Putting The Steelers' 2011 Season To Music
I got an email from Hombre De Acero, admitting he had one and a half too many, but wanted to know if what he just saw was a bad dream.
It's a cold reality Steelers fans could - should - have seen coming. That doesn't make it any less painful, nor does it make it any less surprising.
Before the tar reaches the boiling stage many have been waiting for so they can go find anyone associated with the Steelers organization, and before the trolls continue to overrun these articles, let's reflect on what exactly just happened.
A table built with four legs won't stand long if one of those legs is broken. Doesn't matter if the table is build from oak or plywood. It's not going to stand for long. Credit to the Broncos, they didn't lean on the broken leg, they kicked it out, and kicked out another, and lit the whole thing on fire.
Not since Week 1 had the Steelers been savaged that badly on defense. It wasn't even a play-to-play kind of whipping, it was all big plays; things the Steelers hadn't allowed all season. Pittsburgh's game plan sold out to stop the run, and it largely worked. The problem was the lack of adjustment to the skill and athleticism of Demaryius Thomas.
Say what you will about Steelers defensive coordinator Dick Lebeau, but he sticks by his players. He placed immense faith in CB Ike Taylor, and kept him locked in man coverage on Thomas throughout the game. Taylor's failures were not technique, they were with overconfidence. And frankly, every Steelers defender can be accused of that today. They didn't respect the Broncos offense, and were going for the interception on every pass.
I'm ok with it. Why? Because I was saying all week they can gamble and force turnovers. They gambled and they lost.
As I typically do at the end of a season, I page through iTunes, and listen to music, hoping to find some perspective. In that search, I'm finding a few random songs to apply to Steelers fans and players/personnel alike.
In no particular order:
The Heart of the Matter - Don Henley
I'm tryin' to get down to the heart of the matter/because the flesh will get weak/and the ashes will scatter/so I'm thinkin' about forgiveness/forgiveness/even if you don't love me anymore.
This goes out to the veterans; Taylor, Hines Ward, Casey Hampton, Brett Keisel, Aaron Smith, Chris Hoke, Max Starks, Chris Kemoeatu, James Harrison, Bryant McFadden, Troy Polamalu, James Farrior, Larry Foote, Willie Colon, Trai Essex, Charlie Batch, Heath Miller, and of course, Ben Roethlisberger.
We'll be asking ourselves all off-season whether this is the last run of this generation of Steelers players. There's a zero percent chance all of the aforementioned players will be Steelers next season. The flesh gets weak. Ashes will scatter. We may not love them now, but in six years, at the Steelers' 10 year reunion of the Super Bowl XLIII team, tell me you won't be misty-eyed.
That's the heart of the matter. Champions don't always win, but they always handle themselves like champions. If Taylor isn't doing that today, in your estimation, there's something wrong with you.
You Can't Always Get What You Want - The Rolling Stones
You can't always get what you want/But if you try sometimes/you might find/You get what you need
To Lebeau, for having to navigate through what history will show as the transition year from the second-greatest Steelers dynasty to whatever they will become in this decade. Ravaged by injuries, forced to play rookies far more often than he ever had before, even with the letdown against Denver, he led the league's best scoring defense throughout the season.
In the end, it's obviously not what he wanted, but the experience gained by those younger players will be something he'll need next season.
Turn The Page - Metallica
So you walk into this restaurant, all strung out from the road/And you feel the eyes upon you, as you're shakin' off the cold/You pretend it doesn't bother you, but you just want to explode/Yeah, most times you can't hear 'em talk, other times you can/All the same old cliches, is it woman, is it man?/And you always seem outnumbered, you don't dare make a stand/Make your stand.
To Heath Miller. Denver had no answer for Miller early, and while the offensive line was being overrun, Miller was needed in pass protection. He could have been an even bigger part of the game plan than his five catches on seven targets day suggests. And he was barely a part of the offense after a monster game against New England in Week 8. Miller is said to be the consummate team player, and doesn't vocalize his opinion to the media often, so perhaps he's saying more behind the scenes than we know. There's no reason a player as talented as he is should be averaging just north of three catches a game.
