he drafted Vince Wilfork and will look to do the same with Phil Taylor. Taylor was one of a few who really improved his draft stock at the Senior Bowl by dominating the competition. There are some lingering concerns about his assault charge, which got him dismissed from Penn State, but that was three years ago and he has kept himself out of trouble ever since.

 

 

22. Indianapolis Colts - Gabe Carimi OT, Wisconsin

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Jerry Hughes OLB, TCU

Team Needs: OT/OG/DT/WR/SS

Charles Johnson, Tony Ugoh, and Adam Terry will all be free agents this offseason. Add to that Jeff Saturday will be 36 years old and his body has already started to break down. The Colts are in desperate need of an offensive line overhaul. Personally I think that Nate Solder or Derek Sherrod would be a better fit for the Colts offense but GM Bill Polian seems to have a thing for Big10 players. They could also target Florida's Mike Pouncey. Aside from the O-line they could also use an upgrade at DT in which case Stephen Paea would fit their defensive scheme. And after cutting the often-injured Bob Sanders the Colts will probably target another Hawkeye safety in the second or third round in Tyler Sash.

 

 

23. Philadelphia Eagles - Mike Pouncey OG, Florida

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Brandon Graham DE, Michigan

Team Needs: CB/OG/OLB/SS/RT

Philly's two biggest needs are on the offensive line and in the defensive secondary. Outside of Asante Samuel they really have nothing at CB. Ellis Hobbs has already announced his retirement and Dimitri Patterson was routinely burned. Offensively they need to do a better job of protecting Michael Vick. As far as I see it I think this pick will come down to Florida OG Mike Pouncey, Miami CB Brandon Harris, or Colorado CB Jimmy Smith. It'll be whichever player Andy Reid covets most and I'm giving them Pouncey as he is a perfect fit. The Eagles will still be able to find a quality CB in the second round and their top priority has to be the protection of Michael Vick.

 

 

24. New Orleans Saints - Justin Houston DE, UGA

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Patrick Robinson CB, Florida State

Team Needs: DT/OLB/DE/RB/RT/SS

It's a pretty safe bet that the Saints will draft defense here as their offense is as potent as any in the league. Their biggest needs are at OLB and for a DE to play opposite of Will Smith. With the signing of Shaun Rogers the Saints filled their need for a DT, albeit temporarily, to pair with Sedrick Ellis. They could also take an ILB and move Jonathan Vilma to WLB. On offense they could use an upgrade at RT over Jon Stinchcomb. At Runningback they have a lot questions marks. Pierre Thomas is a free agent, Reggie Bush is injury-prone and not worth the money he's making, and Chris Ivory is still pretty unproven. Based on their needs and the talent available Justin Houston makes the most sense. At the combine he looked to be in great shape at a well-defined 270lbs, but didn't look fluid in the Linebacker drills which will probably exclude him from the draft boards of the Chargers and Chiefs.

 

 

25. Seattle Seahawks - Jimmy Smith CB, Colorado

2010 1st round Draft Picks: Russell Okung OT, Oklahoma State/ Earl Thomas FS, Texas

Team Needs: CB/QB/SS/RT/OC

Matt Hasselbeck is nearing the end of the line, and Charlie Whitehurst is nothing more than a career clip board holder. There's a reason he could never beat out Billy Volek for the #2 QB job behind Phillip Rivers in San Diego. Pre-Senior Bowl this would have been a prefect spot for Jake Locker. Unfortunately there was no part of the entire week of practice or the actual game that showed anyone he is worthy of first round consideration but he did get a little bit of redemption at the combine. So if they opt to stay with Whitehurst for the 2011 season their attention will shift to the defense where a lot of holes will need to be filled along the front line and in the secondary. Any number of options could come into play here but I'm going with Jimmy Smith. Seattle's pass defense is atrocious with the exception of 2010 first round pick Earl Thomas and CB is perhaps their biggest need, especially with Kelly Jennings being a free agent.

 

 

26. Baltimore Ravens - Derek Sherrod OT, Miss. State

2010 1st Draft Pick: Sergio Kindle DE/OLB, Texas

Team Needs: CB/RT/RG/DE/WR/ILB

Offensively the Ravens do have a few issues at OC, RT, and WR. Current starting OC Matt Birk will be 35 years old at the time of the 2011 draft and Jared Gaither will probably be traded in the offseason. Even though most teams view Florida's Mike Pouncey as a Guard, don't be surprised to see the Ravens take him as a Center if he's available. At WR none of the Ravens starters are younger than 30 years old, and they need someone who can stretch the field vertically. Defensively everyone knows the Ravens biggest weakness is in the secondary. Chris Carr, Fabian Washington, and Josh Wilson will all be free agents this offseason. Last offseason Ed Reed gave some serious consideration to retirement as his mounting injury history is taking a toll on his body and as such 2010 may be his last season.

