clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

5 Burning Questions on the Pittsburgh Steelers 2013 Season

Does the Steelers 2013 experience tell us that offensive line depth is a "must have" or a "nice to have?" Why don't more Steelers Rookie of the year winners become future Steelers MVPs? If you're Kevin Colbert, what would you change? Answer these and other Burning Questions on the 2013 Pittsburgh Steelers

Ben and Todd both SWEAR they got on the same page in 2013. Of course the also said that in 2012....
Ben and Todd both SWEAR they got on the same page in 2013. Of course the also said that in 2012....
Karl Walter

As we now know, the Steelers defeated the Browns to finish 8-8, yet NFL officiating errors prevented a playoff run that BTSC was set to call the "Steelers Zombie Apocalypse." The Pittsburgh Steelers face a lot of difficult decisions this off season, but before that, BTSC looks back and asks Steelers Nation to answer 5 Burning Questions on 2013.

1. In the final pre-season issue of Steelers Digest, Bob Labriola used the term "working without a safety net" twice to describe the Steelers offensive line depth. Of course 8 plays into the season, disaster struck and Maurkice Pouncey was lost. Yet, Steelers were able to stabilize their line with in-season replacements and found themselves in the playoff hunt until late in the afternoon on week 17.

Does the Steelers 2013 experience on offensive line tell you that offensive line depth is "Must Have" or simply a "Nice to Have?"

2. Season end awards saw Antonio Brown take the team MVP while Le'Veon Bell was named the Joe Greene rookie of the year. Neither choice was a surprise, yet it does suggest and interesting comparison. Here are the award winners since the Steelers began issuing both in 1984:

Year Team MVP Rookie of the Year
1984 John Stallworth (WR) (1) Louis Lipps (WR)
1985 (1) Louis Lipps (WR) Harry Newsome (P)
1986 Brian Hinkle (LB) Anthony Henton (LB)
1987 Mike Merriweather (LB) Delton Hall (CB)
1988 David Little (LB); Rod Woodson (CB) Warren Williams (RB)
1989 (1) Louis Lipps (WR) Carnell Lake (S)
1990 Rod Woodson (CB) Eric Green (TE)
1991 Greg Lloyd (LB) Adrian Cooper (TE)
1992 Barry Foster (RB) Darren Perry (S)
1993 Rod Woodson (CB) Chad Brown (LB)
1994 Greg Lloyd (LB) Bam Morris (RB)
1995 Neil O'Donnell (QB) (2) Kordell Stewart (Slash)
1996 Jerome Bettis (RB) Jon Witman (FB)
1997 Jerome Bettis (RB) Chad Scott (CB)
1998 Levon Kirkland (LB) Alan Faneca (G)
1999 Levon Kirkland (LB) Troy Edwards (WR)
2000 Jerome Bettis (RB) Dan Kreider (FB)
2001 (2) Kordell Stewart (QB) Kendrell Bell (LB)
2002 Joey Porter (LB); Hines Ward (WR) Kendall Simmons (G)
2003 Hines Ward (WR) (3) Troy Polamalu (S)
2004 James Farrior (LB) (4) Ben Roethlisberger (QB)
2005 Casey Hampton (NT), Hines Ward (WR) (5) Heath Miller (TE)
2006 Willie Parker (RB) Santonio Holmes (WR)
2007 James Harrison (LB) Daniel Sepulveda (P)
2008 James Harrison (LB) Patrick Bailey (LB)
2009 (4) Ben Roethlisberger (QB) Mike Wallace (WR)
2010 (3) Troy Polamalu (S) Maurkice Pouncey (C)
2011 Antonio Brown (WR) Marcus Gilbert (OT)
2012 (5) Heath Miller (TE) Mike Adams (OT)
2013 Antonio Brown (WR) Le'Veon Bell (RB)

Seeing the two lists side-by-side raises and obvious question. Why is it that only five players (numbered above) who won the rookie of the year award later when on to win the team MVP award? What does this say about the nuances of player development?

3. One of the biggest decisions the Steelers faced in 2013 was whether to honor the New England Patriots 1 year restricted free agency offer to Emmanuel Sanders. Faced with a similar choice in 1993, the Steelers opted to make the opposite decision and keep Sanders.

Now, with the beauty and benefit of 20/20 hindsight, do you think the Steelers could have taken someone with that 91st pick that would have pushed 8-8 to 9-7. Here's a link to the 2013 draft results for your reference.

4. You are Kevin Colbert. You get one 2013 personnel decision "do over." What is your choice?

5. Todd Haley became a lighting rod during the Steelers 0-4 start and even as recently as the Miami game Roethlisberger was forced to say that perceived criticism of his offensive coordinator came from quotes "taken out of context." Yet the offense was markedly improved late in the season, and Roethlisberger claim's he's comfortable with Haley...

...Of course in 2012 Roethlisberger and Haley proclaimed their love for one another, only to be outed by Bob Labriola at season's end.

Whose story are you buying this year?

There you go folks. Have at it for our final installment of the 5 Burning Questions for the 2013 Season.

We'll do additional 5 Burnings during the off season as often as they can be made relevant. In closing out 2013, however, I'd like to once again thank everyone who took time to answer questions this year, as coming up with compelling questions was a much bigger challenge in 2013 than in previous seasons, so my appreciation is heart felt. Thanks to all!