Streets of Philadelphia - Bruce Springsteen
I walked the avenue/`til my legs felt like stone/I heard he voices of friends/vanished and gone/at night I could hear
the blood in my veins/black and whispering/as the rain/on the streets of Philadelphia
To Mike Tomlin. While on the surface, this has been his team for a while now. He's been a part of coaching changes and enough roster turnover where he's clearly put his stamp on things.
But this offseason will really project Tomlin's leadership acumen. He's going to ask himself some extremely difficult decisions, highest on that list are the questions about Lebeau and offensive coordinator Bruce Arians. Tomlin knows his defense played lights-out overall this season, but the financial aspect of this game is going to force them into some difficult decisions. He has to be happy with the development of his younger defensive backs, but how much longer is Troy Polamalu going to play the game?
An even more painful question, where are the Steelers without Polamalu? Is Lebeau the right leader for the team's trademark defense? Tomlin is an excellent leader, and he knows these kinds of questions must be asked and the answers evaluated.
As for Arians, there have been obvious rumblings for a long time, but the continuous regression of the offensive line and the insistence on a style of offense that will invariably lead to injuries to Roethlisberger - and as we saw in 2011, cost the Steelers the season - have to be questioned as the long-term direction of the franchise. Roethlisberger couldn't move, and couldn't avoid four sacks taken in the final two minutes of each half.
The Standard is The Standard seems more like "Place All Your Eggs in One Basket" today. I wrote Sunday Roethlisberger needed to be great in order for the Steelers not only to win the game, but to justify their stubborn insistence on offensive game plans centered solely around Roethlisberger attacking vertically, results be damned.
Roethlisberger was not great. The Steelers lost. Many will argue, and fairly so, Roethlisberger was hurt and can't be held accountable. He was hurt, and what's being held accountable is the fact he's being enabled to get the ball down field, regardless of the cost. Mike Wallace is not a physical receiver. Yet, they're throwing passes to him where he needs to go up and be physical. Roethlisberger should have been intercepted twice in the end zone, and we all saw the backward lateral blown call.
With such a vicious pass rush coming from Denver at the end of that game, other options could have been used. The Broncos weren't playing a two-minute defense, the Steelers could have run more underneath routes, and used their last timeout that way. Instead, it came after a sack.
The Steelers have invested high value draft picks in offensive linemen the last two years (C Maurkice Pouncey in the first round and T Marcus Gilbert in the second round). The decision to cut Max Starks at the beginning of the year and only to bring him back a few weeks later damaged their salary cap position. Starks hurts his knee and is replaced by the guy he sent to the bench in Week 5. And Jonathan Scott out-played him.
They need to find the right combination of offensive linemen. I wonder if Tomlin is thinking about Russ Grimm's return as an offensive coordinator.
The game of musical chairs the Steelers are playing with their offensive line, whether it's due to injuries or a lack of performance, is destroying their rhythm. Tomlin has to ask himself if Arians is the right leader for a potentially great offense that can't seem to get out of its own way.
Where The Streets Have No Name - U2
The city's aflood/And our love turns to rust/We're beaten and blown by the wind/Trampled in dust/I'll show you a place/High on a desert plain/Where the streets have no name
To Kevin Colbert and the Steelers front office. We're all anguishing in a tough loss in a season where things just never got on track. Colbert's never had a bigger challenge in all his time in Pittsburgh. The roster will likely be turned upside down, but he'll validate our faith in him. He'll show us that place, we just don't know where it is right now.
30 comments
|
Add comment
|
1 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Kudos Neal
right on point summarizing the season and what we need. It will be interesting to see if BA stays or not. Might show us just how much pull BB has if BA is kept as OC.