Because of this I would expect the Ravens to possibly target UCLA's Rahim Moore here or Oklahoma's Quinton Carter in the second round. Outside of Terrell Suggs they haven't been able to generate nearly as good of a pass-rush from their linebackers in recent years as well. I know they drafted Sergio Kindle in the second round of the 2010 draft, and it still may be too early to tell whether or not he's going to pan out, but they can't count on him to recover from a serious head injury. They could also use an upgrade at DE over Cory Redding who hasn't been that good in pass-rushing situations. Previously I went with Illinois ILB Martez Wilson to be the heir apparent to Ray Lewis and because of his potential to be an outside rusher as well. Unfortunately he had such a bad pro day that he's probably no longer going to garner first round consideration. Sherrod represents the best combination of need and talent. Marshall Yanda is a free agent and with Jared Gaither's back problems they'll need someone who can step in right away at RT or LT if they move Michael Oher to the right side.

 

 

27. Atlanta Falcons - Nate Solder OT, Colorado

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Sean Weatherspoon OLB, Missouri

Team Needs: WR/OG/OT/SS/CB/TE/DE

The offensive line is a big issue with starters Tyson Clabo, Justin Blalock, and Harvey Dahl all free agents this offseason. And Sam Baker really struggled in 2010 and would be better served playing on the right side. Tony Gonzalez has stated that he's 50/50 on whether or not he's going to retire at the end of the season. If he does the Falcons will need to find a dependable replacement to keep the offense moving in which case Notre Dame's Kyle Rudolph would get some serious considerations. After being absolutely abused by Green Bay's offense in the divisional round of the playoffs Atlanta's defense could also use an infusion of talent. DE John Abraham will be 33 years old before the start of the 2011 season.

In the secondary they could use an upgrade from William Moore as well as a nickel CB. I went with Solder because I expect Atlanta to resign at least one of their free agent Guards at some point, whenever a new CBA is reached, and can find better value in the later rounds at the position. Mike Mayock called Solder the next "Tony Boselli". Personally I don't see it but Solder is an excellent pass-blocker and if he can add some bulk to his extremely lean frame he could become a steal at the end of the first round.

 

 

28. New England Patriots - Akeem Ayers OLB, UCLA

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Devin McCourty CB, Rutgers

With no value at Offensive Tackle or guard the Patriots will almost assuredly take a defensive prospect with this pick especially with Florida OG Mike Pouncey off of the board. Given how much the Patriots like to trade back and acquire more picks it would surprise me if they stayed here. Ayers has the type of versatility that Head Coach Bill Belichick loves and would help them continue to upgrade their pass-rush.

 

 

29. Chicago Bears - Corey Liuget DT, Illinois

2010 1st Pick: Major Wright FS, Florida

Team Needs: OT/OG/DT/OC/WR

Offensive Coordinator Mike Martz finally discovered a play set that doesn't get Jay Cutler killed, however it's only masking the serious deficiencies on the O line. Frank Omiyale can't pass-block, Chris Williams is looking like a bust, and Olin Kreutz is a 34 year old free agent. On the defensive side they could certainly use some help in the secondary and a complimentary pass-rusher to Julius Peppers. And they also need to find a replacement for Tommy Harris at DT. If Mike Pouncey is gone at this point Liuget makes the most sense.

 

 

30. New York Jets - Brooks Reed DE/OLB, Arizona

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Kyle Wilson, CB, Boise State

Team Needs: OLB/DE/NT/CB/K/WR

The Jets have serious issues along the defensive line. Nose Tackle Kris Jenkins was recently cut after missing 25 games in the last 3 years. Also Defensive End Shaun Ellis will be a 32 year old free agent. They also have a serious need for pass-rushers, especially after cutting Jason Taylor and the woefully disappointing Vernon Gholston. Offensively they are relatively set except that they'll probably need a WR to replace Santonio Holmes or Braylon Edwards, whichever the Jets let walk in free agency. Of course it's almost an absolute certainty that if one of them isn't resigned it'll be Edwards. And with the release of Damien Woody they are now in the market for a Right Tackle as well. The hype on Brooks Reed has just been growing and grow and he's drawing some comparisons to Green Bay OLB Clay Matthews and not just because he's a white guy with long-blonde hair.

 

 

31. Pittsburgh Steelers - Muhammed Wilkerson DT, Temple

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Maurkice Pouncey OC, Florida

Team Needs: RG/CB/OT/DE/P/NT

By now every Steelers fan knows their weaknesses and what the team needs to be focusing on come draft day. In the secondary the team needs to find a solid CB to play with Ike Taylor. And Taylor himself is on the wrong side of 30 and a free agent. Bryant McFadden has been very poor in coverage and has become injury prone. Willie Gay is barely serviceable as a nickel CB. Hopefully Crezdon Butler will make strides in his second year but that can't be counted on.On the defensive line age has become a very big concern. Aaron Smith has missed a significant portion of the season for the second time in 3 years. After a very slow start to his career Ziggy Hood has come on as of late. Also NT Casey Hampton will turn 34 years old by the start of the 2011 season.

The biggest issue by far is on the offensive line. Outside of rookie Maurkice Pouncey every other position has been a struggle just about all year. Both starting OT's ended the season on I.R. LT Max Starks, even when healthy, is only an above average option and would be better suited at RT. Willie Colon, who suffered a ruptured Achilles, will be a free agent and has been looking to cash in. The most pressing issue has been at RG where we have seen a revolving door of players such as Trai Essex, Ramon Foster, and Doug Legursky unable to stabilize the position or capitalize with their chance to start. Mike Pouncey would be the perfect fit and seems to be destined to join his brother in Pittsburgh.

