State of the Steelers' Rosters: Safety
Overview: No other position was as effected by injuries as significantly as the safety position was in 2007. Together the two starters combined to miss 16 games. The effects of their absence became more apparent as the season progressed. The four safeties on the 2007 roster are all signed through at least 2008 and none of them should be in danger of being cut.
Troy Polamalu
Age and '07 Statistics: 26 years old (4/19/81), 58 total tackles, 9 passes defended in 11 games
Contract Status: signed through 2011 with cap hits of $4.57 million (2008), $7.245 million (2009), $9.045 million (2010), $9.345 million (2011)
2007 Analysis: Troy suffered through a couple of different injuries and played in a career low 11 games. He also set a career low (not counting his rookie year, when he wasn't a starter) in tackles, sacks (0), and interceptions (0). Polamalu was still pretty effective when he was healthy but he lacked the special playmaking ability that made him so popular and disruptive in previous seasons.
2008 Outlook: 2007 was the second consecutive season that injuries kept Troy from playing a full season, or anything even close to it. His reckless style of play is what has made him great but at the same time it has to be considered a contributing factor to the recent rash of injuries. Hopefully the past two seasons were not a sign of things to come. Troy at some point might have to scale back his kamikazi style in order to stay healthy, but the question is whether he is the same type of impact player without it. Either way though, it doesn't take a genius to look at the remainder of his contract and realize how vital it is for the Steelers to have a healthy and productive Troy Polamalu patrolling the secondary.

Anthony Smith
Age and '07 Statistics: 24 years old (9/20/83), 69 total tackles, 2 Ints, and 3 passes defended in 16 games (10 starts)
Contract Status: signed through 2008 with a cap hit of $619K
2007 Analysis: Smith probably had the most up and down season of any Steelers player in 2007. He lost a preseason battle with Ryan Clark for the starting free safety job only to see Clark suffer a freak spleen injury just six games into the season. After Clark went down, Smith burst on the scene in a big way the very next game against Cincinnati. He had a couple of crushing hits on both Cincy receivers and totaled 10 tackles. Smith performed great for the next couple of games and at times had us all wondering how he didn't win the job in the preseason. But, it only took two absolutely horrible games to bring Smith back down to earth and the bench, and to remind us that at only 24 years of age, Smith still has plenty to learn. After getting beat repeatedly in both games, he was benched for third string safety, Tyrone Carter.
2008 Analysis: There's no doubt that Smith had a rough 2007, but there also shouldn't be any doubt that this guy has the physical tools to be a really good safety in this league. At his age some immaturity and lack of discipline shouldn't be all that surprising, but when he plays up to his ability, he has the potential to be a good player. Smith is entering the final year of his rookie contract and if he wants to chance to play in Pittsburgh he'll have to play better in all areas in 2008.
Ryan Clark
Age and '07 Statistics: 28 years old (10/12/79), 22 tackles, 1 sack, 3 passes defended in 6 games
Contract Status: signed through 2009 with cap hits of $2.2 million (2008) and $2.4 million (2009)
2007 Analysis: Clark was off to a solid start in 2007 and on pace for around 60 tackles before an odd pre-existing injury to his spleen caused him to miss the final ten games of the year. Clark isn't a flashy player like his younger counterpart Anthony Smith but he's a reliable veteran who knows where to be at all times, no matter what the offense is doing. His value was underestimated until we got to see this defense without him.
2008 Outlook: Clark is still relatively young and as long as he can fully recover from this injury there's no reason why he shouldn't be a starter for the next couple of years. Clark's main job at free safety is to stay deep and he does it better than anyone who is currently on the roster. His reliability and consistency is a true asset to the Steelers future.
Tyrone Carter
Age and '07 Statistics: 31 years old (3/31/76), 56 tackles, .5 sacks, 2 passes defended in 16 games
Contract Status: signed through 2009, with cap hits of $823K (2008) and $838 (2009)
2007 Analysis: Carter played in all sixteen games and started 5 of them. He filled in pretty well for a third string safety, although ultimately his 2007 will be remembered for getting juked by David Garrard in the playoff game. Carter is best suited as a backup safety and special team's player but he's not horrible if he has to start a game or two. In his first two starts he totaled 20 tackles.
2008 Outlook: Carter's price tag is cheap enough to keep him around for the remainder of his contract and he's versatile enough to play both safety spots. He's probably better suited to play the strong safety role because he's a better tackler/run supporter than a deep cover guy. Hopefully the next several years will be marked by fewer injuries than was the case in 2007, allowing Carter to focus on special teams as opposed to being a starting safety.
