Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Jerry Sandusky's Wife Tries To Run A Reporter Over

Awaiting An Update on Santonio Holmes Ankle; Time To Go Back To Starks?

I don't think it was mentioned by me, or anybody else, in the interesting post-game conversation threads that Santonio Holmes missed time in Sunday's game with an ankle injury. It's nice that the team has an extra day to rest and prepare for the Dolphins next Monday night, but it would be presumptous to assume Holmes will play. I mention it because our offense is a lot easier to gameplan for when he's not in there. Nate Washington's improved a little bit this year, but sorry, isn't going to ever get more than single-coverage. Anyway, it's Tuesday, so we should get an update on Holmes from Tomlin sometime this afternoon. No guarantees we get more than a uninformative, non-committal answer, but I'm anxiously awaiting none the less.

*****************

One quick thought about the line that I wanted to throw out there. Is it time to give Max Starks another opportunity in place of Willie Colon? I'm still learning how to evaluate talent at offensive line - it's obvious when you see a great lineman, but it's less obvious to me distinguishing between average players - but my guess is that Colon has a bit more potential long-term than Starks. Colon must be pretty raw playing high school ball in the Bronx, then college ball at Hofstra. Hopefully, at least. Clearly his foot speed isn't great, but perhaps with professional instruction he can learn some techniques to mask that.

Has it been said or written anywhere (or even reasonable to believe) that Starks is not playing because he won't be a Steeler in 2008, so might as well get Colon some valuable experience to see what they have in Colon as soon as possible?

Starks isn't great, but he's basically on an extended tryout for teams around the league, so maybe he'd step it up and give us a solid stretch of football.

Thoughts?

Comment 10 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Holmes was missed on Sunday
I'll have to make sure and ask Ed today in his chat.

Colon has been unimpressive but I'd rather see Simmons get replaced than Willie. At least Willie is young enough to get better (24 years old). Simmons looks like a guy who worked his ass off to get a contract and is fat and happy now.

"The more violent team will win tonight" - Mike Tomlin.

by cgolden on Nov 20, 2007 12:58 PM EST reply actions  

Yes
Willie is young enough to get better, but might Starks give us a bettter, albeit probably smaller, chance to win now?

by Michael Bean on Nov 20, 2007 1:13 PM EST reply actions  

Bad Bad Bad news
Holmes and Troy not expected to play Monday, both listed as doubtful.
"The more violent team will win tonight" - Mike Tomlin.

by cgolden on Nov 20, 2007 1:19 PM EST reply actions  

If this don't say it all...
I particularly liked this line from the injury report -- "Tomlin said three players will be involved in replacing Holmes --- Cedrick Wilson, Nate Washington and Willie Reid."  

Guess that's a testament to Santonio's ability.

by Cotter on Nov 20, 2007 2:07 PM EST reply actions  

OR
the lack of ability of those three.
"The more violent team will win tonight" - Mike Tomlin.

by cgolden on Nov 20, 2007 2:10 PM EST up reply actions  

Indeed
you are correct sir. I'd like to have faith in them, but I'm not even sure all 3 together can equal Santonio's ability.

by Cotter on Nov 20, 2007 2:18 PM EST up reply actions  

Willie Reid
About damn time. I really hope he steps up and can be our 3rd WR. Our recievers inablility to get open really hurt us in NY especially after Holmes was injured.

Also all the sudden we're really thin at Safety. Good thing Tomlin had some of his cornerbacks learn safety in the offseason.

by schnifin on Nov 20, 2007 3:33 PM EST reply actions  

no worries
I'm glad the announcement was made right away that Troy and Santonio will not play vs. Miami. They need to get healthy. Their replacements and everyone else need to get focused on the task at hand.  I'm sure they will. I was worried about the Jets but not the least concerned about the Dolphins. It's their misfortune to catch us coming off a bad game and playing at home on MNF. This will be an easy win and will give other players, especially at WR, a chance to step in and make some plays. I think Washington has done a nice job and he is the No. 3 guy, so he is really the guy on the spot to play well. I'd like to see what Reid can do, too. He looked okay earlier in the season.

