Steelers Offensive Breakdown in Preparation for the 2012 NFL Draft
This is the second in BTSC's extended series covering and analyzing the 2012 NFL Draft and how it will affect the Pittsburgh Steelers. We're hoping to highlight prospects, discuss or lament speculation and even provide a full mock draft or two. Keep your eyes open for it, as of now there's no particular timetable, but if you have any ideas, feel free to leave a comment, or email me at the address indicated in my profile. - nc
In Part I, the Steelers defensive personnel was highlighted. Moving onto the offense, the first and most obvious unit is the offensive line.
We've likely seen G Chris Kemoeatu's last game as a Steeler, and with T Marcus Gilbert moving from right tackle to left in wake of the return of Willie Colon, the five trenchermen will be different than it was a year ago.
But what else is new?
Offensive line
First Round Draft Possibilities: G David Decastro, G Cordy Glenn
An offensive line that saw more shake-up than stability in 2012 should expect much of the same. Colon will enter camp as the starting right tackle, and Gilbert will move to the left, leaving questions around the futures of Jonathan Scott and Max Starks.
Starks is a free agent, and ties to the area - and support from QB Ben Roethlisberger - could convince him to stay in town for the veteran minimum. That's if the Steelers even want him back. The Steelers won't pay Starks more than that, especially considering Scott still has a year left on his deal, and is clearly favored by Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin.
Colon's return - assuming he stays healthy - should eliminate either Starks or Scott, with Scott being the favorite to stick around. Drafting an offensive tackle with the 24th pick doesn't seem to be a terrible option, but the left guard position could garner more attention. Kemoeatu will be cut before March 13, which would pencil in Doug Legursky as the starting left guard. Ramon Foster would stay at right guard.
Trai Essex is an unrestricted free agent, but could be brought back for the veteran minimum as well, due to his versatility. He can play all five offensive line positions. The Steelers love linemen who could play guard or tackle, and if they can find a younger one in the draft, it may mean the end for Essex.
Decastro is going to be a dominant player in this league, and if he happens to fall in striking range of the Steelers, don't be surprised if he's the target of a trade-up situation. The Steelers are deep already, and have a few positions in which they simply won't draft anyone, so giving a few picks to get their starting left guard would be a good option.
Quarterback
First Round Draft possibilities: None
In another year where quarterback will not be a position addressed in the first round, it will be a year the Steelers target a passer in the middle-to-late rounds. Plain and simple, Roethlisberger is entering into a stage of his career where injuries are going to pile up. His decision to gut it out and play in pain is admirable, but that doesn't make him a better quarterback. The Steelers would love to keep Charlie Batch around, and could possibly do that, but his minimum salary is $925,000.
Same goes for Byron Leftwich, who, if healthy, would likely have made Batch expendable in the past. Leftwich is more likely to return as Roethlisberger's back-up, but the likely departure of Dennis Dixon will leave a third QB position open. The Steelers would like to target a project kind of player, someone they could stash on the practice squad for a year. QBs aren't often safe on practice squads, just ask Houston how quickly you may be forced to keep one on your 53-man roster.
Running Back
First Round Draft Possibilitles: None
The Steelers are one of the league's deepest teams at running back, and this is being written before they formally announce their next offensive coordinator. Starter Rashard Mendenhall is likely to begin camp on the physically-unable-to-perform (PUP) list, and Isaac Redman will be considered the starter until Mendenhall full rehabs his knee after tearing his ACL in Week 17.
It's an extremely important offseason for Jonathan Dwyer, who will be in competition for the remaining three spots with John Clay, Baron Batch and Mewelde Moore. The Steelers love the veteran Moore, but may not love his salary if they feel they can get similar production, if not smarts, from any of the three younger and far less expensive backs.
Batch turned heads during training camp last year due to his aggressive blocking and quickness, and he should be 100 percent after tearing his ACL last August. He may end up beating out Moore for third-down duties early in camp. That would leave Dwyer and Clay needing something to differentiate themselves from Moore. Clay could wind up on the practice squad again, where he was the majority of this season.
