If I was Kevin Colbert I would

After all the work I put in analyzing the top 3 rounds of draft targets and the potential free agents, I have decided to now tell you all what I would do if I was Kevin Colbert.


  • Casey Hampton (unless he will restructure down to around the vet minimum) - If Casey Hampton won't let the Steelers redo his contract to something near the vet minimum, he has to be cut. I am assuming he won't do that as it is a massive pay cut and he could likely get $4 to $5 million from another team.
  • Chris Kemoatu - Kemoatu is awful and needs to be replaced. Cutting him and saving the money is the best move the Steelers could make.
  • Anthony Madison - Madison is a great ST player but with the emergence of Curtis Brown, Stevenson Sylvester, and other young players, their is no room for him on the roster. Cut him and save about $1 million dollars.
Restructure/Pay Cut
  • Hines Ward (to almost the vet minimum) - If Hines is unwilling to take a massive pay cut to about the vet minimum, he would move up to the cut category. However, I think he will do it and serve a purpose as a blocking WR and a #4/#5 WR.
  • James Farrior - Farrior can still bring it and if we can get him under $2 million for this year, he should be kept. His leadership can't be replaced with anybody.
  • Larry Foote - Foote for the vet minimum is what we need. As a backup LB and a ST player as well as a leader in the locker room, he is an invaluable member of the Steelers.

Not Resign

  • Dennis Dixon - Dixon is a bum who does not want to be in Pittsburgh.
  • Max Starks - Starks should not be resigned until the Steelers know he is healthy. It is unlikely anyone else signs him so if we need a LT in September, we could sign him again.
  • Charlie Batch - Batch has been a great member of the Steelers and has been fantastic when called upon but we need to get a younger backup QB in the mix.
  • Jerricho Cotchery - Cotchery will likely want to go somewhere where he can start or be a #3 WR and that is not in Pittsburgh. If he is willing to play the #4 WR spot, maybe you resign him.
  • Aaron Smith - Smith will likely retire but if he does not, the Steelers won't be bringing him back.
  • Bryant McFadden - McFadden contributes almost nothing to the Steelers.
  • Daniel Sepulveda - Sepulveda is a great punter but is always injured and Kapinos had a great year last year.
  • Trai Essex - Essex is a good, versatile backup but he does not need to be signed right away. If we get into the season and injuries pile up, the Steelers could give him a call and resign him.
  • Mewelde Moore - Moore has been a good 3rd down back but it is time to move on. Batch is a younger option and the Steelers are deep at RB.


  • Mike Wallace - Wallace has to be kept. Whether they work out a long term deal or not does not matter. I think Todd Haley could make him even better than he already is.
  • Ramon Foster - Foster is a borderline starting quality guard and he should be kept. His best value is as a backup guard and that is what he will be paid to be.
  • David Johnson - Johnson serves his purpose as an H-Back/TE#2 and they could keep him for the minimum most likely.
  • William Gay - Gay was one of the better nickel corners in the NFL last year and he should be resigned. A 2 or 3 year deal for about $5 million seems like fair value.
  • Keenan Lewis - Lewis had an awesome year as the #2 CB and finally showed why the Steelers picked him in the 3rd round.
  • Doug Legursky - Legursky is a great backup OG/C and he should be kept.
  • Ryan Mundy - Mundy had a good season filling in for both Polamalu and Clark when needed and should be resigned. I like him as a future starter.
  • Byron Leftwich - Leftwich should be brought back for the veteran minimum to compete for the QB #2 spot.


  • Josh Johnson, QB, Tampa Bay - A contract of around 3 years $6 million very back loaded - Johnson be brought in to be a backup QB. He has the potential to possibly become a starter so he could end up being a valuable trade chip.
  • Kraig Urbik, OG, Buffalo - A contract of around 3 years $8 million - Colbert must make up for his sin of letting Urbik go. Urbik was one of the better guards in all of football last year but because he is a one year wonder, he might not be valued as such.
  • Sammie Lee Hill, NT, Detroit - A contract of about 4 years $12 million - Hill has shown potential to be a starting NT and with the depth and talent the Lions have at DT, they will probably let him go. It might cost us a late draft pick because he is restricted but it is worth it as long as it is not in the top 3 rounds.
  • Shaun Ellis, DE, New England - A one year vet minimum contract - Ellis can be brought in to be a backup DE (we only have 3 DE's on the roster) and a mentor to our younger DL. He probably wants to try and win a Super Bowl and what better place to do it?


  • Round 1 Pick 24 and Round 5 Pick 24 to the Philadelphia Eagles for Round 2 Pick 14 and Round 2 Pick 19 - The Steelers would be best off moving their first round pick either up or down. This is within 1 point on the trade value scale and would help both teams.


  • 2.14 - Brandon Washington, OG/OT, Miami - Washington is a versatile player who will likely be a guard at the next level. Pairing him with Urbik as our starting guards and with Legursky and Foster backing them up, the guard position would go from a weakness to a strength.
  • 2.19 - Ronnell Lewis, ILB, Oklahoma - Lewis is an athletic LB capable of covering RB's and TE's. He could play a year of special teams and limited defensive snaps while he learns the system.
  • 2.24 - Alameda Ta'amu, NT/DT, Washington - Despite signing Hill, the Steelers could use a guy like Ta'amu. With the Steelers going to more and more 4 man fronts, they could use a 2nd DT and Ta'amu can do it all. He can stop the run, and rush the passer.
  • 3.24 - Stephen Hill, WR, Georgia Tech - Hill is a massive, athletic WR with all the tools to become a dominate guy. Haley and Ben would be running around and screaming for joy if the Steelers got Hill and Haley could turn him into the next Dwayne Bowe.
  • 4.24 - Brandon Taylor, S, LSU - Taylor is an athletic S that can play both spots. He is able to play ST and as a 4th safety, he has the potential to become a potential starter.
  • 6.24 - Blair Walsh, K, Washington - Walsh is the best kicker in the draft and his combination of accuracy and power will make him the next great Steelers kicker.
  • 7.24 - Edwin Baker, RB, Michigan State - Baker is a versatile back who could compete for that 4th RB spot with Jonathan Dwyer.
Log In Sign Up

Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Behind the Steel Curtain

You must be a member of Behind the Steel Curtain to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Behind the Steel Curtain. You should read them.

Join Behind the Steel Curtain

You must be a member of Behind the Steel Curtain to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Behind the Steel Curtain. You should read them.




Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.