Orff - Carmina Bruana - O' Fortuna
Comes on strong, slowly builds to a full crescendo, and then goes out in a hail of bullets. Overall pervading feeling of the piece is impending dread of the unknown. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6oqGtAsUiyo&feature=related
"My mentality is singular in that I want to be world champs each and every year, so that's what we work toward. I have a tough time acknowledging levels of success short of that. That's just how I'm wired." - Mike Tomlin
Great article Neal
Good shout outs to the whole squad, and tough questions.
"My mentality is singular in that I want to be world champs each and every year, so that's what we work toward. I have a tough time acknowledging levels of success short of that. That's just how I'm wired." - Mike Tomlin
by MDSTEELERSFAN on Jan 9, 2012 12:06 PM EST up reply actions
that was great
Just what I needed at this moment and a great trigger for some less emotion-laden reflection. Thanks for making me think about the future.
One note about the past: everyone I encountered, on Facebook, around the office, at the bar, etc., was super-confident about a Steelers win yesterday. I never was and couldn’t get anyone to listen. When all ESPN game picks went our way, I really got worried. Good metaphor about the table. This is why I come here.
This
All week, I thought I was being fairly realistic in my assessment that the Steelers would beat the Broncos, but that their season would probably end the following week, due primarily to a ridiculous string of injuries.
I was positive they would beat Denver. To imagine Tebow winning that game defies almost everything I have learned about football. But, overconfidence is dangerous, road playoff games are almost always less predictable than expected, and one of our team’s worst performances against the best the Broncos had made the difference. There was some questionable game-planning, and some poor performances, but sometimes, that’s just how the chips fall in sports.
It was still a great season, and I’m glad there was once again playoff football. I expect this team back next season, looking a bit different, having gotten a lot younger, and hopefully with an effective, cohesive line, with a fresh infusion of young talent, finally being able to stay healthy and dominate.
The rest of it is out of my hands, but while yesterday hurt, I know I will be back for more in the Fall.
Wish all of you here a happy new year, and wish Kirby Wilson a swift recovery; my thoughts are with his family. Life is bigger than a game, even if it’s a fantastic one. Go Steelers.
"Football combines the two worst things about America: It is violence punctuated by committee meetings" -George Will
by lottwasgangsta on Jan 9, 2012 1:06 PM EST up reply actions
Off topic
Henley usually isn’t to far out of reach in my truck.
Excellent summation may I add. Could be the most important off season for the Steelers in quite a while.
"you will hardly know who I am or what I mean"-Walt Whitman
Excellent article Neal...
…this off year is a watershed for both the Steelers as a team, and Tomlin as a head coach.
For the team, so many older players, contract issues, money…these things will radically change the face of the Steelers in 2012 and beyond.
For Tomlin, you hit it right; what he does with LeBeau and Arians; how he addresses his coaching staff, and how he manages that staff, will set the tone for the Steelers for many years to come.
United we Stand, melded like Steel
To Roger Goodell, We'll never Yield.
Easy to imagine
what a depressing piece this could be for a lot of teams in this league. We in the steeler nation are a spoiled lot. Sucks to lose to the Broncos like we did but there’s a lot to look forward to.
Yesterday did kind of feel like a Twilight Zone moment
I’m hoping against hope that the Broncos put on a good show against the Pats and make our loss look somewhat less inexplicable.
Glory is fleeting, but obscurity is forever
-Napoleon Bonaparte
There’s a lot of stuff we wouldn’t have to clean up if the city provided basic human rights, like a Port-A-Potty.
-OWS Protester
Cornell University Class of 2014
by LV Steelers Fan on Jan 9, 2012 12:47 PM EST reply actions
drafts, roster
Looking forward to analysis of next year’s Steelers draft. Seems like we have many of the same needs as last year – offensive line, nose tackle, middle linebacker, corner. I’d love to score another game changer like a Polamalu one of these years.
I also have a question about "veteran minimums." Is a player permitted to voluntarily waive the minimum? For instance, if a certain veteran says I have made more than enough for the rest of my life already and all I really want is the chance to play one more year of football and I would do it for one dollar, is this permissible? I’m not suggesting this would happen here or anywhere else, but I am curious to know the answer.