Needs: If there were fewer holes in the OL and DL, safety might be a higher priority in this years draft. When this unit is healthy, its a strong unit with plenty of depth. But as soon as Troy gets dinged the safety position is in trouble. If Smith can take a step towards becoming a more reliable player and away from a volatile, inconsistent youngster, the safety position can be the strength of our secondary, as well as one of the better overall units on either side of the ball. Where do you rank the secondary position in terms of need going into the draft and free agency period? Can Smith turn the corner and become the player some of us still believe that he can be?
0 recs |
13 comments
Comments
ill go first then
But, despite having 4 guys who are capable of being starters, I still have questions. Carter shouldnt be more than a backup for a top-ranked defense, no two ways about it. I think Smith can be a very good player, but he's not there yet. Can't definitively say he'll be anything more than a pretty good, serviceable safety. I think he can be, but he's shown glimpses of having bad instincts. Clark's not a geriatric by any means, but he's not young either. And then there's Troy, who will go down as one of the all-time most beloved Steelers players. But, as ive said a few times this year, Polamalu just hasn't been one of the league's top three safetys for two years now. He's fairly small for how reckless and wildly he plays. It's not a sure thing that he'll be able to stay healthy enough to do the kinds of things we grew enarmoed with in his first two years in Pittsburgh. 0 sacks and 0 INTs is hard to comprehend, even for a player that missed 5 games.
by Blitzburgh on
Feb 25, 2008 1:19 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
clarification
That doesnt really make sense. What I meant is that because of his small stature (only 5'11" and a shade over 200 lbs), it's not inconceivable to think he may continue to find himself on the shelf unless he finds a way to diversify how he attacks. All that chop tackling and slamming into blockers takes its toll.
by Blitzburgh on
Feb 25, 2008 1:21 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Safety
A Smith is an intriguing player. I love the way he hits. He comes from a great football program. He has solid people to learn from. I hated that he mouthed off to the Pats* last year and didn't back it up. I also didn't like that when faced with adversity he seemed to dip instead of rise up. He got beat on too many deep balls last year. That said, he is young and I feel will improve. He may be a starter this year because
I am not sure about Ryan Clarke. It's not his play that worries me as he is a savvy veteran and the D played much better with him than without him. What worries me about Clarke is he is sans spleen. How can a Safety come back from that? While he is tougher than Chris Sims (who never made it back after losing the spleen) I will be worried until I see him ball hawking on the field. Like Troy I am not sure how much shelf life he has left.
Ty Carter is nothing more than an emergency safety and a special teamer in my book. I like his hitting but I worry about him being overly aggressive and jawing/late hitting opponents. He will be needed on special teams as they were a debacle last year.
I also don't see them drafting a S in this draft. It is a need but they have so many other pressing needs that I believe they can get by with what they have. They also have young guys like Grant Mason and Mike Lorello that may step up
by 5020 on
Feb 25, 2008 1:46 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
It has been rumored...
If memory serves me correct, he went to Minnesota partly because of his relationship with then D Coor. Tomlin who was his position coach in TB.
I like this move if Clark is not healthy enough to play and he comes on the cheap.
As far as what we have on the team:
-Troy is special to watch. I agree with what has been said in that his wreck less style is both a benefit and a burden since it leads to some of his injuries
-Clark was very dependable and it is a shame he got this "freak" injury. I hope he can regain his playing form sans spleen.
-A. Smith will be a stud when/if he matures. He seems to be a play maker when he is out there. If he can put it together, he has the ability to be a pro-bowl caliber player.
-T. Carter is a good vet who I only hope sees the field on ST and in blowouts.
by _ET_ on
Feb 25, 2008 2:11 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I'd draft a safety
FA Dwight Smith would be an upgrade over Carter and also contribute to special teams. If we don't sign Smith or someone similar, I think we should draft a safety in the late rounds. Safeties are good athletes for coverage teams and thats where one or two of our late picks should be directed. Rossum was officially on the roster as a CB so there might be room to add a real defensive back without upsetting the positional numbers.
by steeler lifer on
Feb 25, 2008 9:22 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Wait...
"He comes from a great football program."
You didn't call Syracuse a 'great football program' did you?
by Romain El 82 on
Feb 25, 2008 10:35 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
A. Smith
by Chicago Steeler on
Feb 26, 2008 10:39 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
we could
by TheMostViolentTeam on
Feb 26, 2008 2:13 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
not a bad idea
by cgolden on
Feb 26, 2008 5:10 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Clark
by RickVa on
Feb 26, 2008 4:50 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
actually
by TheMostViolentTeam on
Feb 26, 2008 5:54 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
got it
by TheMostViolentTeam on
Feb 26, 2008 6:44 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Townsend as a Safety
by cgolden on
Feb 27, 2008 8:24 AM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs









