Greetings All,

I'm more than a little surprised that there is no fan fallout and second-guessing regarding Ben's injury on this site.  I guess no one wants to look like they aren't 100% loyal but I think there is some room for debate if nothing else.

Did Ben have to play?  If so, how much?  Who else had to play, who should sit?

Rothlisberger, Ward, Harrison, Clark, and probably Miller needed rest the most.   Parker needed a few touches but Moore is their most valuable RB at this point.  Moore sits earliest then Parker.  I think Parker looked good for 2 reasons - the Browns defense and the fact he has not gotten used much lately - he's recovering still and is fresh. He may even play really well in the coming weeks but I don't think he has more than 20 or so plays in him full speed.  He won't be fully recovered until next year.

In Tomlin's defense - you want the guys sharp.  We all get that.  However, who is the one guy you can't lose?  The starting QB.  No coach is going to get fired for sitting the starter in a meaningless game but coaches do get fired when bad things happen.  If management believes the coach used poor judgment, he can be held responsible for the decision.  Now, I don't think Tomlin is getting fired in 2009 no matter what.  But, how is the decision to play Roethlisburger going to look if Ben throws 3 picks and the Steelers lose?

My contention is that Ben has not been the same since his motorcycle accident.  He is still good but seems more indecisive and shows some real strange decision-making at times.  It takes years to recover from brain trauma.  Big Ben has sustained numerous concussions in football and one big one from the accident.  The guy is standing on the edge of a cliff now.  One more fall in the coming weeks  and he may be really damaged.  Do I want this to be true - NO. 

I believe one quarter was the limit if the coach felt he had to play at all.  The guy has been beaten up for two full seasons and the last half of this season has been no cake-walk.  If anyone needed to sit down and recover for two weeks it was Ben.  Harrison didn't play and for good reason.  Roethlisberger can turn into Roethlisbungle at any time.  If he plays poorly in the first playoff game, what is going to be the first question asked after the game?

All - I reposted this after I typed it out in a reply. Forgive the rant...

Unwatchable.......almost
Is anyone else frustrated or better put confused as to what the coaching staff is doing? I'm not saying I'm smarter than them but how do you:

a) Come out throwing the ball in the first half in bad weather and with a QB who has a bum shoulder?

b) Continue throwing the ball in the first half even though it is generally fruitless and Parker is running well?

c) Allow a one dimensional Jacksonville offense to look so good?

d) With the game on the line allow a draw play for what 15 - 20 yards on 3rd and 9 after giving up a first down on the previous 3rd down and long with the exact same play call?

e) Given your scout films and knowledge of their strengths and coach's demeanor, how can they run the ball down your throat the entire game? It looked like the Steelers were in a loose alignment or nickel package on that last key 3rd down play.  I believe they had already thrown the INT on the last series.... Del Rio is not going to throw the game away... they are going to run it, kick it and play defense... aren't they??  Who are you playing?  It isn't the Colts, Pats, or Bengals for Crissakes... How can you be surprised they are going to run the ball until you stop it !!!!

Agghhh..... I have never come so close to walking away from a game at halftime.. never. And then to look so lame at the end to lose after a valiant comeback. The offense actually helping the defense at the end - of course the defense had to gift-wrap a TD for them but they did tie the game.

My two cents after observing this coaching staff all year:

Arians - Out.  Play calling is bizarre.  One play does not set up the other for long stretches of the game.  That C Wilson pass was beautiful but if it doesn't work how insane is Steeler Nation afterwards?! If not - serious Come to Jesus meeting after the season... not sure if that will work. Play calling is an artform not a degree or certificate program. Some people have it some don't. I'm not seeing it.

Le Beau - Tomlin needs to take control more, perhaps even now. I know they are not the same dominant unit they were 1-2 seasons ago. Forget the stats, the rankings.. did you win and play well defensively against the good teams you played? I would say in many respects - No. Tomlin is a defensive guy and he can't be happy that they were run over, especially when it counted most. I think the scheme is too cute and is over-thought at times. Two examples: PATS: Throwing it all the time, they know where your players are going to be when you call your favorite stuff. Do something different to get a pass rush - most of your DB's are not cover guys. JAGS - They are a running team, what's with all the light in the ass players on the field at the same time? If that's all you have, send 6 or 7 guys on a run blitz. Better yet, get some more tonnage up front with guys who have a hand in the dirt.

Special Teams: Start over. Sepulveda has talent and is going to be fine, had a good game yesterday. Rossum is a has-been and is not worth giving opportunities when big plays are needed. I know they don't want Holmes to get hurt but he would be a game-breaker in the return game. Coverage units are generally poor even though Reed is a good kicker.

O LINE: Re-sign Faneca now, right now. He will forgive if you give him the money - and he deserves it. Draft and trade for help here before anywhere else. The O Line is the football team - without it you can't score, without possessing the ball all defenses wear out. There is no more important unit on the team. CB would be the next spot.

Now is the time for Tomlin to assert himself and put his mark on this team. He can make changes because they need to be made in order to get into the playoffs and because the weaknesses are apparent. He has plenty of cover. No player or fan revolt will come from his tweaking of the existing systems/personalities. Make some adjustments and get it going as best you can leading into the playoffs. I could be wrong but his sideline demeanor indicates that he is along for the ride during the game. 4th down, fake punt/FG, onside kick - those are universally the HC's discretion. Those are not things which make winning teams although they may help win one game. The HC's influence and fingerprints must be upon the whole team. I only see Arians' and LeBeau's at this point scheme-wise. They are tied with the Browns - a team they themselves beat twice. They should not be struggling to beat them in the overall record for the division title. Their respective strength of schedule rating is almost identical, both playing 10 teams with over .500 records in 2006 and 5 2006 playoff teams. What I'm saying here is that the Steelers and Browns are the same, and that's not good.

"Franz" in NoCal