And as I've stated in previous mock drafts, when it comes time for contract renewals both brothers might take a discount to continue playing on the same team which would be a good added bonus. The problem for the Steelers is that there are several teams ahead of them that could also use Mike Pouncey's services and as such he will not be available here. However I do expect the Steelers to make a move up for him come draft time. But since I don't do trades in my mock draft I'm going with Muhammed Wilkerson. For more of my thoughts and assessment of Wilkerson, check out my player profile on him.

I know a lot of people in Steeler Nation would prefer Texas' Aaron Williams or Miami's Brandon Harris but the simple truth is that the Steelers draft based on value and not on need and Wilkerson is the better overall prospect. However that doesn't mean the Front Office won't take either for the CB's. From a schematic standpoint Aaron Williams would be a better fit for the Steelers defense than Brandon Harris.

 

 

32. Green Bay Packers - Benjamin Ijalana OG/OT, Villanova

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Bryan Bulaga, OT, Iowa

Team Needs: OLB/LG/RB/DE/OT/WR

The Packers will have a few holes to fill come the 2011 draft. For one they need to find a replacement for Ryan Grant. James Starks was good in the playoffs but he has a long injury history and even if he pans out they'll still need someone to compliment him. Perhaps one of their biggest needs is for someone other than Clay Matthews to apply pressure. At defensive end Cullen Jenkins is a free agent and Johnny Jolly will be a free agent next year. And even with the drafting of Bryan Bulaga in the first round last year they still need help along the offensive line. OT Chad Clifton is nearing retirement. The bigger need is at OG. Daryn Colledge is a free agent and not very good anyway. However there are plenty of solid Guards that will be available in the next two rounds. Ben Ijalana's stock has been on the rise and he could play either Guard or Right Tackle.

 

**************

 

Round 2

 

33. New England Patriots (via Carolina Panthers) - Torrey Smith WR, Maryland

New England lacks a deep threat. They franchised Logan Mankins but if he's traded this pick will be the best available OG. Torrey Smith has inconsistency issues due to his small hands but he ran a 4.37 40 and posted a 41inch vertical at the combine.

 

 

34. Buffalo Bills - Martez Wilson ILB, Illinois

I would love to give the Bills an OT here but any of the available ones would be a reach. The next option would be Wilson who has the versatility to play inside or outside and the athletic ability that Chan Gailey loves. Aaron Maybin has been a huge disappointment and they could use an upgrade over 32 year old Andre Davis.

 

 

35. Cincinnati Bengals - Christian Ponder QB, FSU

The Bengals need to plan for the future after Carson Palmer, which could be the 2011 season if Palmer gets his way. Previously I've had Ryan Mallett going here but Ponder is a much better fit for Jay Gruden's West Coast offense. Ponder's arm strength is only average but he was the best QB at the Senior Bowl as well as at the combine during drills. If the Bengals go in any other direction they could take the top rated RB if they fail to resign Cedric Benson.

 

 

36. Denver Broncos - Mikel Leshoure RB, Illinois

When Knowshon Moreno is hurt, which is a lot, and out of the line up Denver's ground game is non-existent. Plus new Head Coach John Fox likes to use a multiple-back system.

 

 

37. Cleveland Browns - Jonathan Baldwin WR, Pittsburgh

This pick is a given as Cleveland's biggest need is for WR's. Baldwin ran a 4.45 40 at the combine proving doubters wrong about his lack of speed. He could easily go higher than this, possibly in the first round to a team like San Diego who covets tall WR's.

 

 

38. Arizona Cardinals - Marcus Cannon OG/OT, TCU

The Cardinals have one of the worst offensive lines in all of football. He would be an upgrade at OG over the rapidly declining Alan Faneca. At the combine Cannon showed up at a surprisingly fit 6'6", 358lbs., and by his pro day lost another 9lbs. He also has decent enough athletic ability that he might be able to play RT.

 

 

39. Tennessee Titans - Ryan Mallett QB, Arkansas

Tennessee can't afford to not take a QB here. Mallett will need to sit a year and learn behind Kerry Collins. He has the size and arm strength of a top five pick, but he still needs a lot of work on his throwing motion and footwork.

 

 

40. Dallas Cowboys - Brandon Harris CB, Miami

Mike Jenkins had a terrible 2010 season and Terrence Newman is 33 years old.

 

 

41. Washington Redskins - Jake Locker QB, Washington

Washington can't be serious about Rex Grossman as their starting QB. Rumor has it that Coach Shanahan really likes Locker.

 


42. Houston Texans - Rahim Moore FS, UCLA

With no NT's available, this pick will come down to the BPA at CB or Safety. Houston cut FS Eugene Wilson.

 

 

43. Minnesota Vikings - Colin Kaepernick QB, Nevada

With Favre and Tavares Jackson gone, leaving Joe Webb at QB, the Vikings have to look for a long-term option.

 

 

44. Detroit Lions - Stefen Wisniewski OC/OG, Penn State

The Lions always take BPA and The Wis is better than the available CB's left. They need an upgrade over Dominic Raiola at Center.