Interested to see what changes are made to the team going into next year.
I highly doubt that's an option for players
If a team isn’t willing to pay a vet the minimum, it’s not b/c they can’t squeeze him under the cap. It’s just b/c he’s no longer of any use to them on the field. It’s too easy to rework one contract to clear up a million dollars or whatever to squeeze in a veteran if they’re paid the minimum.
by average joe blow on Jan 9, 2012 4:11 PM EST up reply actions
thank you Steelers! #1
To the Steelers, thank you! I appreciated this season even though it ended with dissapointment. As always, the black and gold gave it everything they had. We came up short but we are and will remain the greatest ever. The black and gold is in my blood and bones forever.
Go Steelers!
Strength, Courage, Commitment, and Excellence!
LeBeau
Is Lebeau the right leader for the team’s trademark defense?
Considering he basically invented it, I can’t think of any better. I think LeBeau should have the DC job in Pittsburgh as long as he wants it.
I know that LeBeau is getting criticism for his scheme yesterday, and my initial thoughts were along the same lines. The Steelers’ defensive plan under LeBeau has always been to generate pressure from unusual angles and avoid the big offensive play (a 3-4 zone blitzing front under a Cover 2 shell), forcing the offensive to methodically move down the field and counting on them being unable to reliably do so. They departed from that in the Broncos game, bringing one or both safeties down to provide run support and forcing the corners to mostly cover without help, basically betting that Tebow wouldn’t be able to beat them.
But he did – Tebow was 6-13 on passes labeled “deep” (plus getting a DPI). Conversely, he was only 4-8 on short or medium passes, and the Broncos were only 3-10 on 3rd down conversions. It seems at first glance that a “conventional” Steelers D – don’t give up any big plays and force the Broncos to sustain 10-play drives – would have been a lot more successful.
But perhaps LeBeau actually does know more than we do. The Steelers were playing on the road at altitude. The Broncos have an effective and physical running game. The Steelers’ D started the game thin and got thinner as the game went on – by the third play of the second quarter, the Steelers had only three defensive linemen left.
I think that LeBeau and Tomlin were concerned that keeping the D on the field for extended Denver drives – even if those drives eventually got stopped outside the end zone – would have led the the defense being so gassed by the fourth quarter that they would have been totally ineffective. They were willing to risk a “shootout” with Denver, because they felt that even an injured Ben had more ability to turn possessions into touchdowns than did Tebow, and fast Denver scores would at least get the defense off the field and preserve them for late in the game.
It didn’t work – Denver hit too many big plays and the Steelers didn’t – but I’m not so sure it was the wrong design.
Interesting thoughts
It could be the way they were thinking. They sure didn’t have a lot of warm bodies left to play around with by the end of it.
anyone trying to contact me via my yahoo account should be aware it has been hacked
by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Jan 9, 2012 2:26 PM EST up reply actions
Warm bodies
I agree, i think the injuries on D were the biggest hindrance to their performance, only 3 lineman for a whole game at altitude, Woodley is not close to 100%, plus Clark and injuries to the corners, I think that LeBeau did the best he could with what he had to work with on the day. The D has ranked 1st in pts against 3 of the past 4 years, yesterday might have been a bad day but any questions of LeBeau are unfounded in my opinion, the D is the last thing wrong with this team. Tomlin needs to man up and get rid of Arians, he enables Ben and has most likely shortened his career. Ben scrambling making plays and getting injured every year is not a recipe for success on offense. If they want to go vertical they need to set it up by running the ball and play action, which Arians hates to do. Under Arians we have been out of the top 10 in scoring 2 of 4 years, out of the top 20 the other 2 years. Just unacceptable in a league where teams with far less talent are putting up record numbers. I don’t understand why instead of a dedicated blocking back they use tight ends who are never thrown to and are sub-par at blocking, besides Heath who is way under utilized. The HC job is to make decisions on coaches and Tomlin needs to put his foot down and realize that Ben might like BA but in the age of offense, the Steelers have greatly underperformed every year. The offense never out scores anybody, the Defense holds them to less points, and that cannot continue. If we scored Td’s instead of FG’s yesterday that is a totally different game and even Wallaces TD was a very stupid playcall to run from the 1 yard line. Enough is enough, he’s gotta go.
Really Thoughtful post, Neal
I remember as a kid growing up with the Steelers in the 70’s when physicality ruled the day and the Steelers of Greene, Blount, Lambert, Shell et al built the legend of the black and gold on a foundation of black and blue hitting. Reminds me of the Mary Hopkin 1968 song “Those were the days”. Next year…
nice read Neal
and I even knew two of the songs.
Salary Cap issues will be forcing some hard choices on the team this winter and I expect to see several vets gone.
Adversity can promote growth. Maybe we will see some more growth from MT after this season. I love the guy but he still has a few things to work on (he wouldn’t be human if he didn’t).
anyone trying to contact me via my yahoo account should be aware it has been hacked
by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Jan 9, 2012 2:29 PM EST reply actions
What an exciting game.
I guess there is not enough time in the week of practice to practice a plan b for a poor passing quarterback to have a career game. You really can not blame Leblau to sticking to trying to put the pressure on Tebow.
As for our QB, he has to take some blame. Going for the big pass when short passes were open many times is not a winning strategy. This is not BA’s fault but BR. Its BA and Tomlin’s for not reigning Ben in.
How about Redman!!
by ibygeorge on Jan 9, 2012 2:39 PM EST via mobile reply actions
great set of counterpoints
however, i think ben, with the serious assist from Redman (!!), putting up 23 is pretty decent. totally second your thoughts about the defensive game plan. if tebow ever pulls out that kind of performance again, we’ll feel better, and if he doesn’t, we’ll feel better…i think…
A Good Year
This was a good, if confusing, year.
12 and 4 is good, and I don’t mind the loss, given how injured this team was.
Some components of this team overperformed. The pass defense over ths year was outstanding, notwithstanding that it played badly yesterday with three guys out. Brown was an amazing asset. I like our draft, with the young cornerbacks, Heyward and Gilbert. The return games improved.
I have been thinking about this squad as if it were the British army in WW2, a group of men who fought bravely and well, but who were continually misused by their generals who held fast to dogmatic plans.
First, Tomlin held on to older players even though they were ready to retire, convinced there was another 10000 miles on the tires. That is not the players’ fault, and loyalty is a noble thing. But I wish I had not seen Hines on the sideline fifth string yesterday… I could have lived without that picture. Aaron and Hoke both ended up on IR unsurprisingly, and Farrior never had it this year. The wear on the tires was not hard for many of us to see. Fortunately we developed youth.
Second, Tomlin and Arians don’t seem to view the OL realistically. The Standard is the Standard, ok, but you can’t spin straw into gold. Not on the lines. Our neglect of the OL gets Ben killed each year. So Ben ends up playing bravely through injuries, but he should not take the hits that he does. And I know the line… He takes more sacks because he holds the ball… Ok, but if the line play is half the problem, then that is half his risk of injury.
Third, there is the Offensive Doctrine. Gotta hit the Long Ball, no matter if your qb can’t plant his foot properly, even though it’s not his best pass, even though your line collapses at lt and lg, and even though your RB is getting your 6.5 per carry. Arians is Earl Weaver… In his love for the big play, his dogmatism, and his ability to keep weaker opponents in the game through neglect of the little things.
It was a good year still, although I would likenext year to be a different species of good year.
but you go to war with the army you have
I hear you about the veterans, but that’s why I like last year’s draft strategy. Farrior may be out of juice, physically, but he still served as cornerstone to the league’s best defense in the YPG & PPG categories—out there providing insight and leadership that created critical adjustments and kept the D on appropriate assignments.
No argument out of me on points two or three, though…
Great take on the situation.
