But numbers can be deceiving, and before engaging in unfounded speculation or assuming answers that may not be correct, maybe some dissection of Roethlisberger's statistical performance is in order.
Roethlisberger shared the top ten with the usual suspects such as Aaron Rogers of the Green Bay Packers, Peyton Manning of the Denver Broncos and Tom Brady of the New England Patriots who were ranked first, second and sixth respectively. Surprisingly, two rookies, Robert Griffin III of the Washington Redskins and Russell Wilson of the Seattle Seahawks, ranked third and fourth respectively, finishing ahead of the Steelers' QB, as did Matt Ryan of the Atlanta Falcons. Drew Brees of the New Orleans Saints, Matt Schaub of the Houston Texans and Tony Romo (eighth, ninth and tenth respectively) round out the top ten.
(You can click on each graph to enlarge it for better viewing)
First, Roethlisberger's final stat line and NFL Passer Rating for the 2012 season:
There are stats other than the NFL's Passer rating used to measure and compare a quarterback's performance, but to avoid arguments over any strengths or weaknesses in them, the NFL's Passer Rating as the most commonly used was chosen as the basis for this analysis.
The first and most obvious positive observation to be made is that Roethlisberger managed to rank as high as he did (seventh) despite missing three games (18.75 percent of the season), and apparently not being 100 percent physically and/or mentally upon his return for the final three games of the season. What's even more impressive is that Roethlisberger is ranked just behind Brayd (98.7) and ahead of Shaub (90.7), both of whom are in the playoffs.
The next aspect to consider is how well Roethlisberger did given his receiving corps' performance; obviously a quarterback needs receivers who can hang onto the ball with some regularity in order for his QB rating to benefit.
To avoid an endless debate over what organization's metric best quantifies the performance of receivers, this analysis is limited to just two: Football Outsiders' rankings of wide receivers based on its DVOA, DYAR and YAR metrics, and Advanced NFL Stats' overall rankings of wide receivers. Although their methodologies differ, they both arrive at roughly the same conclusions.
Each organization's individual rankings of receivers was grouped by team, and the rankings of each team's receivers was averaged to find how the teams' full receiving corps were ranked; the lower the average ranking, the better performing the receiving corps.
Quite simply, the Steelers' receivers collectively ranked in the bottom third of the league in both organizations' performance rankings, and last out of the ten groups of receivers catching passes from the top ten ranked QBs as shown in the first two tables below. The last two tables show the Steelers' top receivers and their scores by the respective ranking organizations.
Simply put, Roethlisberger was a top ten passer despite throwing to a sub-par performing receiving corps.
This ranking would improve somewhat if tight ends were added to the mix, given the Pro-Bowl year the Steelers' Heath Miller was having, but not to a degree sufficient to change the overall standings or lessen the impact of the poor performance of Steelers wide receivers Mike Wallace, Emmanuel Sanders and Antonio Brown.
Roethlisberger's season long passer rating of 97 was achieved game by game as shown below; the dotted blue line represents his rating per game, the solid red line shows his rating on a cumulative basis.
As is shown in the graph above, Roethlisberger's final passer rating was aided greatly by the four games where he achieved a rating over 120. During the Steelers' sole winning streak, between the bye in Week 4 and his injury in Week 10 against the Kansas City Chiefs, Roethlisberger's performance was generally erratic, ranging from a low of 85.4 against the Philadelphia Eagles, to a high of 121 against the Washington Redskins. For that period, Roethlisberger's cumulative passer rating was 94.4 which alone would have ranked ninth out the top ten.
Upon his return from injury, Roethlisberger's performance was generally poor, with only the last game of the season against the Browns being well played. The graph below illustrates Roethlisberger's cumulative passer rating for the season by quarter, as well as his cumulative rating before and after his injury:
On a quarterly basis Roethlisberger's season passing statistics can be broken down as shown in the table below:
From an effectiveness standpoint, the table above indicates that the third quarter was the most successful quarter for Roethlisberger throughout the season.
On a quarter by quarter basis, the table and graph below breaks down Roethlisberger's performance in a manner to account for most aspects and milestones of the season:
Despite his third quarter performance record, it is the second quarter that Roethlisberger threw the most (10 or 38 percent) of his 26 touchdowns, although his completion percentage is the lowest of the regular four quarters and is what made the most difference between his second and third quarter ratings.
Roethlisberger's touchdown and interception performance by quarter is illustrated below:
Much can be said, has been said, and undoubtedly will be said of Roethlisberger's performance after his return from injury starting in Week 14, in particular whether he was mentally or physically ready to play given some of the questionable decisions he made. However, from a performance standpoint it would be a mistake to pin the Steelers' 8-8 season solely on the arm of their franchise quarterback or Todd Haley's new offensive scheme; Roethlisberger's attitude towards his new OC may have had an influence, and certainly the continuing revolving door of offensive line configurations and the very erratic rushing attack hampered any continuity the Steelers offense tried to establish, but statistically Roethlisberger didn't have a bad season; he just made some crucial errors at key points in crucial games near the end.
The interceptions in the Chargers, Cowboys and last Bengals game certainly killed any chances for the Steelers to manage the much needed wins necessary to qualify for the playoffs, but equal blame for those games being so crucial can be shared with the Steelers' defense which allowed teams like the Oakland Raiders and Tennessee Titans to defeat the Steelers early in the season. Those losses, added to Roethlisberger's questionable condition upon his return and all the other injuries accumulated along the way were just too much for the team to overcome.