Behind the Steel Curtain: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Steve McNair Dead - Former NFL QB Shot and Killed


Another Ex-Player Speaks Out....

A month or so ago former defensive back Andre Watters was so depressed that he committed sucide. A few weeks ago former Patriots LB Ted Johnson feared he may be heading down a similar path. Now it's recently retired NYG RB Tiki Barber who is speaking out against the phsyical demands of playing in today's NFL.

In an interview with the New York Post, Barber said that it was only 'an act of God' that he didn't get seriously hurt as a result of the physical demands placed on him and his teamates by head coach Tom Coughlin.

Coach Coughlin is very hard-nosed, and I didn't get a lot of time off, couldn't sit down and rest myself, and so it was a constant grind - a physical grind on me that started to take its toll. There'd be days where I couldn't move on Tuesday or Wednesday at practice, and he'd get mad at me for going half-speed."

Are young men sacrificing a lifetime of mental and physical normality and health in order to succeed for a short period of time in the National Football League? This is a debate that I believe is only going to heat up in the forthcoming years, as more and more evidence piles up linking the game of football with long-term cognitive impairment. This isn't our father's and grandfather's NFL...today's players are so big, so fast, so strong, and (perhaps) so jacked up on HGH and steroids that the phsyical toll of the game has the potential to be far greater than it was decades ago. And it was pretty damn physical back then. It's a war-zone out there between the lines, and if you're too scared or too hurt to go back out there and absorb the physical punishment time after time in order to help you're team win, well, the coach and upper-management will find someone who is willing and able to go out there.

Many of us, myself included, love the game because of what it demands from the players. The speed of the game is breathtaking, the big hits are fun to re-watch on the DVR, and the amount of physicality needed to execute a 10-yard run up the middle is interesting to think about and break down.  Football is also the consumate team sport, as the physicality of the game can deflate even the biggest of egos. These are just a few of the myriad reasons why I enjoy watching the games each Sunday. But, after hearing and reading about the suicide of Waters, and the disintegration of Ted Johnson's physical and mental well-being recently, I have begun to feel almost guilty about taking so much pleasure in following today's NFL.

It saddens me to read stories or hear about retired players , men in they're 60's and 70s, who receive less than $500 dollars per month in disability from the NFL, yet are so debilitated from prior injuries that they haven't been able to hold a job for years.

I know we live in a 'what have you done for me lately?' type of world, and I am aware that this mentality leads to great games week in and week out. But, when the long-term physical and mental health of players is being mortgaged, far more is at stake than the opportunity to play for a Lombardi Trophy.

Discuss.

0 recs | Comment 5 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

We're making progress.
Players are doing a lot better in terms of contracts and post-play treatment, and medical science is shedding enormous light on the longterm implications of playing football. Anectodes abound as well, meaning you don't have to be a scientist to understand the gravity of playing a career of Football.

In the specific instance of Tiki Barber, you have to imagine this is a self-correcting problem. There isn't any utility in playing your star RB into the ground so that he has to retire prematurely. Herman Edwards deserves enormous criticism for his handling of Larry Johnson, by giving him 416 carries. No other player had 350, which is about the threshold for maintaining a career.

The natural progression is a shift to dual-back systems which reduces wear and tear on Running Backs. As an example, Tiki Barber's experience under Coughlin couldn't be more different than CP's under Gibbs. Clinton Portis spells himself whenever he feels like it. The emergence of Ladell Betts as a quality runner can only be good for CP and the organization, because now they have a 25 year old back who won't need to carry the ball 350 times a year. It's no surprise we lost CP after two consecutive near 350 carry years. The team won't make the same mistake in the future by overplaying him.

That could go for other positions as well, as many teams heavily utilize rotation defenses. Eventually we could see an increase in roster sizes.

Hopefully players, owners, and coaches will all realize that what's good for players is good for the latter two as well. Running your guys into the ground can only lead to embarrassment (60s and 70s players treatment), early retirement of stud RBs (Tiki Barber), or early injury. Poor Herman Edwards and Larry Johnson cannot see that, yet.

Great post, by the way.

by Skin Patrol on Feb 14, 2007 11:57 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

they are big, grown up men who make their choices
you've hit on a pet peeve of mine, though:

This isn't our father's and grandfather's NFL...today's players are so big, so fast, so strong, and (perhaps) so jacked up on HGH and steroids that the phsyical toll of the game has the potential to be far greater than it was decades ago.

This whole idea that everyone is so big, so strong, and so fast and that this NFL is so much tougher than the older NFL is nonsense. It has always been a brutal game and size has little to do with it's brutality. If anything, medical care and technology (helmet design, etc) has made it a safer game than it was 30 years ago.

Having gotten that off my chest, these guys make their choice about what they want to do with their career. They also choose how long to stick with it. They're given access to financial counseling, career counseling, etc. What they need to do is take that stuff more serious when they're going in.

Tiki Barber made his, and given the circumstance it was the right one for him to make. Don't hold it against him, but don't spend a lot of time feeling sorry for him either.

Go Big Red Nebraska!
Corn Nation

by cornnation on Feb 15, 2007 9:01 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Corn....
Ok man whatever you say. I guess the laws of physics don't count on the football field.

by Blitzburgh on Feb 15, 2007 11:15 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

I always knew that
F = ma crap was nonsense. Damn you, Newton.

He does have one point - players wear much more protection now than they did in the old days. It'd be suicide to step on today's field in a sweat-shirt and leather helmet.

by Desroko on Feb 16, 2007 3:31 PM EST to parent up reply reply actions actions   0 recs

As for your other points...
I agree. Players should be aware of the inherent risks involved in the game and plan accordingly, both health wise and financially.

by Blitzburgh on Feb 15, 2007 11:16 AM EST reply reply actions actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to BTSC, a blog dedicated to the SIX-time world champion Steelers.

"Thoughtful discussion with a sense of history."

Art Rooney Jr.

"Level-headed thinking." Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

Start posting about the Steelers »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Pc290207_small
Top 5 NFL Players I'd like to punch in the face
Small
Six time the charm
P4070003_small
Signature Moments / The Top 8 of 2008-09 For The Pittsburgh Steelers

Recent FanPosts

Small
Heckling
Small
Rooting For Injuries
2163310289_196904cec9_small
Steve McNair found shot to death
Horns_small
A poll...
Small
53 man roster
Horns_small
Troy Polamalu
A546203962b8877l_small
My Pittsburgh Steelers 2008-2009 Tribute Video
Small
AFC CHAMPIONSHIP GAME LOSSES-WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN?
Small
Steelers radio broadcast question

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini

SPONSORS


Site Founder & Editor

Mbean_small Blitzburgh

Steelers Historian

Steeler_small maryrose

Bringing You Your Daily Six Pack

Plainview_small drinkyourmilkshake

Official Partner of Yahoo! Sports