The Steelers have gotten by for too long, banking on their talent to overcome mistakes in offensive strategy, poor clock management, etc. Arians and Ben deserve to be called out for doggedly pursuing a narrow scheme that ignores the best interests of the entire team. The fact that this was the first game where Redman played long enough to show his true value is another big screw-up. It’s an indication that, unless you’re a WR who can catch the deep ball, you don’t get much attention on this team.
I’m still not ready to admit that Denver played as well as it appeared. To me, it looked like we had absolutely our worst defensive outing in many a year. We also got out-coached because Denver seemed to know exactly how we were going to approach the game defensively. Once they started to hurt us with deep throws, we failed to adjust quickly enough. The poor games we played in KC and SF should have been a warning to us all. As much as I hate to say it, by the time this season ended, the Steelers were no better of a team than the Chiefs or the Bengals.
YEAH!
this is the type of stuff that makes me love this site. Thanks Neal, awesome article (as usual…ho hum)
This is the problem with the Flacco hate, people don’t really know who he is as a person. - Mr. Malor. Crazy Raven fan/possible stalker.
Isn't it great to be jaded with posts like this
I don’t think I have seen any other NFL site (professional or fan based) that has the overall quality and depth of writing that we get here. So many solid writers, each with something different to bring to the table, and knowledgeable fans who discuss and comment on the articles.
We are lucky.
anyone trying to contact me via my yahoo account should be aware it has been hacked
by Cold_Old_Steelers_Fan on Jan 10, 2012 12:49 AM EST up reply actions
Absolutely.
The "each with something different’ i especially like.
This is the problem with the Flacco hate, people don’t really know who he is as a person. - Mr. Malor. Crazy Raven fan/possible stalker.
I appreciate
Ike Taylor’s humility and accepting responsibility for his part in the tough loss yesterday. We all know he is more comfortable “Swaggin’”, but to have him now in the opposite position and accepting his shortcomings & failures is somehow refreshing…
I am sure this game will help to propel him forward to come back next season in even better shape and even more mentally focused and motivated to achieve greater success!
Thanks Neal for the great write-ups here and throughout the year, stay positive and look forward to next season! :) -THO
A new quote for the Welcome to BTSC Box
“Insightful football talk enlightened by amazing pop culture references” – Flying Polamalus
Just off the top of my still-PTSD’d head, the quote could apply willy-nilly to any poast by collaborators as diverse as Neal, Momma, Mechem and John, just to name a few.
Kudos, Neal. One more bandage on our gaping wounds…
"Sir Isaac is the Englishman who ran up the hill but ran downhill from a mountain" - Flying Polamalus, Browns-Steelers Game Thread Jan. 1, 2012
by Flying Polamalus on Jan 10, 2012 8:23 AM EST reply actions
Bruce and Ben
These guys need to really look in the mirror and sort thing s out I know after 12-4 its hard to say bad things but here it is
Ben your not Manning or Breez ,Rogers ,Brady so stop trying to be its not that you cant win just has many games or Super Bowls but just know that in the NFL you play a different style than these other guys it does not make you lesser that you don’t throw for 50 tds and 6000 yard a season but last i seen these thing are not needed to win Super Bowls and I think you know that is what is remembered , SO be you and and live off the running game and if need be like the Cards SB you have to go 5 wide than go ahead and do it ..
On to you Bruce your QB is injured and in the last 2 games you throw the ball over 80 times really I see no big plays coming from your games plans most of the big plays or even TD passes come on a broken scramble play that results from Bens ability to make something out of your predictable plays .Did you see how successful you can be with play action well I think you did when Tebow put on a clinic, and the sad thing is we ran the ball better then the broncos but you refused to make the passing game go thru the run most every time you passed was out of shotgun 5 wide formations and ever time you ran was I formation or 1 back 2 or 3 TE this is not rocket science its football and the Denver Broncos gave you a strong blow to you and Bens ego if you only would have just kept it simple …..
Rocksitter

by 




