 

 

45. San Francisco 49ers - Sam Acho DE/OLB, Texas

The 49ers have to find someone to generate a consistent pass-rush.

 

 

46. Denver Broncos (via Miami Dolphins) - Quinton Carter FS, Oklahoma

Brian Dawkins just can't cut it anymore.

 

 

47. St. Louis Rams - Leonard Hankerson WR, Miami

After missing out on Julio Jones in the first round they have to take a WR in the second round.

 

 

48. Oakland Raiders - Davon House CB, New Mexico State

2010 1st round Draft Pick: Rolando McClain ILB, Alabama

Team Needs: CB/RT/LG/OC/TE/WR

When Oakland cut Nnamdi Asomugha this pick became pretty easy to predict. They will have to take the best CB available. After giving Oakland a lot of respect for their 2010 draft I thought that as a franchise they had finally righted the ship, but after cutting Nnamdi Asomugha and giving Stanford Routt a 3-year/32mil contact I'm convinced Al Davis is no longer on his meds. House has the size (6'1", 200lbs.) and speed (4.35 40 time) that the Crypt Keeper covets.

 

 

49. Jacksonville Jaguars - Aaron Williams CB, Texas

This pick will be the top rated CB or Safety prospect available. Williams ran a decent 40 time (4.52) but didn't look very fluid in his drills which will probably facilitate his switch to Safety.

 

 

50. San Diego Chargers - Jabaal Sheard DE/OLB, Pittsburgh

The Chargers need to generate some kind of a pass-rush.

 

 

51. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Bruce Carter OLB, UNC

Barrett Ruud and Quincy Black are both free agents.

 

 

52. New York Giants -Ryan William RB, Virginia Tech

Ahmad Bradshaw can't stay healthy for an entire season.

 

 

53. Indianapolis Colts - Tyler Sash SS, Iowa

Indy replaces Bob Sanders with another Iowa Hawkeye.

 

 

54. Philadelphia Eagles - Curtis Brown CB, Texas

Philly needs CB's with the retirement of Ellis Hobbs and general sucking by Dimitri Patterson.

 

 

55. Kansas City Chiefs - Chris Carter DE/OLB, Fresno State

K.C. needs a complimentary pass-rusher to Tamba Hali.

 

 

56. New Orleans Saints - Stephen Paea DT, Oregon State

The Saints signed Shaun Rogers but he's nothing more than a 32 year old short-term solution at DT.

 

 

57. Seattle Seahawks - Christian Ballard DE/DT, Iowa

Seattle needs to revamp their defensive line.

 

 

58. Baltimore Ravens - Randall Cobb WR/RB/PR, Kentucky

Baltimore lacks a deep threat at WR.

 

 

59. Atlanta Falcons - Kyle Rudolph TE, Notre Dame

This is a dream scenario for Atlanta, having Rudolph fall to them in the second round. The Falcons need an heir to Tony Gonzalez.

 

 

60. New England Patriots - Shane Vereen RB, Cal

This is pretty much a BPA situation. Danny Woodhead is a nice story but N.E. could use an upgrade at the position.

 

 

61. San Diego Chargers (via New York Jets) - Joseph Barksdale OT, LSU

The Chargers need an upgrade over Jeremy Clary at right tackle.

 

 

62. Chicago Bears - Rodney Hudson OG, Florida State

Chicago has issues all along the offensive line.

 

 

63. Pittsburgh Steelers - Ras-I Dowling CB, Virginia

This pick will probably come down to the highest rated CB with OG Marcus Cannon no longer available. Dowling is a fan favorite of many in Steelers Nation as he fits the tough, physical style of play that the Steelers prefer in addition to his high character. The only thing keeping him from being drafted higher is his injury history. He was also finally able to participate in his own Pro Day, running a 4.37 40, a 38in vertical, and looking good in the drills. Given the lack of emphasis put on the Cornerback position by the Steelers it wouldn't surprise me if they bypass the position early in favor of an offensive lineman if they don't take one in the first round. Someone like Miami's Orlando Franklin or Alabama's James Carpenter would fit Pittsburgh's blocking scheme.

 

 

64. Green Bay Packers - Jarvis Jenkins DE/DT, Clemson

Cullen Jenkins is a free agent and Johnny Jolly can't seem to stay out of trouble.

 

**************

 

Round 3

 


65. Carolina Panthers - Marvin Austin DT, North Carolina

Carolina needs multiple DT's. If they take Nick Fairley or Marcell Dareus with the first overall pick look for Carolina to take the best available WR like Boise State's Austin Pettis or Indiana's Tandon Doss. Austin comes with a lot of baggage but also a lot of potential.

 


66. Cincinnati Bengals - Daniel Thomas RB, Kansas State

Cedric Benson is a free agent.

 

 

67. Denver Broncos - Drake Nevis DT, LSU

Denver will have to double-dip at DT after releasing Justin Bannan and Jamal Williams.

 

 

68. Buffalo Bills - James Brewer OT, Indiana

Buffalo needs upgrades at both Tackle spots.

 

 

69. Arizona Cardinals - Brandon Burton CB, Utah

The Cardinals need an upgrade over Greg Toler.