As much as we would all like to see some changes in the O-line, I doubt Tomlin will replace anyone unless there is an injury. I think the sad fact is that Starks is not as good as Colon and Kemo is not as good as Simmons.  If it was close, we would have seen a change by now. Perhaps a big first-half lead will allow Kemo an extended look at RG or Simmons to move over to center and get some game-action there. Unlikely, but I think those would be our only options for potential improvement up front in the near term.

by steeler lifer on Nov 20, 2007 5:31 PM EST reply actions  

Potential OL changes
I think the amazing thing is that the Steelers OL is playing this badly and injuries haven't been a factor at all. The same five has started all the games so far this year. That's a stark contrast to many teams like the Redskins and Colts who are struggling to put 6 healthy lineman on the field for game day.

I think it's time for Tomlin to let Simmons and Colon and everyone else know (especially on kickoff coverage) that if you aren't doing your job, in all fairness to this football team, then someone else will be given that opportunity.

Tomlin said something interesting about kickoff coverage in his interview with Steelers Digest. Here is the question by Digest editor Bob Labriola and Tomlin's answer.

Q. What constitutes good kickoff coverage in your mind?

Tomlin: To me, it's a personality. You display your personality as a football team on kickoff coverage. It's about speed, it's about defeating blocks and making tackles. Yard line statistics and things of that nature are really irrelevant to me. It's man on man. You've got to defeat people, you have to make tackles.

If that is truly the case, then the personality of this team is charmin soft because the kickoff coverage is really bad. As I've said before, I think the team's kickoff coverage is fixable. And I don't mean pooch-kicking the rest of the season as well. Either use a few more starters on D or get rid of the backups who aren't making plays and signing those who will.

Guys like Verron Hayes and Chidi are still out there. I think Ben Roethlisberger would be the first guy to give Tomlin a hug if V. Hayes came back. Hayes has made his share of tackles on the coverage teams and has excelled at being Ben's bodyguard in blitz pickup on passing downs.

Hayes could walk in tomorrow and be the best blitz pickup running back on the team as well as 3rd down back. Chidi still wants work, although I do like W. Gay and A. Madison on the coverage teams.

Blitzburgh, I know you'd like to give Starks a chance, but I still think Colon is a better option. Colon has had a couple of bad games, but Starks just cannot move his feet well enough to keep Ben from not getting killed. The reality is that injuries occur, and Starks will probably get his shot sometime this season, whether we want him to or not. I don't see how Chris K. could be worse than Simmons, but apparently Tomlin and his staff doesn't feel the same way.  

I am truly disappointed in the way this team is playing right now and in the opportunities that it has squandered. Your thoughts?

by datruth4life on Nov 22, 2007 3:41 AM EST reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the SIX-time world champion Steelers.

"Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history."

Art Rooney Jr.

"Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Small
A Letter to Hines Ward
Franco72_small
The Last Sunday
Small
Joe Greene on Steelers Offense Under BA
Small
Homer reps BTSC and Steeler Nation on Washington Post Front Page
Small
Your Super Bowl Hate Guide

Recent FanPosts

Small
My Top 11 2nd Round Prospects
Small
Who are your Top 5 Steelers of all time?
Steel-ball-logo-poster_small
Knowing Your Guards: A look at the 2012 Prospects (Updated 2/11/12)
Rodthreerivers_small
Report: Steelers Don't Want Ward
Small
Analyzing the Steelers 2008 Draft
Small
My Top 11 Prospects for our First Round Pick
Small
Ike Taylor restructures, over 18 million in cap space created so far this offseason
Small
Analyzing the Steelers 2009 Draft
Small
6 Round NFL Mock Draft

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

Terrible Towel Talk

Listen to internet radio with Michael Bean on Blog Talk Radio


Site Founder & Editor

Imag0299_small Michael Bean

Steelers Historian

Steeler_small maryrose

Bison_small Neal Coolong

Contributing Authors

Small Ivan Cole (RickVa)

Franco72_small 5020

Btsc_head_shot_small Rebecca Rollett

Small big_jay71

Stogs_small John Stephens

178896_499126548441_596563441_5939410_7960015_n_small Anthony Defeo