There's zero chance the Steelers draft a running back in the first round, but it wouldn't be shocking if they took one late in the draft, like they did last year with Batch, and the year before with Dwyer. Redman and Clay are both undrafted free agent graduates, so don't be surprised if the Steelers look to grab a back and work them over on the practice squad next season.
Tight End
Draft Possibilities: TE Orson Charles, TE Coby Fleener
Health Miller types are quickly becoming relics in most offenses around the league. Not the Steelers, however. It can be argued Miller performed his duties at a higher level than any other tight end in the league this season. While nothing can be taken away from the prolific reception numbers put up by Rob Gronkowski and Jimmy Graham, Miller is a better blocker than Gronkowski (and astronomically better than Graham), and ended up being needed more as a third tackle than a receiving threat.
In short, Miller is still one of the best in the business, and will remain there for at least the foreseeable future.
David Johnson will likely get a low-level tender this off-season and probably will be back. The news is going to be about the development of Weslye Saunders, a guy who reeks of potential, but hasn't proved he's worth the hype yet. Johnson's hands will likely cost him a roster spot eventually, but Saunders hasn't done enough to phase Johnson completely out yet. It's extremely unlikely the Steelers would draft a tight end in the first round, but again, this is being written before the Steelers hire their offensive coordinator for 2012.
Quarterbacks coach Randy Fichtner seemed a pretty viable candidate for Memphis University's head coaching job, and he did throw his name in the ring for it. Perhaps the Steelers reached out to him and asked if he'd like to be the offensive coordinator in 2012 instead. I'm just sayin'...
Wide Receivers
Draft Possibilities: WR Michael Floyd, WR Alshon Jeffery, WR Mohamed Sanu
It seems crazy to suggest the Steelers may look for a receiver in round 1, but the biggest reason fans are so excited about this position is what makes it an area of concern; they're young and they're cheap. That won't last for much longer.
The Steelers had a fire sale on receivers the last two years, netting them Mike Wallace, Antonio Brown and Emmanuel Sanders. The emergence of these players could push out Steelers legend Hines Ward. At the very least, Ward will have to accept a fairly significantly reduced contract for next year if he wishes to stay. Although unlikely, the Steelers may outright release him as well, and decide to sign UFA Jerricho Cotchery back.
With longtime fringe-roster guy Tyler Grisham having signed with Denver, the Steelers are looking at a pretty big gap between youth and expensive veterans at the position. Plus, none of them are bigger than 6-foot-1. Floyd, Jeffery and Sanu are all big-bodied, physical targets, and no current Steelers receiver has a combination of those traits.
There isn't much to get after the Steelers receivers for, but a large target could help some of the Steelers' red zone woes from 2011.
29 comments
|
Add comment
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
First!
Good analysis, Neal. Excellent point about the impact the new OC could have on draft priorities, too; until we know for sure, staying the course is de rigueur.
Fly by night, away from here
Change my life again
Fly by night, goodbye my dear
My ship isn't coming and I just can't pretend
RUSH
by Flying Polamalus on Jan 30, 2012 8:48 AM EST reply actions
Thanks
News on the offensive coordinator set for the 9 a.m. CT slot. Odds of our next OC having the last name “Caldwell” take a dramatic dip.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 8:51 AM EST up reply actions
looking forward to this,....
on espn?…or..where?..
by OR69faithfull on Jan 30, 2012 9:35 AM EST up reply actions
Excellent summary Neal...
…I hope this year’s draft focuses on the OL, then the OL, and then, maybe the OL. BPA being the mantra thereafter.