 

 

70. Cleveland Browns - Danny Watkins OG, Baylor

The Browns need to completely rebuild the right side of their O-line.

 

 

71. Dallas Cowboys - James Carpenter OG/OT, Alabama

Marc Colombo is a free agent and pretty awful anyway.

 

 

72. New Orleans Saints (via Washington Redskins) - Mason Foster OLB, Washington

Scott Shanle needs to be replaced at WLB.

 

 

73. Houston Texans - Jerrell "Boom Boom" Powe NT, Ole' Miss.

The Texans need a NT for their conversion to the 3-4 defense.

 

 

74. New England Patriots (via Minnesota Vikings) - Clint Boling OG, UGA

Stephen Neal retired and Logan Mankins will eventually be traded.

 

 

75. Detroit Lions - Johnny Patrick CB, Louisville

Detroit needs CB's, especially if they don't resign Chris Houston.

 

 

76. San Francisco 49ers - Andy Dalton QB, TCU

Coach Harbaugh needs someone to run his West Coast offense.

 

 

77. Tennessee Titans - Quan Sturdivant ILB, North Carolina

The Titans will most likely not resign Stephen Tulloch.

 


78. St. Louis Rams - Will Rackley OG, Lehigh

Adam Goldberg needs to be replaced at RG.

 


79. Miami Dolphins - Luke Stocker TE, Tennessee

Anthony Fasano just isn't cutting it.

 

 

80. Jacksonville Jaguars - Jerrel Jernigan WR/KR, Troy

Mike Sims-Walker is a free agent and will probably not resign.

 

 

81. Oakland Raiders - Orlando Franklin OG/OT, Miami

Robert Gallery and Langston Walker are both free agents.

 

 

82. San Diego Chargers - Kelvin Sheppard ILB, LSU

All of San Diego's ILB's are free agents.

 

 

83. New York Giants - Jake Kirkpatrick OC, TCU

Shaun O'Hara will be a 34 year old free agent next offseason.

 

 

84. Tampa Bay Buccaneers - John Moffitt OG/OC, Wisconsin

Tampa has a hole at LG and OC Jeff Faine is injury-prone.

 


85. Philadelphia Eagles - DeAndre McDaniel S, Clemson

Quintin Mikell is a 30 year old free agent seeking a big contract.

 

 

86. Kansas City Chiefs - Tandon Doss WR, Indiana

K.C. has no one at WR besides Dewayne Bowe.

 

 

87. Indianapolis Colts - Titus Young WR, Boise State

Reggie Wayne will be 33 years old this coming season, Anthony Gonzalez can't seem to stay healthy, and Austin Collie may be forced to retire if he gets another concussion.

 

 

88. New Orleans Saints - Jordan Todman RB, UConn

Reggie Bush is injury-prone and costs too much money. Todman is a solid prospect with good pass-catching skills and is a perfect fit for the Saints offense.

 

 

89. San Diego Chargers (via Seattle Seahawks) - Marcus Gilchrist CB, Clemson

The Chargers need an upgrade at Nickel CB.

 

 

90. Baltimore Ravens - Allen Bailey DE/DT, Miami

Cory Redding is no longer much of a pass-rushing threat.

 

 

91. Atlanta Falcons - Edmund Gates WR, Abilene Christian

Atlanta needs an upgrade over Harry Douglas and Michael Jenkins.

 


92. New England Patriots - Marcus Gilbert OT, Florida

If the Patriots do not resign the 33 year old Matt Light they'll need to shift Sebastian Vollmer to the left side and find his replacement on the right side.

 

 

93. Chicago Bears - Chris Hairston OT, Clemson

Chicago needs to double, and maybe triple-dip into the O-lineman talent pool.

 

 

94. New York Jets - Greg Little WR, North Carolina

Santonio Holmes and Braylon Edwards are both free agents. It's likely that the Jets will resign Holmes and let Edwards walk. Little has the talent of a first round pick but like the other Tar Heels in this draft he comes with a lot of baggage but Rex Ryan welcomes players like that with open arms.

 

 

95. Pittsburgh Steelers - Jah Reid OT, Central Florida

Pittsburgh has to come away with at least one OT/OG prospect as well as a CB prospect in this draft. Jah Reid really impressed at his Pro Day. He has the size at 6'7", 321lbs. to play RT and the enough agility to be a pulling Guard on the inside.

 

 

96. Green Bay Packers - Dontay Moch DE/OLB, Nevada

The Packers could use some competition with Frank Zombo and Erik Walden at the OLB spot opposite of Clay Matthews.

 

 

97. (Compensatory pick) Carolina Panthers - DeMarcus Love OG, Arkansas

Carolina has a huge hole at RG.

 

**************

Rounds 4-7

Comment 44 comments  |  Add comment  |  1 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

i like it

I think Muhammed Wilkerson could be a stud inserted into Lebeau’s Defense

by Lamarr56 on Apr 6, 2011 7:41 PM EDT reply actions  

Ras won't be there at the end of the second

I pray I’m wrong but I think the only way we get him is to trade up in the second

I want Holyfield! You've seen what these guns can do in the Middle East. Now I'm gunna show you what they can do in the ring.
-The late and GREAT Chris Farley- RIP

by Steel_D_43 on Apr 6, 2011 8:35 PM EDT reply actions  

This is the first mock draft I’ve done that had Ras-I Dowling still on the board at 63. That’s just how it worked itself out this time.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:43 PM EDT up reply actions  

Brothers in arms!!