United we Stand, melded like Steel
To Roger Goodell, We'll never Yield.
interesting read
would love to get DeCastro, but not much interested in Glenn who has fought weight problems his whole career…. I could seeus possibly also taking a LT in the first…but most likely were drafting defense again 1st round
Im not so convinced about the running back position, though I agree not anyone really in the first round fits our needs, we are in desperate need of a real FB
TE – well im willing to let Saunders have one more yr to prove himself…
Im with ya on the last sentence in Rec.. was a big missing part in our red zone offense..
My feet are in separate camps right now. I think the Steelers want Glenn (dominated at Senior Bowl practices, combo G and T is a perfect fit for what the team needs right now) but he may have just pushed himself just out of trade-up range. DeCastro would have to tell personnel guys to eff off at the Combine for him to fall where the Steelers could realistically trade up for him.
If it were me, I’m putting a lot of time and effort into Hightower, but I think Glenn’s at the top of the Steelers’ board. Those are my top two right now.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 9:26 AM EST up reply actions
you think they are looking OL first?
time will tell…. so hard to get a wag on things, and then on draft day so much depends on if your guys are available…
Hightower has an upside as he calls all the plays currently for his DF and we certainly need a new mac back…. still seems were losing more players due to retirement on the DL this year, will be an interesting call when # 24 is up in the draft this year..
by OR69faithfull on Jan 30, 2012 9:33 AM EST up reply actions
What I do know is...
…The Steelers don’t draft a position in the first round. They draft a player. Sure, they have needs, but if there’s a complete freak who fell for illogical reasons to 24 (a la Rashard Mendenhall), they’re going to take him.
I think if Cordy Glenn is on the board at 24, they waste zero time in getting the card up to the commissioner, the same way they did when Pouncey was on the board at 15.
They’ve made an art out of taking a passive approach in the draft (not reaching, just taking who’s there and who makes sense). They’ve shown they’ll go up for certain players, but ultimately, they’re not going to stray far from the formula, which is first and foremost, draft only players worthy of being drafted at that spot. Don’t take an offensive lineman at 24 who has a second-round grade just because you need an offensive lineman. The player must first qualify as being worthy of that spot, then it gets into position of need.
It’s early still, and I’ve only just started really digging into analysis and tape, but Glenn and Hightower are the two best guys I’ve seen reasonably possible to be available at 24. I really think the Steelers won’t be drafting at 24, and I think the availability of both of these players will determine whether they’re drafting higher or lower than that. I just can’t see both of them on the board at that spot.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 9:43 AM EST up reply actions
There alot of good talent
in this years draft… I suppose one has to assess over all goal for the complete draft, then depth at position, then make trade off’s in order or round to reach your goals… Guard, I find particularly deep in this draft… as Is DT and NT.. so maybe your first thought of getting Hightower or Burfict makes sense for 1st round…
I’ll have to give a look at whom we might be able to trade up with..
by OR69faithfull on Jan 30, 2012 9:58 AM EST up reply actions
Yes, guard is very deep this year and this is a team that, under Colbert, has been at both ends of the spectrum in regards to the guard position. They’ve drafted them in the first round (Kendall Simmons, and Colbert’s predecessors took Alan Faneca), and they’ve taken UFDAs who end up starting (Foster and Legursky).
I think it’s fair to compare Glenn to Branden Albert from 2007. The Steelers wanted him pretty badly but the Chiefs took him a few spots ahead. My opinion, after Albert went to KC, the Steelers had Darrelle Revis on their card while Carolina was on the clock. The Panthers traded down with the Jets, and the Jets took Revis. The Steelers then took Timmons.
Because they lost a few picks trading up from 32 to 25 with the Giants the previous year, they didn’t make a move to get Albert, thinking they’d just take Revis, who wasn’t expected to go higher than 15.
Those kinds of things will be on Colbert’s mind when assessing this draft. It is deep, and while Albert hasn’t been the most outstanding player, he’s immensely talented, and perhaps the Steelers could have gotten more out of him. We wouldn’t have questions surrounding our left tackle position right now.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 10:10 AM EST up reply actions
To put things in perspective
There should be players available in the second round, who are of equal or greater talent than Marcus Gilbert. If the Steelers wait until round two to draft an offensive lineman, they should be able to find a great value pick.