I agree; I think that the front office will target Pouncey and trade up to get him. I still think we will end up with either Schilling or Boren out of the big 10, and I am curious if anyone has picked up Shaun Rogers yet?? He would make a great tandem with Snack at the nose!!And this may be a dream scenario; what would it take for us to get Asougmo?? I know the Steelers have never been big free agency players but this would certainly put us square in the middle of the run!!

by wmd3 on Apr 6, 2011 9:39 PM EDT reply actions  

The Saint signed Rogers.

I have not yet begun to procrastinate.

by NYSteelersFan4 on Apr 7, 2011 8:42 AM EDT up reply actions  

Yea the Saints signed Rogers already. I don’t think the Steelers would sign him anyway. While they rarely dip into the free agent pool they would never sign one over 30 years old for what it would cost to get Rogers.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:44 PM EDT up reply actions  

It would take dropping some players to get Nnamdi, like McFadden, Will Allen, ARE, Foote, and couple others that are just as replaceable. I wish they would make the move to get both Pouncey and Nnamdi. We can clear the cap space and I’ll take 3-4 quality draft picks that make the team.

by alistar7 on Apr 9, 2011 9:56 AM EDT up reply actions  

me too

i like cam newton more. he has more potential i think. i sitll wouldnt touch either until the second round if i was a team. of course it doenst matter who is in the draft the top qb or two will always be in consideration for top 10 picks. if luck came into the draft gabbert and newton would both go much lower IMO.

by steelerintexas on Apr 6, 2011 11:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

I wouldn’t take Gabbert or Newton in the first round. But if I had to pick one I would rather take Gabbert. There are just too many questions with Newton. I could be wrong but I think he’s going to be the next Akili Smith.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:45 PM EDT up reply actions  

Ditto

I personally like Mallett the most

by ICEICETHATGUY13 on Apr 7, 2011 3:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

He's going to be the next Klye Boller.

I like Newton mainly because I think he’s got that "it" factor. The same one that makes Ben and Brady special. He is just really raw coming from that system.

I'm getting tired of saying this: Dick LeBeau’s system is so complex very few rookies can make an impact.

"It would be tough for me to care less about their opinion, to be honest with you." Mike Tomlin

by Steel in FL on Apr 7, 2011 4:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

Newton does have an "it" factor

But he also played in an offense that a fellow SEC OC called “middle school complicated” (quote paraphrased).

Also, he’s not too accurate. Seems like a better running, worse throwing VY to me

by ICEICETHATGUY13 on Apr 7, 2011 4:36 PM EDT up reply actions  

He also was in the same O as Tebow

That might have an impact.

I'm getting tired of saying this: Dick LeBeau’s system is so complex very few rookies can make an impact.

"It would be tough for me to care less about their opinion, to be honest with you." Mike Tomlin

by Steel in FL on Apr 7, 2011 5:09 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yet he could never break the line up with Tebow around.

"My rule of life prescribed as an absolutely sacred rite smoking cigars and also the drinking of alcohol before, after and if need be during all meals and in the intervals between them."-Winston Churchill

by cscmember on Apr 8, 2011 11:14 AM EDT up reply actions  

Mallet

may have the best arm, but he is super immature, and makes really bad decisions when under duress, and has injury issues. I live in Arkansas and watch all his games, he will not last long in the league IMO.

People don't ever seem to realize that doing what's right is no guarantee against misfortune.
- William McFee

by stillergorillar on Apr 7, 2011 6:55 PM EDT up reply actions  

Fair enough, sounds like Ryan Leaf

Though the pressure thing to me always seemed a tad overblown, and could go away with good coaching.

by ICEICETHATGUY13 on Apr 9, 2011 10:15 AM EDT up reply actions  

Yes

"My rule of life prescribed as an absolutely sacred rite smoking cigars and also the drinking of alcohol before, after and if need be during all meals and in the intervals between them."-Winston Churchill

by cscmember on Apr 8, 2011 11:16 AM EDT up reply actions  

my biggest issue

is with the titans taking mallett. after the vince young experiment i dont think they will be as quick to pick up guys with talent but potential serious off the field problems.

by steelerintexas on Apr 6, 2011 11:57 PM EDT reply actions  

I hear what you’re saying but they are two completely different animals. Mallett is probably the best pure passer in the draft and his problems are just a little immaturity. He’s not the fragile partier like Young.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:47 PM EDT up reply actions  

Mallet

also has issues with drugs accusations, that he has never answered. He also spent part of both years with the Hogs injured. He is far more than a little immature and he makes really bad decisions when under duress.

People don't ever seem to realize that doing what's right is no guarantee against misfortune.
- William McFee

by stillergorillar on Apr 7, 2011 6:58 PM EDT up reply actions  

Danny Watkins falling to the 3rd round?

A lot of mocks have him going in the bottom of the 1st. The top of the 2nd is the lowest I’ve seen him. He has only ONE drawback, he’s 26. If it wasnt for that, he would be right up there with Pouncey.

Stay thirsty my friends.

by SteelerMessican on Apr 7, 2011 7:01 AM EDT reply actions  

Upside may be the concern

At 26 it is possible that Watkins has peaked while some guys who are 21, 22 or even 23 may have much more upside.

"Canada? I don't even know what street it is on." Al Capone

"Until I came to Canada, I didn't know that snow was a four letter word." Alberto Manuel

"I wouldn't say it's cold but every year Winnipeg's athlete of the year is an ice fisherman." Dale Tallon

"If it wasn't for the anticipated flooding it will bring, Spring could not get here soon enough this year." COSF

by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Apr 7, 2011 9:47 AM EDT up reply actions  

That’s how I feel about Watkins. He’s peaked and in a couple years his talent will start to drop, so you’ll only have a few really good years with him.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:48 PM EDT up reply actions  

He's only been playing football for 4 years...

He is still learning. Sure he’s up there in age, but he has low mileage in the trenches. He should have a good 5 years before he starts to drop. I think the big advantage is that the STeelers avoid the monster 2nd contract. They go from rookie contract to “over 30” contract.

Stay thirsty my friends.

by SteelerMessican on Apr 7, 2011 9:22 PM EDT up reply actions  

valid point but

This is a first round choice. How many teams draft someone because they will be inexpensive to sign when it is the end of the first round (unless this is your second 1st round draft choice of the draft). We aren’t Cincy.

"Canada? I don't even know what street it is on." Al Capone

"Until I came to Canada, I didn't know that snow was a four letter word." Alberto Manuel

"I wouldn't say it's cold but every year Winnipeg's athlete of the year is an ice fisherman." Dale Tallon

"If it wasn't for the anticipated flooding it will bring, Spring could not get here soon enough this year." COSF

by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Apr 8, 2011 1:22 AM EDT up reply actions  

Not saying they draft him because of contract issues....

They will draft him because they think he will be a stud lineman for the next 5 years. The contract issues just help offset the age issue. Besides who cares after 5 years? By then Ben will start slipping and our championship contention will be over. The next 5 years is what its all about and Watkins helps out BIGTIME with that.

Stay thirsty my friends.

by SteelerMessican on Apr 8, 2011 12:01 PM EDT up reply actions  

intelligence/learning curve

I never looked at his wonderlic. How is his intelligence and what kind of a learning curve does he have? I certainly wouldn’t turn him down at the end of the 2nd but it is hard to think there isn’t another kid out there who is at the same level (maybe at a different position) who is younger and has a lot of upside.

"Canada? I don't even know what street it is on." Al Capone

"Until I came to Canada, I didn't know that snow was a four letter word." Alberto Manuel

"I wouldn't say it's cold but every year Winnipeg's athlete of the year is an ice fisherman." Dale Tallon

"If it wasn't for the anticipated flooding it will bring, Spring could not get here soon enough this year." COSF

by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Apr 8, 2011 1:20 AM EDT up reply actions  

Well done draft as far as the Steelers are concerned.

  I disagree with your one statement about CB Williams fitting the Steelers system better than CB Harris.
  CB Williams body type is more Steelers like, But unless Lake can do wonders with him. Williams would fit in best with the Steelers replacing Clark in 2012. I do think he would be an improvement there over Clark.
  CB Harris though a little shorter than the Steelers like. With his knowledge of the game, attitude and desire to succeed. Could end up being the best play maker at the nickel position the Steelers have had in a long time. Making QBs fear passing in the interior of the field more

The more I learn -The less I think I know! Just enjoy reading and sharing.

by steeler junky on Apr 7, 2011 8:25 AM EDT reply actions  

Do you draft a CB in the 1st round to play nickel?

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 7, 2011 3:00 PM EDT up reply actions  

Why do they say he should only play nickle?

Not his talent but his height. If anything the short issue should be a motivator.

I'm getting tired of saying this: Dick LeBeau’s system is so complex very few rookies can make an impact.

"It would be tough for me to care less about their opinion, to be honest with you." Mike Tomlin

by Steel in FL on Apr 7, 2011 4:04 PM EDT up reply actions  

Why not

  If it would slow down the bleeding in the interior pass dense.
 That is where NE played first round Devin McCourty part of last season.

The more I learn -The less I think I know! Just enjoy reading and sharing.

by steeler junky on Apr 8, 2011 9:29 AM EDT up reply actions  

I think SteelCage mentioned why not in his post today…how do we know he is any better than Gay? Stats are pretty comparable. Second reason is in Steel in Fl’s signature line. And while short may be a motivator as Steel in FL says…it is still short! I think Anthony Madison is highly motivated…but he is still short!

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 8, 2011 4:37 PM EDT up reply actions  

Add on for round 3

  I agree the Steelers probably will draft a WR some where in this draft.
 But " IF " TE L. Kendricks . is still on the board at the end of round 3. The Steelers will not pass on him.