The first player taken needs to be an impact player. Hopefully, that player will fill a need. I will take a player who can dominate his position for the next 10 years, over an average starter who was taken a round to high, because he filled a need.
by Greig Clawson on Jan 30, 2012 11:51 PM EST up reply actions
The Steelers could have very easily reached for an offensive lineman in both '08 and '09, but didn't because all the projected first rounders were gone.
However, in ’10, when Pouncey was there, they picked him.
by Anthony Defeo on Jan 30, 2012 10:09 AM EST up reply actions
You had me at guard.
I’m all for drafting a left guard. The Steelers have spent the last two years addressing the offensive line in the top two rounds of the draft, if they can find a guard that high this year, maybe we’ll have the makings of a pretty decent line moving forward.
I obviously like Pouncey (if only he could stay healthy) and I thought Gilbert played pretty well for a rookie. I’ve never been high on Colon, but there are scouting experts out there like Matt Williamson who say he’s an above average tackle (at least that’s what he thought two years ago before Colon missed 31 of 32 games), and he obviously knows why more than I do, so if he thinks Colon is decent, I guess I’ll go with that.
It’s amazing how a unit can have a complete transformation from one season to the next. If the injury situation improves, and if they can find the right combination of five men, maybe the offensive line won’t be filled with it’s usual amount of question marks.
Colon went down and the offensive line was filled with question marks in 2010, and they went to a Super Bowl. We won a Super Bowl with Justin Freakin Hartwig starting on the offensive line.
I don’t care what people say, you don’t need an elite offensive line to win a Super Bowl. You can win in spite of having a bad one.
Stay tuned for tomorrow morning, the top five positions of interest for the Steelers first round pick will be up at 7 a.m. CT.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 10:13 AM EST up reply actions
With this approach...
I don’t care what people say, you don’t need an elite offensive line to win a Super Bowl. You can win in spite of having a bad one.
…you leave a lot more to chance, and rely far more than is healthy on the failings of the opponents, than the abilities of your own team. The OL may not have to be elite, but it does need to not be such a glaring weakness.
United we Stand, melded like Steel
To Roger Goodell, We'll never Yield.
by PaVaSteeler on Jan 30, 2012 11:01 AM EST up reply actions
Plain and simple, you have to spend money on skill position players. Save your cap room for your QB, defensive backs (corners in particular) pass rushers and wide receivers. Those are the guys who provide the most bang for your buck.
There are five offensive linemen, no team has more than two Pro Bowl guys anyway. SOMEone on that line is going to be less than his peers. If you know that going on, work on building your strength instead of your weaknesses.
That’s sort of new-age, and it’s a little tough logically, but the Steelers win with a bad offensive line all the time. Why sink 10s of millions of dollars into it when Roethlisberger, Brown, Wallace and Sanders can score points if they get some red zone help, and you can add a more physical inside LB presence who can help tie people up to let the big dogs eat the QB?
Run to set up the pass, cover receivers and hit the quarterback. That’s how you win today.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 4:38 PM EST up reply actions
A couple of things
I don’t care what people say, you don’t need an elite offensive line to win a Super Bowl. You can win in spite of having a bad one.
You shouldn’t have to win in spite of any position. Every position should help you win on the field not saying they have to be elite but they have to have the ability to win their individual battles at least 50% of the game.
There are five offensive linemen, no team has more than two Pro Bowl guys anyway.
2010 Giants O’Hara, Snee and Dheil made the Pro Bowl
2010 Jet Faneca, Mangold and Ferguson made the Pro Bowl
Saints 2011 Jermon Bushrod, Carl Knick, Jahri Evans
as far a players that have made the Pro Bowl (not in same year) playing together
Patriots last year had three in Dan Koppen (1), Logan Makins (4) and Matt Light (3)
Ravens last year Ben Grubbs,(1) Marshall Yanda (1)and Bryant McKinnie (1)
So yes it can happen but usually they don’t stay together very long. It is more impressive with teams like Houston whose O-line plays great with relative no name players.