The more I learn -The less I think I know! Just enjoy reading and sharing.

by steeler junky on Apr 7, 2011 8:53 AM EDT reply actions  

I’m not a fan of Kendricks at all. He’s really a pass-catching TE only, not that good a blocking, and he’s really not that athletic for a pass-catcher to begin with.

by big_jay71 on Apr 7, 2011 3:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

Better value at DT later in draft

I think we could get a better value at that position if we waited until the 3rd round and went with one of the second tier prospects. I dont think that we will get a Williams, Moore, or Cannon after the first two rounds. We have to draft BPA, but also look at value later on down the line.

The Poster Formerly Known As Gimpsta7

by Michael Uhlhorn on Apr 7, 2011 2:13 PM EDT reply actions  

Value to whom?

Please help me understand the ‘value’ comments…how does anyone determine value at this point in time for these players? If you think that you have a quality player that fills a perceived need, are they of greater or lesser value than a less highly rated player taken later? For instance, is Antonio Brown a higher value player than Manny Sanders? Is there a definition of value for potential draftees that I can look up somewhere? I would think that value would be in the eyes of the beholder, in this case.

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 7, 2011 3:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

Value

Importance of position, contrasted with draft position. TE’s drafted in the top 10: Bad value (even if they go on to pro-bowl careers). WR Drafted in the 6th round who becomes a starter: More valuable than drafting a starting WR in the second round.

Reasons, you are more likely to find a starting TE or DT in the later rounds, than you would be a starting QB/CB. That is how you measure value.

We arent talking about whether something has been passed down through generations, but is really only a towel, so its value is sentimental. We are talking about tangible value, vs pay, vs positions you could have drafted. How is that not clear exactly?

The Poster Formerly Known As Gimpsta7

by Michael Uhlhorn on Apr 7, 2011 5:27 PM EDT up reply actions  

Not trying to be argumentative, but...

Does that mean we shouldn’t have drafted Snack in the first round? And shouldn’t have drafted Pouncey @18? Surely there were players of higher value at that time. Or am I still off-base?

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 8, 2011 12:16 AM EDT up reply actions  

Mostly I was being sarcastic

But a 10 year pro-bowl caliber C is a value pick at 18. One of the best NT’s of a generation in the first round (since others are being drafted for DT in the top 5 the last few years) is good value.

The Poster Formerly Known As Gimpsta7

by Michael Uhlhorn on Apr 8, 2011 12:13 PM EDT up reply actions  

OK...thanks!

I fully agree on your two statements above, by the way. And I agree that value is not just positionally defined (playing position), but also individualy defined. The outstanding player is a value no matter where selected or what position they play, with this caveat…anybody selected in the first 5 or so slots of the first round ought to be the second coming of Peyton…or Troy…or Ron Woodson, etc. Here’s hoping that we never again have to draft in that area.

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 8, 2011 4:28 PM EDT up reply actions  

Agreed

I just think that if you have a once in a generation talent, take them wherever (see Patrick Peterson). Usually CB’s are a bust in the top-10, let alone top 3. But he will probably be Charles Woodson 2.0, so he is worth that pick. Same with Suh last year. I think positional value is an important guide, but if the player is someone who is truly great, take them. If they are just the best available (but maybe not by that much) and you don’t need the position as much, or it isn’t of as much value, try to get more for that position (and money) later in the draft. If they set a rookie cap though, draft position value could really change (since you wouldn’t have to pay a 1st overall CB 50+ million a year), you might see BPA taken most of the time.

The Poster Formerly Known As Gimpsta7

by Michael Uhlhorn on Apr 8, 2011 11:33 PM EDT up reply actions  

Not sure I want everyone driven to BPA

I think that Steelers have specialized in BPA, so I’m not sure I want other teams driven towards that by a new CBA! Although I want us drafting 32 every time, I can accept 18 or above. Let Al Davis and the Jerrys fight it out @ pick no. 1!

"We have met the enemy and he is us" - Pogo (1970)

by Andy34 on Apr 10, 2011 11:13 PM EDT up reply actions  


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the SIX-time world champion Steelers.

"Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history."

Art Rooney Jr.

"Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
Your all time Steeler regret?
5467103_small
Hines Ward: a different look part 1. Hines vs. the big boys.

Recent FanPosts

Small
Isaac Redman 2012: Should we temper our expectations?
Photo_small
Worry Warts
6-trophies_small
The Saint Will Be The Starter for 2012 - The Whole Season.
Trophies_small
Why Is Rashard Mendenhall Still On This Roster?
2009-week6_1440x900_benroethlisberger_small
Pads - To wear or not to wear
Small
53 Man Roster (Way too early edition)
Small
WHEN DO TICKETS GO ON SALE?
Small
Submitted for your approval: Steeler names for this year's pledge class
Small
The biggest offseason ever

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Terrible Towel Talk

Listen to internet radio with Michael Bean on Blog Talk Radio


Site Founder & Editor

Imag0299_small Michael Bean

Steelers Historian

Steeler_small maryrose

Bison_small Neal Coolong

Contributing Authors

Small Ivan Cole (RickVa)

Franco72_small 5020

Btsc_head_shot_small Rebecca Rollett

Small big_jay71

Hines_small John Stephens

178896_499126548441_596563441_5939410_7960015_n_small Anthony Defeo