Huge fan of the Steelers. (that includes "Steelers West")
"If I could start my life over again, I would be a professional football player and you better damn well believe a Pittsburgh Steeler!"- Jack Lambert
Looking forward to it!
Stay tuned for tomorrow morning, the top five positions of interest for the Steelers first round pick will be up at 7 a.m. CT.
"They timed it perfectly, they just went too soon." - Darrell Waltrip commenting on an illegal restart.
What about
C/G Peter Konz from Wisconsin, he can play guard and would be a great insurance policy at C if Pouncey goes out
He has been mentioned more than once around here
I am not certain if there are any perceived issues or not.
Neal has an interesting article on the front page that may suggest our draft strategy will be defence oriented.
anyone trying to contact me via my yahoo account should be aware it has been hacked
by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Jan 30, 2012 1:26 PM EST up reply actions
Yeah, I’m a big fan of Wisconsin linemen. I love what that team is about, and if you’re looking to re-establish a running game, Madison’s the place to go scouting for some hogs.
I think, though, there will be G/Ts available at 24 (Kelechi Osemele for example) who bring more of what the Steelers need than a Doug Legursky 2.0 with a first round pick. Any guard with the talent of a first round pick should be able to learn the center position. We have Legursky already, I’d prefer to find a guy who can make the limited-skilled Legursky a back-up in a year or two rather than have the two of them rotate at three positions.
A kid like Osemele (Starks’ size, but much more nasty) can back up four positions potentially his rookie year. Let’s say Colon is 100 percent and does a damn fine job on the right side. Gilbert does well on the left. The issue clearly on the team is the fact Legursky is pretty much your only option at LG. Getting a guy who can back that up in year 1 while still taking snaps at both tackle spots gives him a nice, wide base of knowledge as he grows as a player.
He’s about twice Legursky’s size too, and he can pull. But I wouldn’t rule Konz out just yet.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 4:33 PM EST up reply actions
OG, ILB, NT - first three rounds.
In whatever order is best for players available.
My draft order
If at all possible I think the best way to go is: LG, NT, ILB, S, QB, K, OLB/DE
Absolutely agree with drafting a guard from the top, that is if it’s not a reach.
After LG I think we have to seriously consider going NT with the next pick, Hampton is up in the air and McClendon is alright but isn’t a pocket collapsing double teaming monster.
ILB should be attended to here, given Farrior and Foote are like 70 years old put together. Farrior is clearly suffering from Ray Lewis syndrome, a condition where your formerly awesome play fades out with age.
A safety is a must in this draft. Polamalu had a great season last year, but his health is always in question and we saw that Mundy lacks some of the instinctive skills that his superiors possess.
I’m sure we’ll see the usual tweener DE picked up hoping to make our OLB corps, and probably a token QB tossed in there maybe around round 5.
A kicker has to be found this offseason. It’s ridiculous that we let Akers pass us by, and friggin San Diego finds a great guy off the street, but we have an inconsistent man-child at K.
You're close
My top five goes a little differently. Read it at 7 a.m. CT tomorrow.
by Neal Coolong on Jan 30, 2012 4:34 PM EST up reply actions
I think we need to go with D. poe in the first…..then guard, then ilb,….and let the F.O. do there thing u know diamond in the ruff…that’s what they’re paid for!!!
by moonsteeler on Jan 31, 2012 12:42 AM EST via Android app reply actions
Black & White
Don’t be so naive to believe the Steelers will draft a white player period let alone in the first round. I predict an all black draft class for what like the 4th year in a row.
"if Mel Blount played against Chad Ocochinco, he would fold him up like a taco before he had a chance to get off the line of scrimmage." Mark Madden.

by 






























